Pages:
Author

Topic: [ANN] [ICO] Etheraffle - World's First Truly Decentralized Charitable Lottery! (Read 403 times)

jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
Quick update - we've implemented our random number picker AND made it more obvious per Sjyi's feedback!




You can read more about the update here!

Fantastic!

"RANDOMISE!" is obviously visible.

Etheraffle is constantly improving and the devs really listen.
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
Quick update - we've implemented our random number picker AND made it more obvious per Sjyi's feedback!




You can read more about the update here!
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
I would like to say that this is a great project. I will join you in ICO

Hi quockiencoltd

Glad to have you on board! Let us know if you have any questions!
newbie
Activity: 44
Merit: 0
I would like to say that this is a great project. I will join you in ICO
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!

Etheraffle is launching its Instagram! As well as the existing bounty available for simply following our Instagram @etheraffle, we are offering DOUBLE BONUS STAKES for every 'like' our first post receives!

Simply follow us, 'like' our posts, take a screenshot and report as normal with your other weekly reports.

Visit the Bounty Thread and fill out the Instagram Bounty Form to easily earn yourself some LOT tokens!!
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
where the company is located?

Hi yehor

The team and so the company (for now) are located in the U.K.
newbie
Activity: 126
Merit: 0
where the company is located?
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
Is it a good choice for such a project? recently was a firelotto they as I know, too, were more lucky and similar subjects how do you think you can excel at this?

Hello assasin21rus!

Thank you for the good question! Here is how we feel about the matter:


Firelotto are indeed our competitor, but we don't think they can compare to us at all. For a start they take a large cut of every ticket for themselves meaning smaller returns for investors.


In addition, there is every chance that  Firelotto steals your dividends and winnings which they can easily do because they are completely centralized meaning that you have to trust them with everything, unlike with Etheraffle.


They also don't publish their smart contracts meaning you are at risk from a Firelotto exit scam & them running away with all your money.


Their token doesn't pass the Howie test and so will be viewed as a security when the time comes, and so possibly illegal.


Their company representatives didn't know the URL to their own Github when we met them, and then later thought that showing us some javascript was the same thing as them showing their smart-contracts. If you read their ANN thread you will notice worrying concerns about their leadership and past scams they have been involved in, as well as them failing to pay out winner's prizes in a timely fashion, if at all. Our raffles are automatic, unlike Firelotto, meaning you withdraw your winnings whenever you want!


And worst of all, it seems like Firelotto are driven purely by greed since they take 10% for themselves and give nothing to charity! Our goal is to give as much to charity as possible! So we take 0% for ourselves!


In fact, we compared ourselves to a few other blockchain lotteries too and this was the result:

member
Activity: 322
Merit: 10
Is it a good choice for such a project? recently was a firelotto they as I know, too, were more lucky and similar subjects how do you think you can excel at this?
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
Devs:

Since I have purchased the raffle tickets, I have checked the results screen, but I don't see any "claims" for the LOT token Promotion.  I thought I would see them only on Saturdays.  Well, I still don't see it.

Would you please confirm the behavior for this?

Thanks,


Hi Sjyi

The claim button only appears on the main page on Saturday. We chose to do this because you can only claim once per week. So if you enter, then claimed your free LOT, then entered again, you wouldn't be able to get your second amount of LOT in the same week. So to avoid confusion we opted to have the "Redeem" button appear only on Saturdays.

However, the new update we just pushed last night introduces a way where you can redeem tokens from previous week's entries when you want - it's in the FAQ:


1) Go to the FAQ tab

2) Open the "Can I claim from a previous weeks" question

3) Pick which week you want to claim from via the drop down menu

4) If you have tokens awaiting you, click the redeem button!

Let us know if you have any further issues redeeming your tokens!
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
Hi Sjyi

Are you talking about the fees, which I don't think it is, or the code implementation and verification effort?

We are talking about both. The only way to automate it without human intervention would be via oracles, which is doable but costly. And the prize pool would have to shoulder that cost. Which would be fine for jackpot wins, since it'd be such a small percentage, but problematic for smaller wins. Especially wins like the two match one we are currently working on....


When I think about it, 10 weeks should be long enough, but a person like me, would somehow forget to claim the prize.  I would feel it would be extremely unfair.  But that is life.  Leaving the current method of claiming the winning should be good. 

Another option was of course to have no time limit whatsoever, and just have it available forever for withdrawal. But we didn't like that idea of ETH becoming "stuck" if left unclaimed forever. We thought it better to give a reasonable redemption period after which unclaimed prizes are reclaimed by the contract.


As far as whether to roll the unclaimed winning back into the prize pool or fund the charity, I would vote to roll it back on to the prize pool.  But then as the token holders, we can also suggest changing the behavior and vote on the issue.  This is another positive point.  The token holders control the behavior, not a central power.

That's the great thing - eventually the community as a whole can democratically vote on this! We prefer the prize pool method for now, since the amount raised for charity depends on the level of play, and more attractive prize pools will drive more play.

jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
Devs:

Since I have purchased the raffle tickets, I have checked the results screen, but I don't see any "claims" for the LOT token Promotion.  I thought I would see them only on Saturdays.  Well, I still don't see it.

Would you please confirm the behavior for this?

Thanks,
jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
Devs:

In the current contract code, the winnings need to be claimed within 10 week grace period after a drawing.

With all aspects of etheraffle being automated, why not automate the winning distribution as well?
The system has the information the address of the winning ticket(s).  I'm sure someone will forget to claim within the grace timeframe, but etheraffle supporting altruistic goals, automatic payment would be a great selling point on top of the current positives.


Hi Sjyi

Good question!

Our reasons for opting for a withdraw method, over a "push" method are threefold:

1) If we were to automate the sending of winnings, the contract would be open to a whole new class of re-entrancy bugs that could jeopardise its security.

2) If you look at what happens in the contract, you'll notice that any unredeemed prizes after the ten-week grace period roll back into the prize pool, so all non-winners benefit. We actually thought about maybe having this unclaimed fund going to the charity contract instead, and still might do so. What do you think?

Most importantly though:

3) It is expensive to automate, which is why our competitors, who send out winnings, do so manually, via an interaction with the contract by a centralized entity (be it human or bot), whom you have to trust to do this correctly and in a timely manner. We prefer our method whereby your prize winnings stay in the contract until you come to retrieve them.

With Etheraffle, you don't have to trust anyone in order to claim your ether!


Ah, I haven't thought about some of these issues.  Another proof that you guys are well prepared for the product.  Just curious about how expensive the automatic sends would be.  Are you talking about the fees, which I don't think it is, or the code implementation and verification effort?

When I think about it, 10 weeks should be long enough, but a person like me, would somehow forget to claim the prize.  I would feel it would be extremely unfair.  But that is life.  Leaving the current method of claiming the winning should be good. 

As far as whether to roll the unclaimed winning back into the prize pool or fund the charity, I would vote to roll it back on to the prize pool.  But then as the token holders, we can also suggest changing the behavior and vote on the issue.  This is another positive point.  The token holders control the behavior, not a central power.

copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
Devs:

In the current contract code, the winnings need to be claimed within 10 week grace period after a drawing.

With all aspects of etheraffle being automated, why not automate the winning distribution as well?
The system has the information the address of the winning ticket(s).  I'm sure someone will forget to claim within the grace timeframe, but etheraffle supporting altruistic goals, automatic payment would be a great selling point on top of the current positives.


Hi Sjyi

Good question!

Our reasons for opting for a withdraw method, over a "push" method are threefold:

1) If we were to automate the sending of winnings, the contract would be open to a whole new class of re-entrancy bugs that could jeopardise its security.

2) If you look at what happens in the contract, you'll notice that any unredeemed prizes after the ten-week grace period roll back into the prize pool, so all non-winners benefit. We actually thought about maybe having this unclaimed fund going to the charity contract instead, and still might do so. What do you think?

Most importantly though:

3) It is expensive to automate, which is why our competitors, who send out winnings, do so manually, via an interaction with the contract by a centralized entity (be it human or bot), whom you have to trust to do this correctly and in a timely manner. We prefer our method whereby your prize winnings stay in the contract until you come to retrieve them.

With Etheraffle, you don't have to trust anyone in order to claim your ether!
jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
Devs:

In the current contract code, the winnings need to be claimed within 10 week grace period after a drawing.

With all aspects of etheraffle being automated, why not automate the winning distribution as well?
The system has the information the address of the winning ticket(s).  I'm sure someone will forget to claim within the grace timeframe, but etheraffle supporting altruistic goals, automatic payment would be a great selling point on top of the current positives.
copper member
Activity: 80
Merit: 0
Join the Etheraffle ICO Today!
allocation for bounty program is 1.000.000 USD, how much token?
this project is unique for me and i want to join bounty and take part in it.

Hi. Taking the average price per LOT during the ICO, $1,000,000 = ~100,000,000 LOT.

It would be great to see you in the bounty. Head over to the Bounty Thread to get signed up!


Sjyi, I have forwarded your questions to the dev team.
member
Activity: 215
Merit: 10
iLink2Music
allocation for bounty program is 1.000.000 USD, how much token?
this project is unique for me and i want to join bounty and take part in it.
jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
The project is unique and funny, I like the project. Projects that have many colors in the logo. I want to ask what are the advantages and advantages of this project? I hope this project is a great success Grin

Here is a graph of comparison with other lotteries:
https://imgur.com/a/uDaPj
legendary
Activity: 1647
Merit: 1012
Practising Hebrew before visiting Israel
Internet gambling is always profitable but the problem is the field is filled with many players and blockchain-based gambling services fill a very small niche. I don't know if this ICO will be a success but the potential is there.
jr. member
Activity: 182
Merit: 1
...whats your proffit from this, if fee 0?

We agree that people are cooled to the idea of a lottery since all the existing blockchain ones do is copy real-world models but end up being worse! They are still centralized, take larger fees and do nothing for good causes.

Instead, we are aiming for a fully decentralized lottery who does raise money for good causes. We take ZERO fee because we want Etheraffle to be owned entirely by the LOT token holders, including ourselves! We will profit in exactly the same way any other LOT token holders do - with dividends that the LOT token gives. Our incentives are aligned exactly with yours - we want this to succeed.

We have made Etheraffle not because we want to own a lottery, but because we want everyone to own a lottery.

I don't know if Baltman's question was clearly answered.

Per the WP, each raffle's ticket sales allocation is broken down as follows:
Prize Pool: 67%
EthRelief Contract: 15%
Disbursal Contract: 15%
Overhead: 3%

So, 3% of the ticket sales goes to cover overhead.
I don't know how the LOT will be distributed, but if dev holds some LOT tockens, proportional amount of 15% of the disbursal contract should be distributed to devs as well as to other LOT token holders.  But this is my guess.  The official statement should clarify that further.
Pages:
Jump to: