Author

Topic: What happens to the price of gold if 300 tons are dumped on the market? (Read 2301 times)

legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1865
Its not just rarity that counts but liquidity.

If you had a large stack of osmium or rhodium who could you sell it too?

You could shift kg's of gold with little effort.



I bolded your initial statement, yes, you are correct. 

But, it would be rather hard to even get a large stack of osmium...

Rhodium is likely liquid even for large stacks, but gold of course is best for liquidity, no one is arguing that.

I was trying to clarify and put into context the points made above by neurotypical and bryant.coleman.
legendary
Activity: 2254
Merit: 1043
Its not just rarity that counts but liquidity.

If you had a large stack of osmium or rhodium who could you sell it too?

You could shift kg's of gold with little effort.
legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1865
...

bryant.coleman

I am a collector of precious metals, and in my research (not just the wikipedia links below), I am pretty sure that OSMIUM is the rarest stable element (astatine is the rarest of all, but radioactive).  See below links:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osmium

"Osmium is the least abundant stable element in Earth's crust with an average mass fraction of 50 parts per trillion in the continental crust.[41]"

Although this chart from another article at wiki says different (Ir rarer than Os):




Wiki's article on rhodium:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhodium

"Rhodium is one of the rarest elements in the Earth's crust, of which it comprises an estimated 0.0002 parts per million (2 × 10−10).[24] Its rarity affects its price, and thus its usage in commercial applications."

Rhodium has fairly abundant uses, osmium almost none (just a few minor applications).
hero member
Activity: 854
Merit: 1009
JAYCE DESIGNS - http://bit.ly/1tmgIwK
2) Bitcoin is waaaay more scarce than Gold, there fore is hundreds of times more valuable than it (considering it's better money in every single aspect to boot).

Not a very intelligent argument. Rhodium is the rarest metal on earth. The amount of Rhodium, which is present on the earth's surface is just 1/100th of that of gold. But that doesn't make Rhodium more expensive than gold. The price of Rhodium is even lower than that of gold. Scarcity doesn't count, as long as the demand is not there.

Rhodium is near the price of gold, but it looks like silver from the outside, yet the price of silver is way more cheaper than rhodium:

RHODIUM:   750$ / ounce


SILVER:     15$/ ounce


The valuation is totally subjective, as even they are similar outlook, the price differs 50x  (even though silver is shinyer yet still cheaper)
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
2) Bitcoin is waaaay more scarce than Gold, there fore is hundreds of times more valuable than it (considering it's better money in every single aspect to boot).

Not a very intelligent argument. Rhodium is the rarest metal on earth. The amount of Rhodium, which is present on the earth's surface is just 1/100th of that of gold. But that doesn't make Rhodium more expensive than gold. The price of Rhodium is even lower than that of gold. Scarcity doesn't count, as long as the demand is not there.
legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1865
It can create short term drops because news headlines always makes people have kneejerk reactions. Like another another member has pointed out, 300 tons is not as much as it seems.

300 tonnes is still a very significant amount. The total annual mine production of gold as of now is around 3,300 tonnes. So this Nazi gold represents more than one month output from all of the gold mines in the world. And another important point to note is that, before the discovery of this gold the Polish gold reserves amounted to just 102.9 tonnes.


Indeed, 300 tonnes is a large amount of gold.

But, since the FLOW of (physical) gold is eventually more relevant to price movement, my best guess is that the 300 tonnes will not affect the price much.

FLOW of gold also suggests that even a sharp drop in mine production would not affect prices much (read earlier (2009 on) posts of knowledgeable gold analyst FOFOA: fofoa.blogspot.com (very long pieces!) for more details).

IMO (and FOFOA's), the big gold price moves up will be when people want GOLD, not the paper receipts of various kinds (the GLD, gold futures, gold lending, other derivatives).  Price moves will not be dramatic when the occasional 300 tonnes of gold are found in Poland or when some mines shut down or big gold discoveries are made.

It's when people "stand for delivery" that the shock waves will hit...

*   *   *

Here is Sudan suggesting that a recent "discovery" by a Russian miner of "46,000 tonnes" of gold ("worth $1.7 TRILLION") may not be as advertised:

http://www.sudantribune.com/spip.php?article56019

That purported discovery did create some waves when first announced...
legendary
Activity: 1792
Merit: 1283
I doubt the price would even fluctuate due to that kind of amount being dumped.
More gold is mined every year, I'm guessing the amount produced every year differs a couple of hundred tons, depending on different factors.
hero member
Activity: 672
Merit: 503
The supply of gold is way bigger than a lot of suspected to be, so this means 2 things:
1) The impact on gold's price will not be that much of a catastrophe
2) Bitcoin is waaaay more scarce than Gold, there fore is hundreds of times more valuable than it (considering it's better money in every single aspect to boot).
sr. member
Activity: 826
Merit: 263
I think it will not give an effect to gold..
hero member
Activity: 854
Merit: 1009
JAYCE DESIGNS - http://bit.ly/1tmgIwK
Let us say that the Nazi train in Poland is real, and it contains 300 tons of gold, and it is dumped.  How much would this effect the price of gold?

It would turn gold into a fiat currency  Grin

I would be more worried if the big banks and the IMF starts to unload its gold reserves, that would be the real shock.
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
It can create short term drops because news headlines always makes people have kneejerk reactions. Like another another member has pointed out, 300 tons is not as much as it seems.

300 tonnes is still a very significant amount. The total annual mine production of gold as of now is around 3,300 tonnes. So this Nazi gold represents more than one month output from all of the gold mines in the world. And another important point to note is that, before the discovery of this gold the Polish gold reserves amounted to just 102.9 tonnes.
full member
Activity: 126
Merit: 100
It can create short term drops because news headlines always makes people have kneejerk reactions. Like another another member has pointed out, 300 tons is not as much as it seems.
legendary
Activity: 1134
Merit: 1000
Let us say that the Nazi train in Poland is real, and it contains 300 tons of gold, and it is dumped.  How much would this effect the price of gold?

I think it will not be any effect. Or at least very few. A little decrease which will be temporary. The world reserves are 171,300 ton. So 300 ton are 0.175% of the total reserves. Are nothing to trouble the price.
legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1865
I also agree with other above comments that Poland would likely not dump it quickly if the 300 tonnes does exist.

There are legal issues as well. For Poland to obtain the permission to sell those gold bullion bars and diamonds, they must prove that the treasure originally belonged to them. Already the World Jewish Congress and Russia has claimed that the treasure belongs to them. IMO, Poland will not be able to sell the bullion for the next few years at least.


Yes, I would agree with your analysis.  300 tonnes is a HUGE amount of dollar volume of gold, over $10 billion (if I did my arithmetic right, feel free to check it, it's late here...).

Everybody and his mother will try to get some of that gold.  It will likely be a HUGE MESS.
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
I also agree with other above comments that Poland would likely not dump it quickly if the 300 tonnes does exist.

There are legal issues as well. For Poland to obtain the permission to sell those gold bullion bars and diamonds, they must prove that the treasure originally belonged to them. Already the World Jewish Congress and Russia has claimed that the treasure belongs to them. IMO, Poland will not be able to sell the bullion for the next few years at least.
legendary
Activity: 2940
Merit: 1865
if 300tonnes are dumped, the supply increases, the people with the increased supply would sell at a bit lower price in order to sell faster. Doing that decreases the market price slightly.

300 tonnes is not enough to create such a situation in the long term. Some 600 tonnes of gold are traded legally every month. Many times that amount is traded in the informal sector. If 300 tonnes of gold is dumped all of a sudden, then the price will remain low for a month or so, but the rates will recover once the institutional investors start mopping up the cheap gold.


That would be my take as well.  300 tonnes is very little compared to the estimated 170,000 tonnes above ground.

Sure, the price of gold could likely drop "flash-crash" style, but the Central Bank of OROBTC would likely be in there buying some.  The physical would likely be taken up rather quickly, especially by those who want LARGE amounts (FOFOA's "Giants").

I also agree with other above comments that Poland would likely not dump it quickly if the 300 tonnes of "Nazi gold" does exist.
Q7
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
I remember at one point gold price was at 1100 level. The IMF conducted sales of 200 metric tons of Gold and the indian governent saw that as an opportunity and outright bought it. Not long after that the price shot up to 1400. That happened way back in 2009
sr. member
Activity: 336
Merit: 250
300 tons of gold will just sligtly slip the price to downwards but I assume that it will soon be recover its previous position too due to the currency market demand and supply
legendary
Activity: 1540
Merit: 1000
If it were just dropped into the market it would definitely cause a prise dump, at least for awhile, but you have to remember that precious metals react a lot to inflation because even if there were that much gold put into the markets there would be a dramatic rise again because of both money printing and how fast people would want to buy it all up. I know if the price dropped low enough I'd want to buy a couple of 1kg Bars dirt cheap for myself but I think it's a bit of a pipe dream, you're more likely to be able to flood the precious metals market with asteroid mining than you are with anything you could find on a train.
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
if 300tonnes are dumped, the supply increases, the people with the increased supply would sell at a bit lower price in order to sell faster. Doing that decreases the market price slightly.

300 tonnes is not enough to create such a situation in the long term. Some 600 tonnes of gold are traded legally every month. Many times that amount is traded in the informal sector. If 300 tonnes of gold is dumped all of a sudden, then the price will remain low for a month or so, but the rates will recover once the institutional investors start mopping up the cheap gold.
legendary
Activity: 2114
Merit: 1023
Oikos.cash | Decentralized Finance on Tron
When gold is dumped like that, the rest start panic selling and the whales start buying up even more dirt cheap than what they dumped it at. This has always happened in all markets, not just gold and if peeps are stupid enough to panic sell or sell at a loss then the whales are always laughing.  Smiley
hero member
Activity: 756
Merit: 500
if 300tonnes are dumped, the supply increases, the people with the increased supply would sell at a bit lower price in order to sell faster. Doing that decreases the market price slightly.
legendary
Activity: 1582
Merit: 1064


 Potentially nothing at all as the gold price is already manipulated by the power brokers.

That is a telling image.
Crude, gold..... the greedy bankers have left no commodity untouched.
Very soon, bitcoin will be in their grasp too.
sr. member
Activity: 490
Merit: 250
Let us say that the Nazi train in Poland is real, and it contains 300 tons of gold, and it is dumped.  How much would this effect the price of gold?

I don't think that all of that gold would be instantly be dumped at once. It would probably affect the price for a couple months since it has a huge volume. But I think that Poland will actually rather store that gold than sell it.
legendary
Activity: 3808
Merit: 7912


 Potentially nothing at all as the gold price is already manipulated by the power brokers.
full member
Activity: 168
Merit: 100
if 300 tons of gold were into the market, wouldnt it not change the price.

the stock market is easily manipulated, but it has to be based on a known stock last time I checked esp insider deals etc.
legendary
Activity: 2254
Merit: 1043
If the supply is overwhelming the demand, its eventually to go down?

And as for the china`s comment, its about time they sell off u.s debt lol. There was a zerohedge article on china selling of assests in the billions.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-08-27/its-official-china-confirms-it-has-begun-liquidating-treasuries-warns-washington

But at the moment demand is overwhelming supply (real physical metal not paper promises backed by nothing)
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 100
If the supply is overwhelming the demand, its eventually to go down?

And as for the china`s comment, its about time they sell off u.s debt lol. There was a zerohedge article on china selling of assests in the billions.

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2015-08-27/its-official-china-confirms-it-has-begun-liquidating-treasuries-warns-washington
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
The real thing to watch out for is if China and Russia start dumping all their gold that they have been buying.

It is not going to happen anytime soon. Both Russia and China are looking to replace the United States treasury bonds in their Forex reserve stockpiles with gold bullion bars. China has been doing this for almost 10 years now, and Russia has joined them a few years back. They will continue dumping the bonds for the foreseeable future.
hero member
Activity: 994
Merit: 1000
I'm waiting for a huge asteroid to crash to earth that is full of gold. Now that would effect the price  Grin.

I also think that person finding the train is just a hoaxer.

hey man, I best advise you to buy a bitcoin and throw it into the cold storage, so best of luck with that whole gold asteroid crashing into earth fantasy, I'd rather wish that something like what happened in the movie fight club takes place, everybody who has ever taken a debt is declared debt free due to the loss of significant details and data. yeah, a reset on the economy system is what I pray for.
newbie
Activity: 25
Merit: 0
I'm waiting for a huge asteroid to crash to earth that is full of gold. Now that would effect the price  Grin.

I also think that person finding the train is just a hoaxer.
legendary
Activity: 1148
Merit: 1006
I think gold values will drop dramatically

I don't think the price of gold will go down dramatically just because of additional 300 tons in the market. As of the data available in the internet, in recent years approximately 2,497 tonnes of gold has been mined each year. So additional 300 tons will keep gold price just for couple of months down only but it can't bring down the gold price dramatically.
legendary
Activity: 2590
Merit: 3015
Welt Am Draht
hero member
Activity: 788
Merit: 1000
The real thing to watch out for is if China and Russia start dumping all their gold that they have been buying.
full member
Activity: 187
Merit: 100
https://bitcointester.com/
I think gold values will drop dramatically
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
3300 tones every year? how can this not affect the price? thats strange how it still has such big value

Right now, the supply-demand equilibrium is being maintained at the level of $1,080 - $1,150 per oz. If more than 3,300 tonnes of fresh gold appears on the market, then the price will go down. If there is a scarcity of supply, then the price will go up. But these effects will be temporary, unless a vary big amount (say 2,000 tonnes or 3,000 tonnes) is dumped all of a sudden.
full member
Activity: 179
Merit: 100
3300 tones every year? how can this not affect the price? thats strange how it still has such big value
legendary
Activity: 3766
Merit: 1217
I don't think that it will be having any long-lasting effect. Some 3,300 tonnes of gold are being mined annually, in addition to the thousands of tons which is recycled or traded. Perhaps, the gold price might remain depressed for a month or so. But it is not going to affect the prices in the long term. That said, I don't think that the Poles are going to dump all that gold in one go. Most likely, they are going to deposit it in the Forex reserves.
sr. member
Activity: 286
Merit: 255
Let us say that the Nazi train in Poland is real, and it contains 300 tons of gold, and it is dumped.  How much would this effect the price of gold?
Jump to: