Hey folks. I realize this is poor form, but I am pulling the plug on this auction. I hope this is ok with you all, in light of the fact that 3 days have passed with no bids -- by my reckoning, there are no harmed parties here.
I really never wanted to sell this, I definitely didn't want to sell it at .25, so I never should have put it up for auction. The fact is, it seemed like a special item to me, and I thought others might find it to be so as well. Instead, I found myself defending the very idea of the auction against hostile criticism.
Had anyone bid, I would have absolutely honored the terms of the auction, of course. I think I have shown this with my other auctions.
If anyone has objections to my behavior, please contact me directly and we can discuss. In the meantime, I am locking this thread.
This was my mistake. I should not have tried to sell this item again, when I didn't really want to sell it in the first place. My apologies.
Topic: [AUCTION] Aluminum 1st Edition Trezor (Read 746 times)
People paid 3 BTC to get this item, and there are not many who did so. Doesn't matter how much USD it was -- it was paid in Bitcoin. (But if you care about the USD value back then, it was roughly 3 BTC = $400 iirc.)
I think that 0.25 BTC is a very fair, even cheap, for this collectible Trezor device. These are very rarely traded due to the nature and scarcity of the item.
Trezor devices do not have a battery. They're powered via the USB. Key seed bits are in a permanent memory, doesn't require electricity. And of course you'll have at least one backup of the seed in *any* case.
I think that 0.25 BTC is a very fair, even cheap, for this collectible Trezor device. These are very rarely traded due to the nature and scarcity of the item.
Trezor devices do not have a battery. They're powered via the USB. Key seed bits are in a permanent memory, doesn't require electricity. And of course you'll have at least one backup of the seed in *any* case.
Thanks for the info Anduck, the Aluminum Trezor is pretty cool and I wish I picked one up a while ago.
As for the battery, I feel that any device with a battery nowadays is destined to have some issue since the battery cannot last forever. Heck, we even have exploding batteries that completely obliterate the physical device.
People paid 3 BTC to get this item, and there are not many who did so. Doesn't matter how much USD it was -- it was paid in Bitcoin. (But if you care about the USD value back then, it was roughly 3 BTC = $400 iirc.)
I think that 0.25 BTC is a very fair, even cheap, for this collectible Trezor device. These are very rarely traded due to the nature and scarcity of the item.
Trezor devices do not have a battery. They're powered via the USB. Key seed bits are in a permanent memory, doesn't require electricity. And of course you'll have at least one backup of the seed in *any* case.
I think that 0.25 BTC is a very fair, even cheap, for this collectible Trezor device. These are very rarely traded due to the nature and scarcity of the item.
Trezor devices do not have a battery. They're powered via the USB. Key seed bits are in a permanent memory, doesn't require electricity. And of course you'll have at least one backup of the seed in *any* case.
It does look gorgeous, with or without the original packaging. I would love to pick it up, but my collection is on pause at the moment. I don't know why there are so many comments about your pricing, it's an auction with a reasonable start price - if you don't want to bid, move along.
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
Well I gotta ask what happens if the battery dies anybody know?
It does look gorgeous, with or without the original packaging. I would love to pick it up, but my collection is on pause at the moment. I don't know why there are so many comments about your pricing, it's an auction with a reasonable start price - if you don't want to bid, move along.
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
Well I gotta ask what happens if the battery dies anybody know?
It does look gorgeous, with or without the original packaging. I would love to pick it up, but my collection is on pause at the moment. I don't know why there are so many comments about your pricing, it's an auction with a reasonable start price - if you don't want to bid, move along.
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
I do have one question though, is it possible to replace the battery on these devices?
As a collectible, if it had *never* been opened, it would be pretty boring since it would be just a cardboard box and you couldn't see the device. Still, I get your point.
If you think that, then you don't understand collectibles. Unopened boxes are usually a lot more valuable than boxes which have been opened (let alone used). All time wisdom from the Simpsons: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TNUtreybeVE
IMO if you are afraid to take something out of the package then you aren't collecting it, you are just hoarding it. Part of collecting is that you get joy out of the object itself which usually means value-destroying acts like actually holding it or using it.
@Lauda the packaging for the aluminum Trezors was identical to the plastic models. If unopened there is no way to tell from the packaging that what is inside is aluminum or plastic. I have one and would not sell for 0.25 bitcoin so starting price seems fair. I really doubt Trezor will ever sell these again as they made me aware what a pain it was to machine those housings.
1) No, I'm not aware of any successful past sales of the 1st edition aluminum Trezor. That's why this is a special occasion!
Okay, thanks for answering.2) I'm a little stumped by your second question. We're doing all our auctions in USD now? This is how bitcoiners think these days? So every time someone sells a Casascius coin, their auction post includes an analysis of the US dollar value at time of purchase, and the projected US dollar value now? You've really lost me with this. (People are, of course, free to calculate their own conversions.)
They don't explicitly value the items in USD, but implicitly they do. I have explained this by stating that premiums have been dropping sharply since BTC has been rising.But I don't want to be accused of not answering your questions, so I *think* bitcoin was around $550 when I got this in May of 2014.
In May 2014, the price of Bitcoin was around ~$250.Because it's worth more to me than that. That's why people set a starting price sometimes. This is not strange. Can we just let people not bid, instead of passing judgement on the worthwhileness of the auction?
Then put a reserve price. If you want to make it hidden, you can try PM-ing someone beforehand (e.g. minerjones, lutpin, me, etc.). I did try to auction this back in December, at a different price, and was not successful. Trying again!
Why not start at 0 and see where the market takes it?
Because it's worth more to me than that. That's why people set a starting price sometimes. This is not strange. Can we just let people not bid, instead of passing judgement on the worthwhileness of the auction?
But I get what you're saying -- if the market value is less than .25, then we won't be able to accurately discover that.
Look, I've taught you something valuable about collectibles.
Thank you.
1) Do you know of any past (second hand) sales or auctions of this item?
2) What was the USD total price of the 3 BTC when the item was on sale?
Thanks.
2) What was the USD total price of the 3 BTC when the item was on sale?
Thanks.
1) No, I'm not aware of any successful past sales of the 1st edition aluminum Trezor. That's why this is a special occasion!
2) I'm a little stumped by your second question. We're doing all our auctions in USD now? This is how bitcoiners think these days? So every time someone sells a Casascius coin, their auction post includes an analysis of the US dollar value at time of purchase, and the projected US dollar value now? You've really lost me with this. (People are, of course, free to calculate their own conversions.)
But I don't want to be accused of not answering your questions, so I *think* bitcoin was around $550 when I got this in May of 2014.
I did try to auction this back in December, at a different price, and was not successful. Trying again!
Why not start at 0 and see where the market takes it?
Look, it is what it is.
Look, I've taught you something valuable about collectibles. If you have any more items that you may be *collecting*, it is best to not open them at all. It seems like you're advising people not to bid on my auction -- I admit, I was hoping they would.
No? I am not even able to say whether the asking price is reasonable or not considering that you have not answered my questions. I will try again:1) Do you know of any past (second hand) sales or auctions of this item?
2) What was the USD total price of the 3 BTC when the item was on sale?
Thanks.
Your points are fair. I'd argue that it's a collectible, and an excellent hardware wallet -- not only one-or-the-other.
I didn't mean to imply that it's mutually exclusive. I was rather just interested in your view of it.As a collectible, if it had *never* been opened, it would be pretty boring since it would be just a cardboard box and you couldn't see the device. Still, I get your point.
If you think that, then you don't understand collectibles. Unopened boxes are usually a lot more valuable than boxes which have been opened (let alone used).As a hardware wallet, I am the original owner, I got it directly from TREZOR, and I do not have anything remotely resembling the skills to hack it -- if that is even possible. If you'd like me to prove I'm not that smart, I'll gladly do so 
I didn't mean to imply that you would hack it. It is just not generally good to buy second hand hardware wallets, regardless who the seller is.As for the price, these were originally 3 BTC each, and they are no longer available. So are we pricing in dollars, BTC, collectible value... I really don't think this is an unfair starting price.
The pricing is in USD most of the time IMO. If you look closely, almost all premiums have been tanking sharply ever since BTC/USD has been on the rise. What was the USD value of those 3 BTC at the time? Look, it is what it is. I've explained and shown that it is open, but in good condition. I can't make it something that it isn't. If no one is interested at this price, that is ok. It seems like you're advising people not to bid on my auction -- I admit, I was hoping they would. I have tried to describe the item as accurately as possible, and was hoping there might be some interest. Maybe I misjudged.
Your points are fair. I'd argue that it's a collectible, and an excellent hardware wallet -- not only one-or-the-other.
I didn't mean to imply that it's mutually exclusive. I was rather just interested in your view of it.As a collectible, if it had *never* been opened, it would be pretty boring since it would be just a cardboard box and you couldn't see the device. Still, I get your point.
If you think that, then you don't understand collectibles. Unopened boxes are usually a lot more valuable than boxes which have been opened (let alone used).As a hardware wallet, I am the original owner, I got it directly from TREZOR, and I do not have anything remotely resembling the skills to hack it -- if that is even possible. If you'd like me to prove I'm not that smart, I'll gladly do so
I didn't mean to imply that you would hack it. It is just not generally good to buy second hand hardware wallets, regardless who the seller is.As for the price, these were originally 3 BTC each, and they are no longer available. So are we pricing in dollars, BTC, collectible value... I really don't think this is an unfair starting price.
The pricing is in USD most of the time IMO. If you look closely, almost all premiums have been tanking sharply ever since BTC/USD has been on the rise. What was the USD value of those 3 BTC at the time? Are you trying to sell this as a collectible or a hardware wallet? I am not sure about the price that a second hand Trezor would fetch. I would bid, but not with that starting price due to several reasons:
1) If you're trying to sell it as a collectible, it has already been opened and used.
2) If you're trying to sell it as a hardware wallet, it has already been used. It is completely not recommended to buy second hand hardware wallets unless one wants trouble.
1) If you're trying to sell it as a collectible, it has already been opened and used.
2) If you're trying to sell it as a hardware wallet, it has already been used. It is completely not recommended to buy second hand hardware wallets unless one wants trouble.
Starting bid: .25 BTC
Tl;dr: High starting price. Do you know of any other past auctions of this model?Your points are fair. I'd argue that it's a collectible, and an excellent hardware wallet -- not only one-or-the-other.
As a collectible, if it had *never* been opened, it would be pretty boring since it would be just a cardboard box and you couldn't see the device. Still, I get your point.
As a hardware wallet, I am the original owner, I got it directly from TREZOR, and I do not have anything remotely resembling the skills to hack it -- if that is even possible. If you'd like me to prove I'm not that smart, I'll gladly do so
As for the price, these were originally 3 BTC each, and they are no longer available. So are we pricing in dollars, BTC, collectible value... I really don't think this is an unfair starting price.
Glad to see one of these up for auction.
Has the recovery seed page been used?
Has the recovery seed page been used?
No, it has not! All of the original materials are in great, unused condition.
Are you trying to sell this as a collectible or a hardware wallet? I am not sure about the price that a second hand Trezor would fetch. I would bid, but not with that starting price due to several reasons:
1) If you're trying to sell it as a collectible, it has already been opened and used.
2) If you're trying to sell it as a hardware wallet, it has already been used. It is completely not recommended to buy second hand hardware wallets unless one wants trouble.
1) If you're trying to sell it as a collectible, it has already been opened and used.
2) If you're trying to sell it as a hardware wallet, it has already been used. It is completely not recommended to buy second hand hardware wallets unless one wants trouble.
Starting bid: .25 BTC
Tl;dr: High starting price. Do you know of any other past auctions of this model?
Glad to see one of these up for auction.
Has the recovery seed page been used?
Has the recovery seed page been used?
Jump to: