What is the best Initial Coin Offering rating System?

suchi2591

newbie

Activity: 126

Merit: 0

Quote from: 3dchain on April 26, 2018, 02:43:41 AM

There are multiple rating System for Initial Coin Offering (ICO) with different metrics. What are the most important factors for an investor?

Icomarks.com, ICO bench.com, TrackICO.com and Coinfunda.com are few sources. But You should never trust ICO ratings. Always apply your mind.

Peetxvg1

newbie

Activity: 17

Merit: 0

Of course it is icodrops.com and icobench.com

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: ahtsham90 on June 04, 2018, 07:40:05 PM

the team, the idea, their social activities, community behind the project these all points are important. you can't simply look at one point to invest your hard earned money.

By community behind the project, do you mean followers on Social Media like Twitter and Telegram? Social activity directly relates to marketing not having a strong ICO project.

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: trupero_uno on June 05, 2018, 01:01:10 PM

Ideally, ICO rating should tell how potential an ICO is even there is a not good sound from this reviewer but at least investors can see the general overview from the reviewer. If rely on reviewer, it is better to find various review of such project for comparison then do own research by seeing the points of the reviewer shown such as team, project profile, etc.

From 1 to 10, how much do you rely on ICO rating websites?

trupero_uno

jr. member

Activity: 210

Merit: 1

Ideally, ICO rating should tell how potential an ICO is even there is a not good sound from this reviewer but at least investors can see the general overview from the reviewer. If rely on reviewer, it is better to find various review of such project for comparison then do own research by seeing the points of the reviewer shown such as team, project profile, etc.

ahtsham90

member

Activity: 140

Merit: 12

the team, the idea, their social activities, community behind the project these all points are important. you can't simply look at one point to invest your hard earned money.

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: Intrepid-Ventures on June 01, 2018, 05:53:55 AM

Be weary of the ICO rating sites. Most of them will ask projects to pay to get a certain rating. There are a lot of scams out there. Make sure you do your own research.

A good plate to start (in no particular order):

- The team - is the team legit? Do they have solid experience in what they're doing?
- The roadmap - do they have a clear and well-defined roadmap?
- Prototype - do they have a working prototype? This isn't a must but a good thing to keep in mind when researching
- Do the token-economics make sense?
- Is it a good concept/solid business idea or are they just looking to make money?
- Do the token sale economics make sense? E.g. token supply, hard cap etc.
- What is the level of support? Don't just look at telegram/twitter numbers, these can be bought. What is the level of engagement, are they just adding a lot of people to their group but no one actually cares about their project? Spend a bit of time in their telegram group and you'll quickly notice how responsive the team is and whether they answer questions clearly or respond well to valid criticism.

Do your own research!

A comprehensive response.
I think the most important thing is
- Team
- Whitepaper
I believe if somebody like to invest in an ICOs , reviewing Whitepaper is a must. I have seen some white papers which are mostly copy/paste of other reports or papers.
Which ICO rating website do you recommend?

Intrepid-Ventures

newbie

Activity: 99

Merit: 0

Be weary of the ICO rating sites. Most of them will ask projects to pay to get a certain rating. There are a lot of scams out there. Make sure you do your own research.

A good plate to start (in no particular order):

- The team - is the team legit? Do they have solid experience in what they're doing?
- The roadmap - do they have a clear and well-defined roadmap?
- Prototype - do they have a working prototype? This isn't a must but a good thing to keep in mind when researching
- Do the token-economics make sense?
- Is it a good concept/solid business idea or are they just looking to make money?
- Do the token sale economics make sense? E.g. token supply, hard cap etc.
- What is the level of support? Don't just look at telegram/twitter numbers, these can be bought. What is the level of engagement, are they just adding a lot of people to their group but no one actually cares about their project? Spend a bit of time in their telegram group and you'll quickly notice how responsive the team is and whether they answer questions clearly or respond well to valid criticism.

Do your own research!

Alluro

member

Activity: 742

Merit: 19

Do your own research before invest any ICO project. There are too many ICOs in crypto world. But all project are not legit. That's why do we have to make own research. First of all, read the whitepaper, find the team members are real or not, social media activities and ratings from top ICO rating sites like icobench etc.

yodomaster

newbie

Activity: 50

Merit: 0

different rating sites got different rating criterias so its hard to determine, but please just that those sites as a reference not fully rely on them

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: Cashi on May 30, 2018, 04:40:36 PM

You can find lots of them like:

https://icobench.com/
https://icoguide.com
https://www.trackico.io/
https://www.icoalert.com/
https://icowatchlist.com/
https://icoholder.com/
https://topicolist.com/
https://icorating.com/

By doing a short overview these sites are very useful, but it’s possible they can be paid for a good review so I prefer to check every project by myself. Having a look to:

Website in general
Whitepaper
YouTube
Social Media (Telegram,Twitter, Medium…)
Team (LinkedIn, Google search)
...

Reviewing bunch of ICOs on different rating websites gave me the same impression.

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: masulum on May 31, 2018, 10:29:56 AM

For me, the most important criteria for ICO is website, idea, whitepaper, road map, legal company (or atleast have valid address) and how developer team give an updates about their projects.

Followers on social media not primary, but investor can check this for additional criteria.

I agree with you. Self evaluating the ICO gives you more insight than third party rating.

masulum

legendary

Activity: 2324

Merit: 1604

hmph..

For me, the most important criteria for ICO is website, idea, whitepaper, road map, legal company (or atleast have valid address) and how developer team give an updates about their projects.

Followers on social media not primary, but investor can check this for additional criteria.

Cashi

member

Activity: 392

Merit: 49

You can find lots of them like:

https://icobench.com/
https://icoguide.com
https://www.trackico.io/
https://www.icoalert.com/
https://icowatchlist.com/
https://icoholder.com/
https://topicolist.com/
https://icorating.com/

By doing a short overview these sites are very useful, but it’s possible they can be paid for a good review so I prefer to check every project by myself. Having a look to:

Website in general
Whitepaper
YouTube
Social Media (Telegram,Twitter, Medium…)
Team (LinkedIn, Google search)
...

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Quote from: odolvlobo on April 26, 2018, 04:49:16 PM

If there is a metric, it would be risk-adjusted net present value. I don't think there is a "system" for measuring that. You would have to evaluate each ICO individually.

Going through different ICO rating system, we should say every investor has to do the evaluation individually. Even though these ICO rating website can provide some information, some of them are biased.

fabioganga

full member

Activity: 478

Merit: 113

You will find what you need on

www.ianbalina.com

This guy is great at evaluating ICOs and tells you exactly what methods he is using to evaluate.

I'm sure you will find lots of great stuff for you there.

odolvlobo

legendary

Activity: 4466

Merit: 3391

If there is a metric, it would be risk-adjusted net present value. I don't think there is a "system" for measuring that. You would have to evaluate each ICO individually.

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

Which one is more important for you?
[1] How many followers do you have on Twitter, telegram, ....?
[2] Team?
[3] Idea?
....

3dchain

newbie

Activity: 154

Merit: 0

There are multiple rating System for Initial Coin Offering (ICO) with different metrics. What are the most important factors for an investor?

Topic: What is the best Initial Coin Offering rating System? (Read 178 times)