Note that I didn't use the "get" calls or "dumprivkey" as for the purposes of simplifying the test script I used hard-coded private keys (but in a "live version" I would be basically doing just that).
Topic: ACCT using CLTV - More Effective than a sleeping pill! - page 2. (Read 3575 times)
Yup - I found that for the 4 wallets the simplest approach is to use "-regtest" (as you can generate the coins instantly).
I also use pretty much the same commands you list - but the construction and signing is done with my own software (I was a little disappointed that Bitcoin couldn't do at least the signing but it is a very unusual looking raw tx so perhaps not that surprising).
The CIYAM script I am using for testing this is here: https://github.com/ciyam/ciyam/blob/master/src/bct_acct_test.cin
(some of it is probably a bit mysterious but you can see the Bitcoin RPC calls fairly clearly).
I also use pretty much the same commands you list - but the construction and signing is done with my own software (I was a little disappointed that Bitcoin couldn't do at least the signing but it is a very unusual looking raw tx so perhaps not that surprising).
The CIYAM script I am using for testing this is here: https://github.com/ciyam/ciyam/blob/master/src/bct_acct_test.cin
(some of it is probably a bit mysterious but you can see the Bitcoin RPC calls fairly clearly).
Unfortunately the ACCT/CLTV Bitcoin tx is not something that Bitcoin (or Litecoin) can handle with its raw tx support (so it can't create the tx and nor can it sign it).
You have to build up the transactions manually, but it does track coins held by the wallet. It also tracks payments to the wallet, as long as you pay them to one of the standard output formats.
The fun with testing is that you need to run 4 wallets. You can quickly burn all your outputs and then have to wait 10 minutes for more.
The RPC commands I used in my unfinished (pre-checklocktimeverify) version are:
listunspent (gets available coins in the wallet)
getrawchangeaddress (for change)
getnewaddress (for receiving)
dumpprivkey (for converting an address into a private key)
validateaddress (gets info about the address)
sendrawtransaction (sends the raw transaction)
Why is there a need for copy/pasting?
You could require that both people have their litecoin and bitcoin wallets open and connect to them via RPC. The standard clients can generate private keys and fund transactions. They even handle P2SH addresses that are basic.
You could require that both people have their litecoin and bitcoin wallets open and connect to them via RPC. The standard clients can generate private keys and fund transactions. They even handle P2SH addresses that are basic.
The reason for that is just up to how it is implemented and yes it could be possible to get rid of that via scripts, etc.
Unfortunately the ACCT/CLTV Bitcoin tx is not something that Bitcoin (or Litecoin) can handle with its raw tx support (so it can't create the tx and nor can it sign it).
The annoying part of ACCT is that waiting for confirms is kind of required. This means that you are really giving an option to the other party. The other person can drop out if the price shifts.
I think that is simply the nature of the beast (so it will never be attractive for "day traders").
Why is there a need for copy/pasting?
You could require that both people have their litecoin and bitcoin wallets open and connect to them via RPC. The standard clients can generate private keys and fund transactions. They even handle P2SH addresses that are basic.
The annoying part of ACCT is that waiting for confirms is kind of required. This means that you are really giving an option to the other party. The other person can drop out if the price shifts.
You could require that both people have their litecoin and bitcoin wallets open and connect to them via RPC. The standard clients can generate private keys and fund transactions. They even handle P2SH addresses that are basic.
The annoying part of ACCT is that waiting for confirms is kind of required. This means that you are really giving an option to the other party. The other person can drop out if the price shifts.
To elaborate on the workflow that would be involved in trading LTC for BTC:
Number of steps for Alice (apart from creating the offer) is four whilst the number of steps for Brian is three (guess it should be slightly easier for the party that "goes first").
Note that if the Wallet is clever enough then perhaps Alice's second last step can be simply automated (i.e. the last two steps could be combined into one) but I think three steps each is about as good as it can get with this design.
- Alice creates an LTC / BTC offer pair using the Trade web application (as this could be done once for many trades it won't be counted as a step).
- Brian clicks on the offer and then creates a Trade Transaction providing an Amount, an LTC Refund Address, a BTC Receive Address and a hashed Secret.
- Alice is notified she has a new Trade Transaction and supplies her BTC Refund Address and LTC Receive Address.
- Brian is notified that the deal is on and now sees a P2SH LTC Address which he sends the LTC funds to.
- Alice detects that Brian has sent the LTC funds (via a "watch address") and sends her BTC funds to a BTC P2SH Address.
- Brian now copies and pastes the BTC P2SH Redeem script into a special Wallet and redeems the BTC (disclosing the secret).
- Alice detects (via a "watch address") that Brian has redeemed the BTC and then discovers the secret from the redeem tx.
- Alice copies and pastes the secret and the LTC P2SH Redeem script into a special Wallet and redeems the LTC.
Number of steps for Alice (apart from creating the offer) is four whilst the number of steps for Brian is three (guess it should be slightly easier for the party that "goes first").
Note that if the Wallet is clever enough then perhaps Alice's second last step can be simply automated (i.e. the last two steps could be combined into one) but I think three steps each is about as good as it can get with this design.
A decentralized exchange with a good interface would be quite useful for many. Can it do the reverse? e.g. BTC for LTC?
Yes - it would support that (just using the CIYAM software).
I presume this related to the CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY and the check against questions....I haven't looked at the code above yet.
Indeed - that is how it operates.
Congrats on getting it working. Why do you think you've wasted your time?
Thanks - well - when it is done using AT instead then it will be integrated into a wallet and not have many steps (so ACCT between QORA and BURST should be a good experience).
As CIYAM's blockchain is still a "work in progress" I would have to release Trade as a web application requiring therefore a separate Wallet application to operate with it (which is what my testing is emulating). That adds a few steps (copying and pasting) which I think is not going to be viewed very enthusiastically.
Also when it comes to using Bitcoin (or even Litecoin) you could not realistically be expecting to do trades in under an hour or so (because time stamps in blocks are just not that accurate and you would need to wait for at least one confirmation between each step).
So using the CIYAM Trade application along with using a CIYAM console acting as a Bitcoin/Litecoin wallet I demonstrated to my wife how you could exchange LTC for BTC without a 3rd party (or fees other than tx fees) and apparently it was so boring she fell asleep.
...
So I've built a decentralised exchange but I am getting the feeling that I have probably wasted my time doing so (am glad it hasn't taken me more than a couple of weeks).
Does anyone really think that this kind of idea is going to work?
...
So I've built a decentralised exchange but I am getting the feeling that I have probably wasted my time doing so (am glad it hasn't taken me more than a couple of weeks).
Does anyone really think that this kind of idea is going to work?
A decentralized exchange with a good interface would be quite useful for many. Can it do the reverse? e.g. BTC for LTC?
I presume this related to the CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY and the check
Congrats on getting it working. Why do you think you've wasted your time?
Yes if it's fast enough. The Ripple distributed exchange was always slow compared to regular exchanges, but it did plenty of business last year.
If you could make a trade in 30 seconds or less people would use it. A few coins tried cutting block times to the minimum, and managed a block every few seconds which could make an exchange fairly fast. Viacoin has a 24 seconds block time, and Bitshares 2.0 started with 5 second blocks with the option of reducing it to one second blocks.
If the qora devs saw value in reducing the block time to accommodate an exchange they would probably do it.
If you could make a trade in 30 seconds or less people would use it. A few coins tried cutting block times to the minimum, and managed a block every few seconds which could make an exchange fairly fast. Viacoin has a 24 seconds block time, and Bitshares 2.0 started with 5 second blocks with the option of reducing it to one second blocks.
If the qora devs saw value in reducing the block time to accommodate an exchange they would probably do it.
So using the CIYAM Trade application along with using a CIYAM console acting as a Bitcoin/Litecoin wallet I demonstrated to my wife how you could exchange LTC for BTC without a 3rd party (or fees other than tx fees) and apparently it was so boring she fell asleep.
So I've built a decentralised exchange but I am getting the feeling that I have probably wasted my time doing so (am glad it hasn't taken me more than a couple of weeks).
Does anyone really think that this kind of idea is going to work?
Code:
Generating a spendable amount of RHS for "user1"...
Generating a spendable amount of LHS for "user2"...
Login as "user1" and create a Trading Pair (with Maximum Amount as at least 25) and then Logout.
Now login as "user2" and create a tx from the offer in the All Open Offers list with the following details:
Sending Amount: 25
Refund Address: mtW4pzRHXwNwkHa2mdy2EokKy5GZ4aMWtu
Receiving Address: mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT
Secret Hash: 2bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b
Now login as "user1" and edit the Trade Transaction in the My Trade Transactions list with the following:
Refund Address: mids4AKKn42KmcJTvaynUzmnhWnmfgwRMw
Receiving Address: mgF67ucKz7CddjuJwDvDUgC5HiJBRDGNBx
Now login as "user2" and from the tx click on the Waiting tx and copy and paste the Sending Address:
USER2_P2SH=2N1dPcqdkNyfNqysHDqWRq8hqSs6sT91LTP
Now "user2" will send LHS to their P2SH address.
Now login as "user1" and from the tx click on the Waiting tx and copy and paste the Sending Address:
USER1_P2SH=2NFtwQWeiQzMgeidPCrZZhATv6ULXqA8WaB
Now "user1" will send RHS to their P2SH address...
[
{
"involvesWatchonly" : true,
"account" : "user2 (user1's p2sh)",
"address" : "2NFtwQWeiQzMgeidPCrZZhATv6ULXqA8WaB",
"category" : "receive",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"vout" : 1,
"confirmations" : 4,
"blockhash" : "55647bfcc1ea60124e3e358a046a1e6494babb666d656aec3a9ad7ea3b179e71",
"blockindex" : 1,
"blocktime" : 1453733457,
"txid" : "1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870",
"walletconflicts" : [
],
"time" : 1453733457,
"timereceived" : 1453733475
}
]
Now enter the following from the transaction information above:
TXID=1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870
VOUT=1
Now login as "user2" and from the tx click the Receive Checked button and paste the Secret Reveal Script:
SCRIPT=76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142
236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68
0100000001702804391136748202c2bbae27f3c7fe791e5c52f3f8c588d918b3dbc3ff0e1b01000000d44730440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af65
8502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589ab3ed1076d7501210334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636067365637265744c
6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea
542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68000000000100f90295000000001976a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac00000000
Now "user2" will redeem RHS from the "user1" P2SH address tx (exposing their secret).
Balance of RHS for "user2" is:
25.00000000
Now login as "user1" and from the tx click the Receive Checked button and paste the new Check Address:
ADDR=mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT
[
{
"involvesWatchonly" : true,
"account" : "user1 (user2's reveal)",
"address" : "mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT",
"category" : "receive",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"vout" : 0,
"confirmations" : 1,
"blockhash" : "5ea97dcb1e76ca90ef0b71aae2208488df5d8344248be2713fbb8f1bae8a1667",
"blockindex" : 1,
"blocktime" : 1453733502,
"txid" : "d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf",
"walletconflicts" : [
],
"time" : 1453733502,
"timereceived" : 1453733536
}
]
Now copy and paste the secret reveal txid:
TXID=d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf
{
"txid" : "d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf",
"version" : 1,
"locktime" : 0,
"vin" : [
{
"txid" : "1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870",
"vout" : 1,
"scriptSig" : {
"asm" : "30440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af658502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589ab3
ed1076d7501 0334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636 736563726574 76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf5
27a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68",
"hex" : "4730440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af658502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589a
b3ed1076d7501210334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636067365637265744c6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25
fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68"
},
"sequence" : 0
}
],
"vout" : [
{
"value" : 25.00000000,
"n" : 0,
"scriptPubKey" : {
"asm" : "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 39f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca18358 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
"hex" : "76a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac",
"reqSigs" : 1,
"type" : "pubkeyhash",
"addresses" : [
"mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT"
]
}
}
]
}
Now copy and paste the revealed secret:
HEX_SCRT=736563726574
[
{
"txid" : "e6af2d2c7e6cda9ea14c166a57c83112376a39b24524b5d2b1e607d740663b71",
"vout" : 0,
"address" : "2N1dPcqdkNyfNqysHDqWRq8hqSs6sT91LTP",
"account" : "user1 (user2's p2sh)",
"scriptPubKey" : "a9145bf232454e73c9cafa022f52d819bbf59c63df1087",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"confirmations" : 9,
"spendable" : false
}
]
Now copy and paste the P2SH txid and vout:
TXID=e6af2d2c7e6cda9ea14c166a57c83112376a39b24524b5d2b1e607d740663b71
VOUT=0
Now click the Secret Checked button and paste the Secret Reveal Script:
SCRIPT=76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac67047387a756b17576a9148
e6eac4b9e5944a76f2305a736ed2a7d65742f7688ac68
0100000001713b6640d707e6b1d2b52445b2396a371231c8576a164ca19eda6c7e2c2dafe600000000d4473044022027523c5d0aaf22798d0503c67c073bf4a78522d88d8128720091289845ac0f
1d022078d69e74bea88f7d727a4a04650179136ca24872477f052f58d17f825ce1b0ad01210220d666741f2e8be672556ca8f0b7a7352516422c7b7b3f0681d39adf4cabd953067365637265744c
6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac67047387a756b17576a9148e6eac
4b9e5944a76f2305a736ed2a7d65742f7688ac68000000000100f90295000000001976a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac00000000
Now "user1" will redeem LHS from the "user2" P2SH address tx.
Balance of LHS for "user1" is:
25.00000000
Generating a spendable amount of LHS for "user2"...
Login as "user1" and create a Trading Pair (with Maximum Amount as at least 25) and then Logout.
Now login as "user2" and create a tx from the offer in the All Open Offers list with the following details:
Sending Amount: 25
Refund Address: mtW4pzRHXwNwkHa2mdy2EokKy5GZ4aMWtu
Receiving Address: mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT
Secret Hash: 2bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b
Now login as "user1" and edit the Trade Transaction in the My Trade Transactions list with the following:
Refund Address: mids4AKKn42KmcJTvaynUzmnhWnmfgwRMw
Receiving Address: mgF67ucKz7CddjuJwDvDUgC5HiJBRDGNBx
Now login as "user2" and from the tx click on the Waiting tx and copy and paste the Sending Address:
USER2_P2SH=2N1dPcqdkNyfNqysHDqWRq8hqSs6sT91LTP
Now "user2" will send LHS to their P2SH address.
Now login as "user1" and from the tx click on the Waiting tx and copy and paste the Sending Address:
USER1_P2SH=2NFtwQWeiQzMgeidPCrZZhATv6ULXqA8WaB
Now "user1" will send RHS to their P2SH address...
[
{
"involvesWatchonly" : true,
"account" : "user2 (user1's p2sh)",
"address" : "2NFtwQWeiQzMgeidPCrZZhATv6ULXqA8WaB",
"category" : "receive",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"vout" : 1,
"confirmations" : 4,
"blockhash" : "55647bfcc1ea60124e3e358a046a1e6494babb666d656aec3a9ad7ea3b179e71",
"blockindex" : 1,
"blocktime" : 1453733457,
"txid" : "1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870",
"walletconflicts" : [
],
"time" : 1453733457,
"timereceived" : 1453733475
}
]
Now enter the following from the transaction information above:
TXID=1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870
VOUT=1
Now login as "user2" and from the tx click the Receive Checked button and paste the Secret Reveal Script:
SCRIPT=76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142
236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68
0100000001702804391136748202c2bbae27f3c7fe791e5c52f3f8c588d918b3dbc3ff0e1b01000000d44730440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af65
8502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589ab3ed1076d7501210334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636067365637265744c
6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea
542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68000000000100f90295000000001976a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac00000000
Now "user2" will redeem RHS from the "user1" P2SH address tx (exposing their secret).
Balance of RHS for "user2" is:
25.00000000
Now login as "user1" and from the tx click the Receive Checked button and paste the new Check Address:
ADDR=mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT
[
{
"involvesWatchonly" : true,
"account" : "user1 (user2's reveal)",
"address" : "mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT",
"category" : "receive",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"vout" : 0,
"confirmations" : 1,
"blockhash" : "5ea97dcb1e76ca90ef0b71aae2208488df5d8344248be2713fbb8f1bae8a1667",
"blockindex" : 1,
"blocktime" : 1453733502,
"txid" : "d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf",
"walletconflicts" : [
],
"time" : 1453733502,
"timereceived" : 1453733536
}
]
Now copy and paste the secret reveal txid:
TXID=d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf
{
"txid" : "d374d12b0cee799e7d3b233332b87ae41f18ffae9c1a5dc49f7436df4f216fcf",
"version" : 1,
"locktime" : 0,
"vin" : [
{
"txid" : "1b0effc3dbb318d988c5f8f3525c1e79fec7f327aebbc2028274361139042870",
"vout" : 1,
"scriptSig" : {
"asm" : "30440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af658502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589ab3
ed1076d7501 0334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636 736563726574 76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf5
27a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68",
"hex" : "4730440220456e9d366d89034c7321a900f17e60506cb9e6fb3c280587301609fda6af658502206d785719bc42de81ce05ac4b461fc9d4aab5286d4ec3ef8d0589a
b3ed1076d7501210334ae38e2f6331bfc4832893edd540377bcfc08b1a63730339b91cf8a6e0b6636067365637265744c6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25
fe97bf527a25b87637576a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac6704d0dea656b17576a9142236ea542963ca5022db4332cd63aa2ed895af6888ac68"
},
"sequence" : 0
}
],
"vout" : [
{
"value" : 25.00000000,
"n" : 0,
"scriptPubKey" : {
"asm" : "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 39f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca18358 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
"hex" : "76a91439f079037b44caa047b19f66f9446ad29ca1835888ac",
"reqSigs" : 1,
"type" : "pubkeyhash",
"addresses" : [
"mkoJtKoxHmdL8aXJvPudmUgZKC1xXHb9KT"
]
}
}
]
}
Now copy and paste the revealed secret:
HEX_SCRT=736563726574
[
{
"txid" : "e6af2d2c7e6cda9ea14c166a57c83112376a39b24524b5d2b1e607d740663b71",
"vout" : 0,
"address" : "2N1dPcqdkNyfNqysHDqWRq8hqSs6sT91LTP",
"account" : "user1 (user2's p2sh)",
"scriptPubKey" : "a9145bf232454e73c9cafa022f52d819bbf59c63df1087",
"amount" : 25.00000000,
"confirmations" : 9,
"spendable" : false
}
]
Now copy and paste the P2SH txid and vout:
TXID=e6af2d2c7e6cda9ea14c166a57c83112376a39b24524b5d2b1e607d740663b71
VOUT=0
Now click the Secret Checked button and paste the Secret Reveal Script:
SCRIPT=76a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac67047387a756b17576a9148
e6eac4b9e5944a76f2305a736ed2a7d65742f7688ac68
0100000001713b6640d707e6b1d2b52445b2396a371231c8576a164ca19eda6c7e2c2dafe600000000d4473044022027523c5d0aaf22798d0503c67c073bf4a78522d88d8128720091289845ac0f
1d022078d69e74bea88f7d727a4a04650179136ca24872477f052f58d17f825ce1b0ad01210220d666741f2e8be672556ca8f0b7a7352516422c7b7b3f0681d39adf4cabd953067365637265744c
6176a8202bb80d537b1da3e38bd30361aa855686bde0eacd7162fef6a25fe97bf527a25b87637576a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac67047387a756b17576a9148e6eac
4b9e5944a76f2305a736ed2a7d65742f7688ac68000000000100f90295000000001976a91407f8009f5b6b12a5ae10e0ae539ea06ce232cfbf88ac00000000
Now "user1" will redeem LHS from the "user2" P2SH address tx.
Balance of LHS for "user1" is:
25.00000000
So I've built a decentralised exchange but I am getting the feeling that I have probably wasted my time doing so (am glad it hasn't taken me more than a couple of weeks).
Does anyone really think that this kind of idea is going to work?
Jump to: