Where does the price come from when communication is shut down?

Ekaros

hero member

Activity: 728

Merit: 500

Quote from: Matthew N. Wright on May 24, 2013, 09:49:59 AM

Quote from: ManBearPig on May 24, 2013, 07:41:07 AM

How do we set a price for anything? Start somewhere and haggle up or down. I'm guessing the arbitrary point would be somewhere between the low and the high, a mean of $100 sounds good right?

It would happen, there would be opps for arbitrage to keep the offline markets roughly in sync.

Much like traders crossing the continent hundreds of years ago I imagine.

The problem with that is that there is no tangible value nor real inherent value to bitcoin other than as an arbitrary storage of said value (catch 22). This is why I'm confused a bit about where the price would come from when bitcoin's price is currently a number on a screen telling us how many others believe it has value enough to pay us for it.

Something tells me if the internet were not available, pricing would be a nightmarish prospect.

Without Internet, it's not much. Without exhanges it can be still something...

Matthew N. Wright

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Hero VIP ultra official trusted super staff puppet

Quote from: ManBearPig on May 24, 2013, 07:41:07 AM

How do we set a price for anything? Start somewhere and haggle up or down. I'm guessing the arbitrary point would be somewhere between the low and the high, a mean of $100 sounds good right?

It would happen, there would be opps for arbitrage to keep the offline markets roughly in sync.

Much like traders crossing the continent hundreds of years ago I imagine.

The problem with that is that there is no tangible value nor real inherent value to bitcoin other than as an arbitrary storage of said value (catch 22). This is why I'm confused a bit about where the price would come from when bitcoin's price is currently a number on a screen telling us how many others believe it has value enough to pay us for it.

Something tells me if the internet were not available, pricing would be a nightmarish prospect.

ManBearPig

sr. member

Activity: 350

Merit: 250

"Don't go in the trollbox, trollbox, trollbox"

How do we set a price for anything? Start somewhere and haggle up or down. I'm guessing the arbitrary point would be somewhere between the low and the high, a mean of $100 sounds good right?

It would happen, there would be opps for arbitrage to keep the offline markets roughly in sync.

Much like traders crossing the continent hundreds of years ago I imagine.

chmod755

legendary

Activity: 1624

Merit: 1021

I came here to say something, but it has been said already.

Quote from: DeathAndTaxes on May 24, 2013, 02:14:51 AM

fair is what a good or service will sell for.

I will sell you a widget for 1 BTC. You either think that is a good deal or you don't. It really is that simple. If the last known exchange rate is 5 minutes old and is ~$150 and you think $150 is a good price for a widget you might buy. If the last known exchange rate is 37 days old and is $200 and you think $200 combined with the currency risk is too high then you might not. If enough people don't buy I will have to lower my price. Maybe you buy at 0.75 BTC.

Now without reliable quotes there will be less liquidity and less liquidity means more "friction". Less deals get done, deals are smaller, higher currency risk, etc. Commerce can still happen.

Quote from: Ekaros on May 24, 2013, 01:55:29 AM

The problem is fiat-connection. There isn't much to do untill you can acctually use BTC locally for whole economy. You would just need to consider what the amount of BTC cost to mine or trade for you and then what the service you get is worth for you. Fair price is the price both parties agree on.

Matthew N. Wright

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Hero VIP ultra official trusted super staff puppet

Quote from: DeathAndTaxes on May 24, 2013, 02:14:51 AM

fair is what a good or service will sell for.

I will sell you a widget for 1 BTC. You either think that is a good deal or you don't. It really is that simple. If the last known exchange rate is 5 minutes old and is ~$150 and you think $150 is a good price for a widget you might buy. If the last known exchange rate is 37 days old and is $200 and you think $200 combined with the currency risk is too high then you might not. If enough people don't buy I will have to lower my price. Maybe you buy at 0.75 BTC.

Now without reliable quotes there will be less liquidity and less liquidity means more "friction". Less deals get done, deals are smaller, higher currency risk, etc. Commerce can still happen.

Your response actually made me reconsider my original stance that "lack of communication would cause the price to be unstable". In effect,it could cause it to be even more stable as people would have less means to communicate price differences. I imagine this is true for some disconnected island nation that uses a currency at face value that has since been devalued heavily, or who still thinks a certain rock is worth a lot even though it's freely available anywhere else in the world. I'm not sure of any real life examples, but it seems to stand to reason that without communication, people would be following a "price ghost".

DeathAndTaxes

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1080

Gerald Davis

fair is what a good or service will sell for.

I will sell you a widget for 1 BTC. You either think that is a good deal or you don't. It really is that simple. If the last known exchange rate is 5 minutes old and is ~$150 and you think $150 is a good price for a widget you might buy. If the last known exchange rate is 37 days old and is $200 and you think $200 combined with the currency risk is too high then you might not. If enough people don't buy I will have to lower my price. Maybe you buy at 0.75 BTC.

Now without reliable quotes there will be less liquidity and less liquidity means more "friction". Less deals get done, deals are smaller, higher currency risk, etc. Commerce can still happen.

The 4ner

hero member

Activity: 602

Merit: 500

R.I.P Silk Road 1.0

Quote from: Ekaros on May 24, 2013, 01:55:29 AM

Quote from: Matthew N. Wright on May 24, 2013, 01:45:13 AM

It's not just about the government shutting down bitcoin. I'm sorry for not making that clearer in my OP. It's about every exchange being DDoSed too. When the price coming in unreliable, how does one decide what is a fair price?

The problem is fiat-connection. There isn't much to do untill you can acctually use BTC locally for whole economy. You would just need to consider what the amount of BTC cost to mine or trade for you and then what the service you get is worth for you. Fair price is the price both parties agree on.

+1

Ekaros

hero member

Activity: 728

Merit: 500

Quote from: Matthew N. Wright on May 24, 2013, 01:45:13 AM

It's not just about the government shutting down bitcoin. I'm sorry for not making that clearer in my OP. It's about every exchange being DDoSed too. When the price coming in unreliable, how does one decide what is a fair price?

The problem is fiat-connection. There isn't much to do untill you can acctually use BTC locally for whole economy. You would just need to consider what the amount of BTC cost to mine or trade for you and then what the service you get is worth for you. Fair price is the price both parties agree on.

Matthew N. Wright

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Hero VIP ultra official trusted super staff puppet

Quote from: solex on May 24, 2013, 01:35:25 AM

Matthew, how long have you been active with Bitcoin? Why worry now that the internet might be switched off?

This is really a scenario to stick in the doomsday basket, like what happens if a large asteroid hits the planet, or Iran nukes Israel or global warming melts Antarctica. The internet becomes a more persistent structure every day, and meshed into everyone's lives. Any government which tries to cut it off has to be in a life-or-death situation, like in Syria or North Korea. There would be mass-starvation and social breakdown first. People would be bartering food for guns, petrol for medicine.

The beauty of Bitcoin is that any post-disaster society would have a currency ready for use when their internet was stable again.

It's not just about the government shutting down bitcoin. I'm sorry for not making that clearer in my OP. It's about every exchange being DDoSed too. When the price coming in unreliable, how does one decide what is a fair price?

solex

legendary

Activity: 1078

Merit: 1006

100 satoshis -> ISO code

Matthew, how long have you been active with Bitcoin? Why worry now that the internet might be switched off?

This is really a scenario to stick in the doomsday basket, like what happens if a large asteroid hits the planet, or Iran nukes Israel or global warming melts Antarctica. The internet becomes a more persistent structure every day, and meshed into everyone's lives. Any government which tries to cut it off has to be in a life-or-death situation, like in Syria or North Korea. There would be mass-starvation and social breakdown first. People would be bartering food for guns, petrol for medicine.

The beauty of Bitcoin is that any post-disaster society would have a currency ready for use when their internet was stable again.

Matthew N. Wright

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Hero VIP ultra official trusted super staff puppet

I understand the somewhat naive reasoning that "if the government shuts down the internet, you can still trade bitcoin locally so it's unstoppable!!!11" but I'm concerned with the value at that point. In talking with Erik Voorhees before, he explained it to me that people in the local area would decide their own rates and such which sounds alright but it's also highly impractical.

The day that mtGox was being DDoSed, an artist asked for payment for an illustration for a project I was working on. She was in a hurry to get paid, so I sent her what I believed to be fair (a little more than the spot price) and it was actually less than what I owed her by the time it confirmed in her wallet. Now let's assume that mtGox, BitStamp, and every bitcoin exchange are outlawed as money laundering facilitators or terrorist SilkRoad enablers or some bullshit (pick your conspiracy). Where does the *price* come from?

A centralized IRC server with fake accounts trying to manipulate the price?
Email from strangers promising to pay?

We'd need some sort of broadcast of the current price from somewhere, and I am having a hard time understanding how that can be decentralized in the current bitcoin implementation. Is this why we need a decentralized exchange badly?

Topic: Where does the price come from when communication is shut down? (Read 1000 times)