I really think the power of Karmacoin is to empower people to do good and better themselves rather than, as Dogecoin is doing, just giving money to causes.
Teaching someone how to fish vs. giving them fish
Giving money to causes is good, yes. Where would humanity be without altruism? But in a lot of case, I think, donating is a temporary solution or just a bandage.
Not to knock Dogecoin, but the only project that comes close to have real global impact is "Doge 4 Water". This project aims to build 2 water wells in Kenya at a cost of about $34,000. It's a good start, but it won't have any real global impact.
Their goals are:
- build two (2) drilling wells in Kenya
- provide access to water
- provide tools to retrieve and store water
But why not, instead, train people how to repair broken water pumps instead of spending money to build new ones? The New York Times looked at the issue of maintaining water pumps
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/12/13/to-maintain-water-pumps-it-takes-more-than-a-village/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0The question is, who will pay to maintain these wells and pumps when they break? Who will train people in the surrounding communities how to use them properly?
"...governments and charitable groups install water pumps, well and other village water systems, but pay insufficient attention to keeping them running. Surveys show that between 30 and 40 percent of water points in rural Africa are out of commission. Many will never be repaired."
I have a close business associate in Kenya and he assures me this project won't work. It will also not benefit that many people. Who will police the well if the local mafia takes it over and charges exorbitant rates? This reminds me of all the clothing donations from rich countries that are sent to Africa that end up being hijacked and sold at markets at 100% profit instead of given away to those that need them.
Let's take a look at how Karmacoin could do it:
- for 10% of the cost, hire 5 people to go around Kenya for 6 months to different villages to train the locals how to repair their pumps
- contract with a Chinese factory to deliver something like Lifestraw for about $1.50 per unit (there are already a number of factories that can do this)
These solutions are cool and sexy and they probably wouldn't get much attention, which is what we need to really grow our community. But I think there are ways to make it interesting.