Topic: Are Bitcoin private property - page 7. (Read 25325 times)
yes there is no doubt about this that bitcoin is a private currency, it does not belong to any group or state but it is a private currency of the person who is owning it.
yes bitcoin is a private property ans it is not the property of a state or a forum or of a single person, it is the property of the person who is really owing it, if you have 40 bitcoins then you are the owner of 40 Bitcoin and it is really your own property.
yes bitcoin is a private property and any one who hold bitcoin is the owner of these bitcoins.
bitcoin is the property of those people who are owning it, if i have 30 bitcoins in my wallet so i am the owner of 30 bitcoins.
I think he didn't mean to ask who the owner would be if possession is concerned.I think he meant to ask what would be the case in case of someone receiving the coins mistakenly
yes there is no doubt about this that bitcoin is a private property
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. Still confuse on private property thing. But yes, you do have a point. It is not government owned so it was a private property just like companies who were not owned by the government. Since we have some of bitcoins then we are the owners and it become a private property because government do not have any cut on it like having a tax on it.
None of the government own it so we call it as our private property but in a capitalist system of society the fiat is also considered as our private property and the land we own is also considered as our private property because we do hard work for it to earn that and make that for our self.
It is true that everything on the earth belong to God and have right on all the universe. But it is injustice that your government also claim an ownership on your land. If you spend your money to buy that then your government do not have any right to take it.
yes bitcoin is a private property no doubt a bout this .
ye bitcoin is a private property and not the property of one person.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. Still confuse on private property thing. But yes, you do have a point. It is not government owned so it was a private property just like companies who were not owned by the government. Since we have some of bitcoins then we are the owners and it become a private property because government do not have any cut on it like having a tax on it.
None of the government own it so we call it as our private property but in a capitalist system of society the fiat is also considered as our private property and the land we own is also considered as our private property because we do hard work for it to earn that and make that for our self.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. Still confuse on private property thing. But yes, you do have a point. It is not government owned so it was a private property just like companies who were not owned by the government. Since we have some of bitcoins then we are the owners and it become a private property because government do not have any cut on it like having a tax on it.
None of the government own it so we call it as our private property but in a capitalist system of society the fiat is also considered as our private property and the land we own is also considered as our private property because we do hard work for it to earn that and make that for our self.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. Still confuse on private property thing. But yes, you do have a point. It is not government owned so it was a private property just like companies who were not owned by the government. Since we have some of bitcoins then we are the owners and it become a private property because government do not have any cut on it like having a tax on it.
None of the government own it so we call it as our private property but in a capitalist system of society the fiat is also considered as our private property and the land we own is also considered as our private property because we do hard work for it to earn that and make that for our self.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. Still confuse on private property thing. But yes, you do have a point. It is not government owned so it was a private property just like companies who were not owned by the government. Since we have some of bitcoins then we are the owners and it become a private property because government do not have any cut on it like having a tax on it.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice. It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
but to me bitcoin is a private property, because every one has the right to hold it for how long time he wan to. there is no time frame for holding bitcoin, and the second is that ever one has the right to use bitcoin according to their own choice.
It is not a private property since we are able to hold, sell, buy, earn, and invest them. If it is a private property then it was regulated by a company or some people and the supply or the bitcoin would be really low. And its price is truly so high because it was being regulated by a company. They got hold of the price of it. Its price is stable. Maybe if it was a private property only some people have the capacity to have a bitcoin.
I am confused on what you are trying to say. Private property as to ownership? If it is that's the case, do you think we will be able to experience bitcoin today? If they keep it to their self and just sell like only a 10% of bitcoin would it become a hit! I do not think so.
If we keep it then we are the owner and it will become private property since you do not want other people to know your address and the bitcoin you have.
If we keep it then we are the owner and it will become private property since you do not want other people to know your address and the bitcoin you have.
Yes, bitcoin is private property and anyone who takes my coins is a thief. Because the probability of someone accidentally generating my private keys is zero.
yes it is a fact that bitcoin is the property of the those people who are owning it, it is not just like the fiat currency which is the property of the state and the private property of the people. By possessing bitcoin,you get the right to hold,sell,spend or let it lay idle in your wallet>Once you lose it anyhow you also lose the right to claim its ownership
I get your point. But I'm not sure we should use the word "right" as a "positive right", as some people (governments) could enforce this right (and be aggressive toward some people).I have one more example that could actually arise in reality:
> B sends money to A (and A sends "something" or some information to B). Then, we don't know why, everyone decides to change their Bitcoin rules and the result is that A can't get to spend his money in the new version.
So does A have a right to force other participants to use his arbitrary version of the Bitcoin, in order to be able to spend his money? I mean, could his justification of "I have the right to spend those bitcoins" be used while he attacks other people when trying to force them to change their stuff on their computers? I'm thinking about governments behavior and analogous justifications. Since I believe that bitcoins aren't priv. prop., that kind of justification is wrong.
bitcoin is the property of those people who are owning it, if i have 30 bitcoins in my wallet so i am the owner of 30 bitcoins.
yes it is right to say, so it is a private property, and the government of any stare or any other organization or department or any other person is not the owner of bitcoin and every one the owner of bitcoin which he has. Remember, Bitcoin technically doesn't sit or move, what does move is the private bitcoin address, so all you technically own is that address, so if its in your control, you own it, i guess.
A court will be pragmatic and look past this technicality. A bitcoin is a type of property -- a general intangible. Like a right to something.Jump to: