Pages:
Author

Topic: advantage bitcoin over other payment methods online - page 2. (Read 1690 times)

legendary
Activity: 826
Merit: 1002
amarha
Hi all,

doing an assignment for school and I would like to find information on if and if so why it is cheaper to pay with bitcoin instead of a debitcard or a creditcard when purchasing something online or with a debitcard even in a physical location. I would like to find numbers on the costs involved in these payments?

Thx a lot

One big advantage compared to payment companies like PayPal is the fact that you cannot have your account arbitrarily locked and your funds frozen/stolen from you by the company. PayPal is notorious for locking peoples accounts and not being receptive to customers who attempt to cooperate.
hero member
Activity: 552
Merit: 501
http://blockchain.info/stats has the numbers you want. The cost per transaction at present is  about US$ 30 and the average transaction size in dollar terms is  about US$ 1,300, so as a percentage, the cost per transaction is just over 2%. This is somewhat less than the cost of credit card transactions, for which merchants pay ~ 3% or more, depending on the card.

Note that this is not the fee because it is not paid for by the people doing the transfer. Instead it is paid for by inflation (new bitcoins earned by the miners who process transactions), which means in effect that all holders of bitcoin are paying the cost of all transactions on the network in proportion to their bitcoin holdings. At present, the bitcoin rate of inflation is about 11% (ignore all the nonsense you read about bitcoin being a deflationary currency - it is nothing of the sort). So all things being equal, all holders of bitcoin will experience a devaluation of their holdings by 11% per year to pay for transactions made during that year.

At present direct transaction fees are minimal (a fraction of a percent) but this will have to change over time as bitcoin inflation falls (it halves every four years) so that miners will increasingly come to rely on transaction fees. Nobody knows what level transaction fees will be in the future or how they will be charged (this is a huge topic of research), but ultimately somebody has to pay for the costs of the network. There's no such thing as a free lunch (except maybe POS, but that's another story ....)

This is confusing and convoluted and does not address what the OP is asking about in any way whatsoever (with the minor exception of "at present direct transaction fees are minimal"). The weird monetary hypothesis being advanced here under the pretenses of talking about transaction fees has nothing to do with any of the economics directly surrounding merchant and customer adoption vs. credit cards.

Yes we all know "Bitcoin transfers are very low cost, they save merchants credit card fees blah blah blah". Any dullard can write a report stating the obvious. But the intelligent student will ask himself - is BTC really fee-free? Are there hidden costs? What are they? How will they work in future? That then takes the student into issues such as BTC inflation, transaction fees etc. But sure. If the OP just wants to get a C+/B- then he can take your approach.
full member
Activity: 196
Merit: 101
Because the fee is related to the amount of data that makes up the transaction and not to the amount of Bitcoins being sent, the fee may seem extremely low (0.0005 BTC for a 1,000 BTC transfer) or unfairly high (0.004 BTC for a 0.02 BTC payment, or about 20%).
If you are receiving tiny amounts (e.g. as small payments from a mining pool) then fees when sending will be higher than if your activity follows the pattern of conventional consumer or business transactions.
hero member
Activity: 667
Merit: 500
http://blockchain.info/stats has the numbers you want. The cost per transaction at present is  about US$ 30 and the average transaction size in dollar terms is  about US$ 1,300, so as a percentage, the cost per transaction is just over 2%. This is somewhat less than the cost of credit card transactions, for which merchants pay ~ 3% or more, depending on the card.

Note that this is not the fee because it is not paid for by the people doing the transfer. Instead it is paid for by inflation (new bitcoins earned by the miners who process transactions), which means in effect that all holders of bitcoin are paying the cost of all transactions on the network in proportion to their bitcoin holdings. At present, the bitcoin rate of inflation is about 11% (ignore all the nonsense you read about bitcoin being a deflationary currency - it is nothing of the sort). So all things being equal, all holders of bitcoin will experience a devaluation of their holdings by 11% per year to pay for transactions made during that year.

At present direct transaction fees are minimal (a fraction of a percent) but this will have to change over time as bitcoin inflation falls (it halves every four years) so that miners will increasingly come to rely on transaction fees. Nobody knows what level transaction fees will be in the future or how they will be charged (this is a huge topic of research), but ultimately somebody has to pay for the costs of the network. There's no such thing as a free lunch (except maybe POS, but that's another story ....)

This is confusing and convoluted and does not address what the OP is asking about in any way whatsoever (with the minor exception of "at present direct transaction fees are minimal"). The weird monetary hypothesis being advanced here under the pretenses of talking about transaction fees has nothing to do with any of the economics directly surrounding merchant and customer adoption vs. credit cards.
hero member
Activity: 552
Merit: 501
Hi all,

doing an assignment for school and I would like to find information on if and if so why it is cheaper to pay with bitcoin instead of a debitcard or a creditcard when purchasing something online or with a debitcard even in a physical location. I would like to find numbers on the costs involved in these payments?

Thx a lot

http://blockchain.info/stats has the numbers you want. The cost per transaction at present is  about US$ 30 and the average transaction size in dollar terms is  about US$ 1,300, so as a percentage, the cost per transaction is just over 2%. This is somewhat less than the cost of credit card transactions, for which merchants pay ~ 3% or more, depending on the card.

Note that this is not the fee because it is not paid for by the people doing the transfer. Instead it is paid for by inflation (new bitcoins earned by the miners who process transactions), which means in effect that all holders of bitcoin are paying the cost of all transactions on the network in proportion to their bitcoin holdings. At present, the bitcoin rate of inflation is about 11% (ignore all the nonsense you read about bitcoin being a deflationary currency - it is nothing of the sort). So all things being equal, all holders of bitcoin will experience a devaluation of their holdings by 11% per year to pay for transactions made during that year.

At present direct transaction fees are minimal (a fraction of a percent) but this will have to change over time as bitcoin inflation falls (it halves every four years) so that miners will increasingly come to rely on transaction fees. Nobody knows what level transaction fees will be in the future or how they will be charged (this is a huge topic of research), but ultimately somebody has to pay for the costs of the network. There's no such thing as a free lunch (except maybe POS, but that's another story ....)



full member
Activity: 166
Merit: 100
Fast payment and no charge back for merchant.

For consumer, portable and lower transaction fee if his base currency is usd.

sr. member
Activity: 406
Merit: 250
There are serious advantages to merchants as well. No charge backs is a huge one as is the lack of fraud. 
hero member
Activity: 658
Merit: 500
Unless you are sending the money out of an exchange that collects always the transaction fee, you really don't need to pay any fee. The transfer might be a little more slow, but usually I didn't notice any difference in speed. Speed will be much more related to the general conditions of the network than on the fee. So, basically, bitcoin transfers are free or subject to a voluntary donation.

Check information on bitcoin here https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ


if you do not pay a fee and your coins are relatively new (less than a year since last spent), you risk your transaction taking days to confirm, but worse -- miners may not confirm your transaction at all. i always send the .0001 because -- why risk having to wait 3 days to have a transaction rejected? just my two cents...
legendary
Activity: 1455
Merit: 1033
Nothing like healthy scepticism and hard evidence
Unless you are sending the money out of an exchange that collects always the transaction fee, you really don't need to pay any fee. The transfer might be a little more slow, but usually I didn't notice any difference in speed. Speed will be much more related to the general conditions of the network than on the fee. So, basically, bitcoin transfers are free or subject to a voluntary donation.

Check information on bitcoin here https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/FAQ


hero member
Activity: 658
Merit: 500
it is not ideal for tiny micro payments (i.e. a few cents), but for larger payments it is extremely cheap. this is because the transfer cost is based on the size of data -- not a percentage of the amount transferred, like most/all electronic transfer methods. so, instead of getting charged a hefty flat fee and possibly a % on a wire transfer (depending on the type of business transacted), one could transfer the same amount of value instantly for only a matter or cents!
hero member
Activity: 667
Merit: 500
This might be a good starting point --

http://youtu.be/WqzS0mNYUpY
newbie
Activity: 9
Merit: 0
Hi all,

doing an assignment for school and I would like to find information on if and if so why it is cheaper to pay with bitcoin instead of a debitcard or a creditcard when purchasing something online or with a debitcard even in a physical location. I would like to find numbers on the costs involved in these payments?

Thx a lot
Pages:
Jump to: