Topic: Why cant we tip others in bitcoin in the bitcoin forum? (Read 979 times)

Quote from: serje on June 15, 2016, 02:39:58 AM

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

Horrific idea. There's enough accounts being hacked already. Knowing there might be bitcoins available too would make this a total honeypot for (more) dishonest scum.

yesiam6

hero member

Activity: 1036

Merit: 520

1KoMmKPMG6xaWcqB8CPP3WJ8avRSVRHtP2

I think that the best way would be to just tip the persons signature address
Loading up bitcointalk btc balance to tip people wouldnt be decentralized anymore

nururochac

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 100

Quote from: nururochac on June 15, 2016, 02:35:48 AM

Quote from: nururochac on June 15, 2016, 02:35:48 AM

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

I think thats a good idea so that other people will eager to do more effort in making a post.

Also the admins shoul think at the possibility for everyone to see how much BTC everyone deposits in his account so that hackers won't waste time hacking the forum when there are no funds !!! What do you guys say?

It doesnt go like that, whenever this is approved there's just a code that bind our wallet address on the forum thats all. There's no need to deposit to another wallet address.

serje

legendary

Activity: 1232

Merit: 1002

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

I think thats a good idea so that other people will eager to do more effort in making a post.

Also the admins shoul think at the possibility for everyone to see how much BTC everyone deposits in his account so that hackers won't waste time hacking the forum when there are no funds !!! What do you guys say?

nururochac

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 100

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

I think thats a good idea so that other people will eager to do more effort in making a post.

TookDk

legendary

Activity: 1960

Merit: 1062

One coin to rule them all

Quote from: shorena on June 15, 2016, 01:15:32 AM

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

Nono. The best would be to keep your bitcoins in your wallet until you need to spend them.

serje

legendary

Activity: 1232

Merit: 1002

Quote from: omegaaf on June 15, 2016, 12:30:31 AM

-snip-
How many forums do you know that got hacked and lost all the customer funds.
-snip-

How often do you think this forum got hacked? A hint, the number is not 0.

Quote from: koshgel on June 15, 2016, 01:11:44 AM

Quote from: koshgel on June 15, 2016, 01:11:44 AM

i think the next software of bitcointalk will be support it

Yes, pretty sure there are plans to implement it in the next version of the forum.

As of now most people have BTC addresses in their profiles or signatures that you can send to if you really want to tip them.

No, theymos said they dont want to get into the legal trouble of holding funds for users. The only reason for OPs solution I see are payment too small to be done on chain. With those kinds of tips, dont even bother.

Since the number is not 0 I'm sure that in the next version we will see a tipping button!
That being said let's wait for the next version that will never come hopefully!!!

This version is perfect!

omegaaf

full member

Activity: 181

Merit: 101

Quote from: omegaaf on June 15, 2016, 12:30:31 AM

i think the next software of bitcointalk will be support it

Yes, pretty sure there are plans to implement it in the next version of the forum.

As of now most people have BTC addresses in their profiles or signatures that you can send to if you really want to tip them.

Great, cant wait for it.
and btw.
Most people do not have their btc address posted.

shorena

copper member

Activity: 1498

Merit: 1528

No I dont escrow anymore.

-snip-
How many forums do you know that got hacked and lost all the customer funds.
-snip-

How often do you think this forum got hacked? A hint, the number is not 0.

Quote from: koshgel on June 15, 2016, 01:11:44 AM

i think the next software of bitcointalk will be support it

Yes, pretty sure there are plans to implement it in the next version of the forum.

As of now most people have BTC addresses in their profiles or signatures that you can send to if you really want to tip them.

No, theymos said they dont want to get into the legal trouble of holding funds for users. The only reason for OPs solution I see are payment too small to be done on chain. With those kinds of tips, dont even bother.

koshgel

legendary

Activity: 1162

Merit: 1001

Quote from: Lutpin on June 15, 2016, 12:03:31 AM

i think the next software of bitcointalk will be support it

Yes, pretty sure there are plans to implement it in the next version of the forum.

As of now most people have BTC addresses in their profiles or signatures that you can send to if you really want to tip them.

omegaaf

full member

Activity: 181

Merit: 101

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi.

Nono. No solution at which we need the forum to hold the users bitcoin for a certain timeframe should be desireable in any case.
Also, we don't need an additional feature for things that can be easily done with the options we already got at hand.

Quote from: serje on June 14, 2016, 11:55:32 PM

That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

Use the section in your profile then, maybe?
Funny that you would see a tipping address in the signature as somehow disturbing, as this was the original use for them, long before signature campaigns came up.

maybe he wants everyone to see that he is tipping .... maybe he wants to brag about it

You can post txhashes for bragging rights.

I don't agree. I think leaving small amounts of btc on the forum is safer then leaving amounts in our exchange accounts. How many forums do you know that got hacked and lost all the customer funds.
Forum gox?
Forum Cryptsy?
Forum Mintpal.

And yes, bitcoin addresses are not sexy nor nice to look at. Id like to see the tip option soon. Hopefully like others mentioned on the new forum.

patronis

sr. member

Activity: 420

Merit: 250

This would be a cool feature but I remember reading somewhere mods/admins are against someone creating a bot to do this, maybe because of spam or they eventually planned on adding it but who knows when?

pandalion98

sr. member

Activity: 504

Merit: 250

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Maybe for reasons of ease. If someone really wanted to tip someone, they can look for their BTC address then send it to there, but most people would go like "too many clicks, too lazy. Nevermind on the tip".

That's why UI developers emphasize on ease and reducing tediousness, and you usually see "one-click" actions/solutions/forms/registration/login/etc.

Skylake

full member

Activity: 165

Merit: 100

i think the next software of bitcointalk will be support it

Lutpin

copper member

Activity: 1904

Merit: 1874

Goodbye, Z.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi.

Nono. No solution at which we need the forum to hold the users bitcoin for a certain timeframe should be desireable in any case.
Also, we don't need an additional feature for things that can be easily done with the options we already got at hand.

Quote from: serje on June 14, 2016, 11:55:32 PM

That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

Use the section in your profile then, maybe?
Funny that you would see a tipping address in the signature as somehow disturbing, as this was the original use for them, long before signature campaigns came up.

maybe he wants everyone to see that he is tipping .... maybe he wants to brag about it

You can post txhashes for bragging rights.

serje

legendary

Activity: 1232

Merit: 1002

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

maybe he wants everyone to see that he is tipping .... maybe he wants to brag about it

who knows .... but i like him because of his signature Cheesy

omegaaf

full member

Activity: 181

Merit: 101

Has this been covered? It seems strange that we cant tip other members for quality posts that help us. Is this being considered?

Everyone can add their bitcoin address to either their profile (there's an extra section for that) or to their signature for example.
There's nothing keeping you from sending tips to the addresses other users got in their profiles via the blockchain (/your wallet).
As a result, I don't see the need for any forum-based tip implementation when we got the best tool for it already at hand.

Nono. The best tool would be to allow us to deposit btc on the forum and just like we can click ignore on someone we can also click on tip and send him a few staoshi. That would be the best and it would keep the signatures clean from everyone's address.

Lutpin

copper member

Activity: 1904

Merit: 1874

Goodbye, Z.