Author

Topic: Viabtc Cloud Mining, read before you buy. (Read 397 times)

copper member
Activity: 1988
Merit: 905
Part of AOBT - English Translator to Indonesia
August 01, 2023, 08:44:29 PM
#21
I am of the opinion that every cloud mining should be labelled as a scam. No exception

But for no reason, there are a lot of people who still fall into this program.

Unfortunately, just like in casinos where MOST people end up losing money given the statistical advantages the house has over the players, you can't label them as scammers, the same thing is true for cloud mining that is offered by "legit" companies like Bitmain, in other words, you could sue all those fake cloud mining companies who simply take your money and run, but I doubt you can do the same with Bitmain, Viabtc, any other company that doesn't just run away with your money.

They simply are counting on people's ignorance and greed, they know the math very well, and they know how to make a profit at the expense of those who don't, do I advice everyone against it? yes, can I say without a doubt that Binance, Viabtc, and all those folks are scammers? would be hard to prove in a court to be honest.

It is kinda grey scam hahaha I just recently saw Binance Cloud Mining and am interested to see but after doing math with stompix at the end if we subscribe to Binance cloud mining today we will get razor-thin profit


I just know after you guys tell me, and yes it actually profitable but razor-thin margin and we need 3 months to get return of investment for now it is not worth it too, it is better to buy with DCA technique and maybe the return will more than this.

* Hashrate Fee 0.02 + Electricity Fee 0.0531 = 0.0731/USD/T/Day (the historical output 0.0776/USD/T/Day - Fee 0.0731/USD/T/Day = 0.0045/USD/T/Day

I wonder where the 23% comes from



So right now it's 0.0777 in profit with 0.0200+0.0531, a bit better than yours but still, you get
0.0731 in expenses and 0.0777 in revenue, which is 0.0041 in profit, so a 5% margin, nowhere near a 23% stated there.
Taking into account the current mempool spam that drove the fees up and you get a 5% bonus from this which might not be there tomorrow the profit is paper thin, one tiny dif increase and you're losing coins.
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
I am of the opinion that every cloud mining should be labelled as a scam. No exception

Unfortunately, just like in casinos where MOST people end up losing money given the statistical advantages the house has over the players, you can't label them as scammers, the same thing is true for cloud mining that is offered by "legit" companies like Bitmain, in other words, you could sue all those fake cloud mining companies who simply take your money and run, but I doubt you can do the same with Bitmain, Viabtc, any other company that doesn't just run away with your money.

They simply are counting on people's ignorance and greed, they know the math very well, and they know how to make a profit at the expense of those who don't, do I advice everyone against it? yes, can I say without a doubt that Binance, Viabtc, and all those folks are scammers? would be hard to prove in a court to be honest.
legendary
Activity: 3248
Merit: 3098
TL:DR, Cloud mining assuming it isn't a straightforward scam, is most likely going to make you lose money, it's extremely rare for the events that make it profitable to actually happen, and even if and ones they happen, you are very likely to not benefit from them.

I am of the opinion that every cloud mining should be labelled as a scam. No exceptions. So far, I have not seen cloud mining profitable for users, only for owners.
About 10 years ago, I saw it for the first time on the cex.io exchange, I even bought that Ghash of theirs, which really brought some kind of income. But everything ended up like what you wrote in the table. With no real profit, they are hanging on the edge of breaking even. It's a good thing that they stopped doing it themselves without an exit scam.

I really don't know why Binance starts something like this, big red flag for them because of that.
hero member
Activity: 854
Merit: 772
Watch Bitcoin Documentary - https://t.ly/v0Nim
The only case where Cloud Mining companies are scam is when they offer unexpected returns and run away after some months. These companies are scam but companies that offer you certain conditions with responsibility, aren't scammers. These cloud mining contracts look like when banks offer you deposit interest but inflation is going to be far greater than deposit interest.
When an investment is presented to an individual, it mainly aims to increase the return on investment, and then it is assumed that the probability of profit and loss is 50%, or at least clarify that this is a high-risk investment, while leaving the choice to the user.

What happens here is that they give the user part of the truth or the part in which he is supposed to make profits without explaining the whole idea, the type of risk and the possibility of profit, and then the user deposits the money and cannot know that he is losing it until after a while.

If Binance explained its model exactly as mikeywith did, would it invest in it?
Just go with an investor and tell him: Hey, I want to open a Cafe, would you give me 100k pound? This is a great business idea, it will bring us a lot of profit, we will sell £1 Cappuccino for £5 and so on.
What do you think, will any investor accept that offer? Or don't you think that such a dumb people aren't looking for investors and offer them such a dumb proposals without any calculation and actual idea of how are they going to do the things?
No, investors see these kind of people very often, it depends on investor, whether he/she accepts such a bad offer or not. This cloud mining offer is no different, they offer people this option and terms, it depends on people whether they find this offer acceptable or not. I wouldn't accept it but some people think they are super smart by finding out a person who does all the staff to rent a money printing machine on them instead of printing money for themselves.
sr. member
Activity: 406
Merit: 443
It has been three years for this topic, thought it would be a good idea to refresh it now that Binance is attempting the same indirect "scam" of cloud mining. I will quote myself here for all the realistic and possible scenarios that you will likely face if you buy cloud mining packages from Binance.

And there is another indirect scam, as you gain them additional power. Binance uses the customers’ money, does not give them good profits, and uses that money to increase its control over altcoins and cryptocurrencies as a whole.

The only case where Cloud Mining companies are scam is when they offer unexpected returns and run away after some months. These companies are scam but companies that offer you certain conditions with responsibility, aren't scammers. These cloud mining contracts look like when banks offer you deposit interest but inflation is going to be far greater than deposit interest.
When an investment is presented to an individual, it mainly aims to increase the return on investment, and then it is assumed that the probability of profit and loss is 50%, or at least clarify that this is a high-risk investment, while leaving the choice to the user.

What happens here is that they give the user part of the truth or the part in which he is supposed to make profits without explaining the whole idea, the type of risk and the possibility of profit, and then the user deposits the money and cannot know that he is losing it until after a while.

If Binance explained its model exactly as mikeywith did, would it invest in it?
hero member
Activity: 854
Merit: 772
Watch Bitcoin Documentary - https://t.ly/v0Nim
@mikeywith. Were there mining contracts that made some small holders some profit? I am sorry for my bias against the service, however, I have only seen many complaints from users and the contract issuers stop the service.

There is a huge difference between a straight-out scam service and legit services that you are unlikely to profit from in most cases, 99% of these cloud mining services are actually scammers, so I am not surprised that you are biased, in fact, I am perhaps more biased than you are.

With that being said, there are indeed a few legitimate cloud mining contracts, for an example bitdeer aka Bitmain "partners" are legit, even this very service we are discussing is actually legit, but whether you make money from it or not is a whole different story..
The only case where Cloud Mining companies are scam is when they offer unexpected returns and run away after some months. These companies are scam but companies that offer you certain conditions with responsibility, aren't scammers. These cloud mining contracts look like when banks offer you deposit interest but inflation is going to be far greater than deposit interest.
Even Binance offers cloud mining, this doesn't mean that they are gonna steal your money and do exist scam. I don't want to disrespect anyone but absolutely everyone who buys cloud mining contract and then complains about loses, is a very stupid person. Just think about it twice: Company builds a building where it's going to host miners, then buys these miners, negotiates with government about electricity prices, hosts them, then hires developers and invests money to create a platform where you'll be able to buy their cloud mining contract and people still think that they do this to make your richer? Definitely mining companies are the only ones who benefit from this contract, otherwise they would mine on their own. I don't really know why is it so hard to understand. Would you work every day to feed other lazy people? Definitely no unless you are getting greater benefit from this. Think about this guys!
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
It has been three years for this topic, thought it would be a good idea to refresh it now that Binance is attempting the same indirect "scam" of cloud mining. I will quote myself here for all the realistic and possible scenarios that you will likely face if you buy cloud mining packages from Binance.

Cost per th for 180 = 13.1580$
Estimated profit with both difficulty and price staying flat: 12.6$

Scenario 1: both stay flat > you lose
Scenario 2: difficulty gues up while price goes down  > You lose more
Scenario 3: difficulty stays flat while price goes up > You win (only if prices increases more than 4.25% for the average of the 180 days)

Scenario 4: difficulty goes down while price goes up > you win more

so in 2/4 you could win, although the conditions needed to win are less likely to happen, especially the difficulty part, it just doesn't go down, so it's more like 30% chances of winning at best.

All the above is in respect to fiat, let's run the same thing in respect to BTC.


Cost per th for 180 = 0.0004464BTC
Estimated profit with both difficulty and price staying flat: 0.0004274 BTC

Scenario 1: both stay flat > You lose
Scenario 2: difficulty goes up while price goes down  > You lose more
Scenario 3: difficulty stays flat while price goes up > You lose
Scenario 4: difficulty goes down while price goes up > you win (only if difficulty drops more than 4.25% for the average of the 180 days)

1/4 you could win, but only if difficulty drops more than 4.25%, is that impossible? nop, is it very unlikely? indeed?

So you are going to need to be very , very lucky to end up winning anything out of this.

I think Binance could be setting up a trap for the naive folks with its 180 days packages, anyone who buys the package =<180 to the halving will certainly end up losing despite any condition.


Oh ya, not to mention that in the rare event of difficulty dropping and packages start actually yielding profits, Bitmain could just end the deal as that isn't against the agreement you have to sign. Cheesy

TL:DR, Cloud mining assuming it isn't a straightforward scam, is most likely going to make you lose money, it's extremely rare for the events that make it profitable to actually happen, and even if and ones they happen, you are very likely to not benefit from them.

hero member
Activity: 952
Merit: 513
December 04, 2020, 02:32:04 AM
#14
Never take cloud mining contracts by their "face value" expiry date. You will be committing a grave mistake since increased difficulty will ultimately terminate your contract beforehand. Especially with 6% fees which is absolutely crazy even for cloud mining maintenance, you are likely to see your ViaBTC contract last less than a year less than 3.

Cloud mining is really a no brained from the provider's perspective since they not only get a windfall at the start, but also have a risk free stream of revenue from maintenance fees afterwards (assuming that they are mining in the first place).

Don't believe in the hype just because these contracts are 'selling fast' or whatnot. Seeking out passive income is a phase that all bitcoiners go through and they will all come across cloud mining at some stage, but there is a reason why the consensus in the community is that these services must be avoided at all costs.
legendary
Activity: 2828
Merit: 6108
Jambler.io
November 29, 2020, 04:53:40 PM
#13
Well, you haven't shown up in the difficulty thread for a while, I hope being wrong most of that isn't the reason  Grin,

Not at all, I've not stopped throwing around predictions some even more awesome than that and I will for certain not disappear just because I was wrong the 385th time  Grin.
I'm still reading the topic whenever it pops up in my topic list but, to be completely honest, I have one big ZERO to add to the conversation lately, no drama from China, no drama from Bitmain, nothing that would reduce or increase the current price influation on the hashrate, it's like there is nothing that can alter the current course.

Bottom line, nothing constructive to add.....what should I do:) Grin

but I believe we all agree that in 3 years difficulty will most certainly go above 43%, the only people who would bet against this are Viabtc mining contracts buyers.

It's a bit weird, probably this would have worked during the spring, people were more pessimistic at that time, the whole virus/lockdown/dump, but right now that everything is going a lot better you're betting against the price going up and dragging the hashrate by a not so impressive margin over 3 years. One must be really bearish to do the math and still buy those.
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
November 29, 2020, 03:35:57 PM
#12
Bitdeer is obviously a better option, with Viabtc contract you are stuck with 4% PPS+ mining fees which are the highest in the market, so without even looking into the details of bitdeer contracts, it's safe to assume that it's indeed better, but better doesn't mean good enough just so that people don't think I am saying Bitdeer contracts are good. Grin

Quote
I was going to say something along the lines but then I remembered one of my predictions...so better shut up  Grin
Btw, I am more than 100% off on that difficulty rise prediction, closing on 2.5  Cry Cry

Well, you haven't shown up in the difficulty thread for a while, I hope being wrong most of that isn't the reason  Grin, honestly, most of us are more wrong than right when it comes to predicting the future, but I believe we all agree that in 3 years difficulty will most certainly go above 43%, the only people who would bet against this are Viabtc mining contracts buyers.
legendary
Activity: 2828
Merit: 6108
Jambler.io
November 29, 2020, 09:31:28 AM
#11
Hihi, they are trying to get piece of the pie from bitdeer?  Grin

46$ for 1125 days you pay 0.04 per TH/day,  Bitdeer rents it for $0.037, electricity costs are 0.052$ vs $0.054 at the end of the day bitdeer wins by the dust of a cent. But I can't find out if bitdeer takes some extra fees and how much are those worth.

But the critical difference is the duration of the plan from viabtc goes for 3 years, who knows how much a TH would bring you at that time and if the electricity cost would not topple that, bitdeer has a shorter interval 180 days, it's more likely we will not see some revolutionary more efficient gear coming up and getting delivered in this period, over 3 years, it's a different story. It's like these black Friday VPN deals, get 60% for a 5-year plan, who knows what will be in3  not 5 years, I would rather go with one-third of the discount for a 12 months period.
As Mikey said, they don't even need to scam you out of this

I don't suppose you remember how many they had available when you looked into this, not that we should trust the numbers but right now they claim "Left 16601 contracts" $700k waiting for investors.

the only way for you to win is if bitcoin difficulty doesn't go up beyond 43% until the expiration date, while that isn't impossible I am willing to bet the horse against it.

I was going to say something along the lines but then I remembered one of my predictions...so better shut up  Grin
Btw, I am more than 100% off on that difficulty rise prediction, closing on 2.5  Cry Cry
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
November 28, 2020, 08:07:14 PM
#10
Well I do not think all of them are scams, however, that most of them became scams because the contract issuers cannot pay out the terms. The risk is always on the contract buyer. That is where my bias comes from.  

You make perfect sense, but you can't generalize, when a company like Viabtc does this, it's a whole different story, the chances that they will scam under any circumstances are slim to nothing, it's the only reason why I wrote this topic specifically on Viabtc cloud mining and not the other hundreds of cloud mining scams, most of us know those are either scammers or going to be scammers really soon so there is no point in talking about them, however, the situation here is different.

Viabtc has close to 10% of the network hashrate, with a simple fast semi-accurate calculation we can see that they mine 12 blocks a day, say the average block reward is 7btc, so that is a total of more than 30,000 BTC a year, their cut is 4% and that is 1,226BTC, that is close to $22,000,000 a year, they have other services such as currency exchange, they charge withdrawal fees for certain amounts.

Long story short: Viabtc make enough profit which eliminates the incentive of scamming a few newbies on cloud mining contracts, and they are being quite honest here, they told you that they don't have the mining gears at all  Grin

Quote
Sufficient Hashrate - There'll be no running short of hashrate since it doesn't count on the facilities


So there will be no broken mining gears, no fire, there will be nothing to stop them from supplying the "artificial" hashrate that you pay for, they don't want to scam you, they just want to borrow money from you and give it back to you with negative interest.  Cheesy
legendary
Activity: 2926
Merit: 1440
November 28, 2020, 01:57:25 AM
#9
@mikeywith. Were there mining contracts that made some small holders some profit? I am sorry for my bias against the service, however, I have only seen many complaints from users and the contract issuers stop the service.

There is a huge difference between a straight-out scam service and legit services that you are unlikely to profit from in most cases, 99% of these cloud mining services are actually scammers, so I am not surprised that you are biased, in fact, I am perhaps more biased than you are.

With that being said, there are indeed a few legitimate cloud mining contracts, for an example bitdeer aka Bitmain "partners" are legit, even this very service we are discussing is actually legit, but whether you make money from it or not is a whole different story.

Quote
What are your personal experiences on mining contracts and what were the profitable contracts?

I own mining gears, I never actually bought a cloud mining contract, although theoretically cloud mining can work well for both buyers and sellers if the terms and prices are right, but just like gambling the casino has the odds on its side and you are more likely to lose than to win at any given time, the way these legit cloud services play the game is by making you bet against the things that have the highest probability of happening like difficulty going up while gear prices go down.

Well I do not think all of them are scams, however, that most of them became scams because the contract issuers cannot pay out the terms. The risk is always on the contract buyer. That is where my bias comes from.  
mk4
legendary
Activity: 2716
Merit: 3817
🪸 NotYourKeys.org 🪸
November 28, 2020, 12:05:42 AM
#8
Also, if the miners behind Viabtc were profitable, they certainly would not sell contracts. If this was not a scam, they want the contract holders to be the holders of risk hehehe.

We could make the argument that them selling contracts could probably mean that they could expand their business a lot faster(by being able to get more machines and data centers) due to the increased cash flow.

But still, it doesn't change the fact that cloud mining is a bad investment.
hero member
Activity: 2198
Merit: 847
November 27, 2020, 03:22:19 PM
#7
This is what I wanted to write, thank you for making things brighter for society. It's sad but people don't ask this question to themselves: Why mining company offers cloud mining when they can mine for themselves?
Personally, I look at cloud mining as a mechanism that lessens the risks for the mining company. There are high chances that you'll end up without the profit or maybe (but a lower chance) to end up with profit but in first case, mining company benefits better than you and on the second case, mining company gets more profit than you. In any way, it's a double win and not serious loss for the mining company.
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
November 27, 2020, 11:31:31 AM
#6
@mikeywith. Were there mining contracts that made some small holders some profit? I am sorry for my bias against the service, however, I have only seen many complaints from users and the contract issuers stop the service.

There is a huge difference between a straight-out scam service and legit services that you are unlikely to profit from in most cases, 99% of these cloud mining services are actually scammers, so I am not surprised that you are biased, in fact, I am perhaps more biased than you are.

With that being said, there are indeed a few legitimate cloud mining contracts, for an example bitdeer aka Bitmain "partners" are legit, even this very service we are discussing is actually legit, but whether you make money from it or not is a whole different story.

Quote
What are your personal experiences on mining contracts and what were the profitable contracts?

I own mining gears, I never actually bought a cloud mining contract, although theoretically cloud mining can work well for both buyers and sellers if the terms and prices are right, but just like gambling the casino has the odds on its side and you are more likely to lose than to win at any given time, the way these legit cloud services play the game is by making you bet against the things that have the highest probability of happening like difficulty going up while gear prices go down.
legendary
Activity: 2926
Merit: 1440
November 26, 2020, 11:01:24 PM
#5
@mikeywith. Were there mining contracts that made some small holders some profit? I am sorry for my bias against the service, however, I have only seen many complaints from users and the contract issuers stop the service.

What are your personal experiences on mining contracts and what were the profitable contracts?
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
November 26, 2020, 02:31:19 AM
#4
So they collect bitcoin that they trade or invest in money making vehicles then they just give a fraction of the profit to their gullible customers?

Well technically, you pay $107.07 in order to make $153.45 in three years, so that is about 43% profit or 14% a year which does seem like "better than the bank", but the trick here is that they will pay you in BTC and the only way for you to win is if bitcoin difficulty doesn't go up beyond 43% until the expiration date, while that isn't impossible I am willing to bet the horse against it.

Also, if the miners behind Viabtc were profitable, they certainly would not sell contracts. If this was not a scam

Viabtc is one of the largest mining pools, they make a fortune so it's highly unlikely that they will scam, and by scam I mean take investors' money and flee the country.

Quote
they want the contract holders to be the holders of risk hehehe.

mining contracts are meant to be this way, essentially there is nothing wrong with cloud-mining, someone has the mining gears but isn't willing to take the risk, you have the money and willing to take the risk, if mining gets more profitable than holding you win, and the opposite is also correct so it's more like a 50/50 chance, but a three-year contract at these prices is more like 70% Viabtc 30% investors.



legendary
Activity: 2926
Merit: 1440
November 26, 2020, 12:08:43 AM
#3
Also, if the miners behind Viabtc were profitable, they certainly would not sell contracts. If this was not a scam, they want the contract holders to be the holders of risk hehehe.
sr. member
Activity: 1526
Merit: 412
November 25, 2020, 11:59:08 PM
#2
$46.38 in three years [1.29 per month] assuming the rate will be constant, nice! hehe.

So they collect bitcoin that they trade or invest in money making vehicles then they just give a fraction of the profit to their gullible customers? Sounds familiar? Yes, that's like a bank at work.

Are they even allowed to do this? I mean any business that gets money from the public with a promise of return should be licensed correct?
legendary
Activity: 2170
Merit: 6279
be constructive or S.T.F.U
November 25, 2020, 10:49:05 PM
#1

Just like how things go with every bull-run, Viabtc started to advertise their cloud mining plans that most newbies will think of as free easy money, while Viabtc isn't exactly scammers the way they "and most other cloud mining providers" present their mining plans are misleading.


Here is an example of one of the contracts

Quote
S19 contract
Unit = 1TH per contract
Price: $45.99
Fees: 6%
Power cost: 6 cents per KwH
Power: 36W/contract
Effective Date :Dec 1, 2020
End date: Dec 31,2023

At first look, you might think it's a great deal but let's run the numbers:

You pay $45.99+$2.76 for fees +  0.05184$ daily for power, since the contract is 1125 days (Maybe off by a day or two) you will pay $58.32 for power, so the total will be 58.32+45.99+2.76= $107.07

The above calculation assumes that the 6% fees are paid on the contract price and not the total amount, so you could end up paying more.

Right now 1TH makes $0.1364 so that will be $153.45 in 1125 days, but this is the "all sunshine and rainbows" scenario which assumes the difficulty and price will stay flat, this might work for someone who can't buy bitcoin directly for whatever reason, but other than that and while knowing that the difficulty will go up without a doubt then this is a terrible deal IMO, you might think that price is subject to go up to as well, well then just buy BTC instead of getting stuck in a mining contract for 3 years.

Another interesting point is that it doesn't seem like Viabtc actually own any mining gears

Quote from:  www.Viabtc.com
Sufficient Hashrate - There'll be no running short of hashrate since it doesn't count on the facilities
=
You will also be forced to mine to their pool with only PPS+ method, which proves that they don't actually own the mining gears they selling the contract for, what they doing is collecting your BTC in a lump sum only to give it back to you in pieces.

Jump to: