Every bit of info I have helps :-D
I still use Crypsty because it's the only market for one of my coins. I haven't had any major problems, but I've seen some weird glitchy stuff the last couple weeks that makes me wary.
1) Made a withdrawal, didn't get my coins, so I contacted support. They said I didn't confirm it in email. I did, though. So, I went back to the email, confirmed it again and it was fine.
2) When loading a market, one time it sorted the buy orders from bottom (as in 1 satoshi buy orders) instead of from the top. As soon as I reloaded the page, it was fine. I can't even imagine what the programming looks like to make that happen, though.
3) Related to number 2. When loading a market, the price column was filled with the date the order was placed. Again, reloading the page fixed it.
Like I said, it's weird glitchy stuff, but it's stuff that makes absolutely zero sense, and is not situations where you're like, "oh yeah, I can see that happening." It really makes me question what's happening behind the scenes, and what their code looks like that's causing it.
To be honest on regular days I have had no issues at all with Cryptsy, support has been good and they seem to be consistent, also they are incorporated in the US and are now trading USD so they at least have more to loose if they do something really bad, so I like that better. On the negative side, weird things happen on really active days like on coin launches or during big pumps, seems like you cant log in or you loose opportunities because you cant place an order fast enough I think this is a combination of manipulation on their part to take advantage and inability to service the peak in demand. But other than loosing opportunity because the system lags on peak trading times Ive never had any issues.