Topic: Banning gay men from giving blood is stupid - page 2. (Read 2677 times)

Right. Political correctness is getting in the way of issue.

This is a kind of right that MAY have some kind of threat. Rethink about it, it isn't stupid.

This is a difficult issue. If there is in fact a known higher risk of transmitting a disease from the blood of male homosexuals I can see not allowing them to give blood if there is no absolute way to rule out these diseases. At the same time it smacks of prejudice to exclude them.

My brother is a homosexual and I know how difficult it can be when you are treated as less than human, but my wife had 3 blood transfusions back in the early 1980's that could have been a death sentence for her so I can see both sides of this. 

We need to move this discussion beyond politics and focus on the human side of it.

The tests look for anti-bodies. What are anti-bodies? They are created by your immune system to fight off viruses. If you have anti-bodies of whatever in you're system, it means that you have effectively fought off the virus. This is basic 6th grade science... why is the most basic & obvious discarded? For Profits... that''s why!

Woah I was not even aware this was a thing still. That's disgusting. As long as they are tested there should be no issues.

The possibility of airborne Ebola does take precedence over this, I agree.

http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/33277/title/Ebola-from-Pigs-to-Monkeys/

This is such a sensationalist thread and we've got far bigger issues in society to be concerned about imo.

Yea, gay sex will get you the death sentence in many African & Muslim fundamentalist countries.
Nigeria is a good example.

In some regions, like Eastern Europe or Middle East a large part of society don't understand it. Cultural and religious factors are responsible for homophobia, transphobia, etc. In Islamic countries, the situation is probably the worst. Western problems are funny compared to them.

I'm more concerned about people like my roommate that live on fast food & GMO's giving blood... I wouldn't want that garbage in my system.

The debate was political from the start.

There are probably certain health concern which make them higher risk than an average person.

Should not turn valid issues into a political debacle.

I have no dog in this race. I guess I'm bisexual, but I only date transwomen. In my opinion, both the gay & black rights movements have gotten out of control. It's fucked up to put a label on every damn thing, as all it does is divide people. Personally, I like the fact that we are all human & that's good enough. The human race is unlikely to survive, when it's constantly fighting itself.

Yeah most of gay get more right than a normal people. And most of people more feel disgusting to black people than gay. They are laugh at black people but, defend the gay with human rights.

Poppers for one are a HUGE immune suppressant, as well as meth (both big in the gay community).
In the 60's & 70's people were smoking pot, dropping acid, taking shooms... that sort of thing.
Also if you look at the bath-house culture & the number of sexual partners involved in that would have. These folks were getting STD's left & right.
What difference did it make to them if you can clear most of them up with anti-biotics. Anti-biotics are immune suppressants on their own. Imaging taking multiple rounds of anti-biotic treatments.
It's enough to fry your immune system.
Dr. Robert Gallo, under pressure from the US government hypothesized that the retro-virus, HIV, was the cause of AIDS. The US government accepted this whole-heartedly without much research into it.
They were under pressure from many gay rights groups. The hypothesis was accepted as the truth & any other research into the matter was de-funded & blackballed.
At least look into what I'm saying. No-one should blindly accept anything without researching it first.
I would also recommend the documentary film "House of Numbers" & the follow-up "Positively False", they are both on You tube.

House of Numbers:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwgmzbnckII

Positively False:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-iccGpFto8

EDIT: Also I forgot to mention that those tested to have the retro-virus, HIV, were given highly toxic chemotherapy drugs (mainly AZT, which was rejected for use in cancer treatment because of how toxic it was) & now they are given anti-retro-viral drugs, while not as deadly as AZT... are still an immune suppressant.

If AIDS is a lifestyle disease then why wasn't it killing people left and right in the free sex and drug era of the 60s-70s?

Even the gay community itself called it the "gay cancer" before AIDS was known because it was something new and unheard of.

I think banning gay men from giving blood is completely stupid.
HIV doesn't even cause AIDS, it's a lifestyle disease. (ie, doing things to wear down your immune system).
Check out the work of Professor Peter Duesberg. He was interviewed on the Joe Rogan show recently:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1jj0mUYJ_g
& here's his flagship book... Inventing The AIDS Virus:
http://amzn.com/0895263998
It's quite the read at over 700 pages, but the dude knows his stuff. Unfortunately, he has been blackballed by the medical establishment & his funding has been cut.
Profit before people is a sad reality.

I think he has a point.. it's not about sexual preference but health. Where are you from? The post was rather short

Actually, the ban is not at all, stupid as the risk of STDs especially Aids is much higher in gay community, you also have to note that the blood test are not 100% http://std.about.com/od/herpes/f/herpesaccurate.htm the accuracy range from 92% to 99% depending on the test, and that is huge if you consider the numbers we are talking about in blood donations and risk % blood donation from gay community can be a concern

wait,wait,wait

gay people can't give blood 

btw, you can move it yourself

bottem left corner, move topic

I'm disease free, already checked.  But the fact I used them is an important red flag in finding people too stupid to check.  I know it's stupid, but when I'm sick one day, I want my blood coming from the cleanest sources possible.