I've read the link mentioned
http://cryptolife.net/in-depth-analysis-nxt/ and I believe the analysis is good enough in the sense of giving precautions to whoever is thinking about "investing" in Nxt, and in counter-arguing against shills. I guess it can't hurt to hold a few Nxt, like it doesn't to hold a few Dogecoins, Hobonickels or Peercoins or whatever you believe has future, but ultimately what you do with your money it's only your business, not mine as a detractor neither is Nxt shills.
On a personal note -- if it isn't obvious already -- I'm becoming quite frankly fed up of Nxt promoters, Nxt shills and Nxt community. All I see are bag holders waiting to lure others into their dump. The situation fits well alongside scams, referral spam, excuses for large premines, IPOs and in other context, multilevel marketing or CPA offers. In short, bottom of the barrel self-serving garbage. The scrypt multipool that pays out in Nxt (and the agenda of some supporters with the explicit purpose of dumping others to pump themselves) caught my attention and illustrates at what extent people go. If they feel the need to dump others to pump their coin, they ARE bag holders of a coin that does not have real-life financial or economic value to stand on their own.
The software and the developers indeed have merit, however.
Right, I read your post about the mining pool and honestly thought, well no argument there and moved on. Everything you said has merit and I'd just be BS'ing if I tried to argue any of it.
For transparency sake though, I've bitched and complained about NXT for a long time. I was nearly banned by one of the mods on nextcoin.org. (Graviton actually had to prevent that, if you went and read my post history (same name on that forum) its just one negative thing after another for weeks/months, all warranted in my opinion).
That said, NXT is still in my opinion the only thing worth investing in long term. There is simply too much work being done on it and it's the only self-supporting alt. If it's not good enough, it can be modified/fixed/upgraded, whatever needs to be done to make it successful. The community over at potcoin is not going to re-code something or make major modifications to their code even if it requires it. I'm not pumping NXT, don't buy it, sell all of it, I don't care. Just recognize that it should be considered basically one of only a few names in the game.
The only way someone can innovate on Bitcoin is to change the fundamentals on which it was developed (most of which I think are excellent). The only way to change the fundamentals by which it was developed is to develop something
different.