I never said the miner found blocks. The miner is finding shares, and has successfully found NMC shares. Of course, a good enough share is used as a block that the pool broadcasts.
The shares the miner submits are not "good enough for NMC but not good enough for BTC". It is in fact that the shares he submitted were counted for both NMC and BTC. He earned NMC because the shares he submitted were paid out when blocks of NMC were found. No blocks of BTC were found so he didn't earn any. When the pool finds a block of BTC, assuming he's got any shares, he'll be paid.