Author

Topic: Why is copyscape not integrated here ? (Read 169 times)

legendary
Activity: 1372
Merit: 1123
February 09, 2018, 05:14:05 PM
#7
I've seen a handful of threads pop up today asking about why X or Y have not been implemented here on the forum, and in the interest of trying to save a long-winded explanation I'll try to keep it simple and concise.

Take a look at another user being responded to by Vod for asking about a similar implementation

It's probably just that little bit of money, plus a LOT OF PROGRAMMING TIME.

Theymos has modded this forum considerably.  That's why it's such an old version of SMF - he can't upgrade it anymore.

A "simple" thing like 2FA could break a dozen mods he has made....

So the answer is security, efficiency, resource management, etc. There are only so many things that can be done before moving to the new forum software (which have been being worked on for years). It probably would take a long time or a lot of effort to program into the forum, then once it is properly implemented it might come with security flaws/holes, which lead to further problems or even simple compatibility issues with what has already been programmed into the forum.

It is a lot of effort and risk for probably minimal reward; there is not normally a time where copy + paste can be used and still make sense in response to the thread/conversation. So most of them will be thread-starters, and a lot of people around here already search little parts of your posts to see if it can be found elsewhere. There are already people watching, this gets called out fairly regularly and punished severely.
full member
Activity: 1442
Merit: 108
February 09, 2018, 03:57:40 AM
#6
This is actually a great idea! I am not familiar with copyscape but somehow I feel it provides service like Turnitin where it can give you a score or a percentage of how much of your work is plagiarized or not properly paraphrased. This can be a great addition to the features of the forum. Maybe someday we will see the incorporation of such programs for the betterment of the forum. 
Copyscape also shows how much of the content is copied. It can be integrated in a way where the member's post will be rejected automatically if he has posted copied content.


I am familiar with Copyscape service. It's not giving accurate results for several reasons, I can show you duplicate content and Copyscape won't be able to detect it. The free version is limited daily, The API with premium will cost a lot of money to the forum, and won't give better reults.
Moderators rely on members reports to do this.Otherwise, they would spend 24/7 checking all posts

You are correct that it is not 100% correct but has quite good accuracy. It is used a standard plagiarism tool all over the world by thousands of webmasters.
copper member
Activity: 2940
Merit: 4101
Top Crypto Casino
February 02, 2018, 10:38:18 AM
#5
I am familiar with Copyscape service. It's not giving accurate results for several reasons, I can show you duplicate content and Copyscape won't be able to detect it. The free version is limited daily, The API with premium will cost a lot of money to the forum, and won't give better reults.
Moderators rely on members reports to do this.Otherwise, they would spend 24/7 checking all posts
full member
Activity: 182
Merit: 147
February 02, 2018, 10:22:35 AM
#4
This is actually a great idea! I am not familiar with copyscape but somehow I feel it provides service like Turnitin where it can give you a score or a percentage of how much of your work is plagiarized or not properly paraphrased. This can be a great addition to the features of the forum. Maybe someday we will see the incorporation of such programs for the betterment of the forum. 
full member
Activity: 1442
Merit: 108
February 02, 2018, 09:01:19 AM
#3
Copyscape is a nice service, I’ve used it to find copies of my content. But do they offer real time checking?

They do offer real time checking. I have seen it implemented on a website where about 1000 articles are submitted daily. Regarding price, it was approx $100 or so monthly if I remember correctly.
full member
Activity: 210
Merit: 119
February 02, 2018, 08:56:57 AM
#2
Copyscape is a nice service, I’ve used it to find copies of my content. But do they offer real time checking? I don’t think it would be hugely useful to have copied content deleted a long time after it was posted. Also, IIRC Copyscape is very expensive if there’s a large number of pages to check.
full member
Activity: 1442
Merit: 108
February 02, 2018, 08:49:56 AM
#1
I have a small suggestion for the forum owner. If possible, kindly integrate copyscape with the forum. It will automatically detect copied content whenever a member tries to post it here. Will make the work of moderators easy.
Jump to: