Binance Raw trading data - page 2. | Bitcointalksearch.org

StarofBTC

hero member

Activity: 1148

Merit: 528

Quote from: glaz330 on March 26, 2019, 08:01:30 AM

I am trying to understand who is going to pay 1500+ $ for raw Binance historic data... https://coinograph.io/binance-historical-data/ | https://www.kaiko.com/pages/kaiko-pricing

I am trying to develop such a service but with a fee of 100~200 $.

What do you think?

Will anyone here, be interested in such service?

What price do you think is fair?

Raw data from Binance? is it not the same way you got it that others too can get it, I doubt if many people will make this as priority because I personally don’t see how their raw data can be of help to my trade, if you need to develop anything that will really be of help to many people, I will advise you develop what will help people make profit in their trading.

Moreover, the amount you are talking about is quite too expensive, do you know how much I will get if I just invest that in bitcoin and leave it for a very long term. $20 dollars would have been a fair price for many potential people that will patronize it.

Tytanowy Janusz

legendary

Activity: 2156

Merit: 1622

It depends. For litecoin in the worst case 100 positions on binance might be 0.6% which is definitely not enough while on IOST its 50%. +-20% of current price would be great.

You know what i mean? Sometimes whale put huge sell wall +5 to +10% higher and another whale seeing that being in accumulation phase run for it because he knows that its more than he would get constantly buying for few days pushing price even higher doing that. Seeing that in data would be helpful to understand that for AI bot.

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: Tytanowy Janusz on March 28, 2019, 09:08:38 AM

This is incomplete in my opinion and might be confusing for AI bots without full order book all the time. Big (fake or real) walls in order book very often push price in various directions that won't be visible for AI bot with only trade history.

Fair enough....

So do you think, that raw data in sync with an order book of say 100 positions, in both directions, is a good sample?

Ty in advance

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: Mpamaegbu on March 28, 2019, 08:21:54 AM

OP, honestly if anyone were interested initially and then seeing that you're just a Newbie would make them lose interest in your project. Who even pays for a bot services that high in price. BTW, there's nothing special about what you intend to supply as it can be found online already.

How exactly did you conclude that I am a Newbie? (on the forum yes)

Quote from: Mpamaegbu on March 28, 2019, 08:21:54 AM

BTW, there's nothing special about what you intend to supply as it can be found online already.

Please provide links, to check if you really understand what I am saying.

Ty

Tytanowy Janusz

legendary

Activity: 2156

Merit: 1622

This is incomplete in my opinion and might be confusing for AI bots without full order book all the time. Big (fake or real) walls in order book very often push price in various directions that won't be visible for AI bot with only trade history.

Mpamaegbu

legendary

Activity: 2716

Merit: 1225

Once a man, twice a child!

OP, honestly if anyone were interested initially and then seeing that you're just a Newbie would make them lose interest in your project. Who even pays for a bot services that high in price. BTW, there's nothing special about what you intend to supply as it can be found online already.

alisafidel58

full member

Activity: 364

Merit: 127

Quote from: butka on March 27, 2019, 02:40:57 AM

Does it mean the spreadsheet contains every individual trade ever made on every currency pair?

If so, I can see why this information can be pricey, but I still have a problem to see the usability in trading. Can you share something about how people use these data in practice?

Why would it be pricy when you can get the data is public. I didn't need any such data when I'm trading. These people who wish to sell the data when in fact you don't need such a thing when your trading a coin.

Pursuer

legendary

Activity: 1638

Merit: 1163

Where is my ring of blades...

you should focus on whether anybody would even want this type of data. I don't think it is even needed because most important of all, it won't help you trade any better by having or analyzing such data types. the altcoin market doesn't work like that.

Quote from: glaz330 on March 28, 2019, 03:52:54 AM

you need to know programming/networks/devops and spend some (a lot) money to build such service.... it is not an easy task

really? I have not done something like this ever since I never needed it but I think it is easy to fetch the trading history of an exchange as long as it is public and then store it somewhere.

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: dothebeats on March 27, 2019, 12:07:24 PM

Also, if you mean 'trade-by-trade' data, this, to me suggests that there is something wrong with how Binance handle their trading history and data for you to be able to come up with an updated and raw data on your own.

Thank you for your answer and suggestion, but I am not sure what do you mean by this sentence?

No Binance is handling their trading history as expected, you need to know programming/networks/devops and spend some (a lot) money to build such service.... it is not an easy task

dothebeats

legendary

Activity: 3542

Merit: 1352

Cashback 15%

Honestly, I don't think this will be of interest to the regular and local traders of Binance, however this may be of interest to some analysts and researchers that checks whether trading volumes and trades are being faked or not (the topic is being revived now, so yeah). Also, if you mean 'trade-by-trade' data, this, to me suggests that there is something wrong with how Binance handle their trading history and data for you to be able to come up with an updated and raw data on your own. Anyhow, you won't get some luck into posting such offer here but perhaps try another forum, or use the Services section instead and post it there.

Jating

hero member

Activity: 2842

Merit: 772

Quote from: glaz330 on March 27, 2019, 02:59:47 AM

Quote from: butka on March 27, 2019, 02:40:57 AM

Does it mean the spreadsheet contains every individual trade ever made on every currency pair?

If so, I can see why this information can be pricey, but I still have a problem to see the usability in trading. Can you share something about how people use these data in practice?

Yeap I am talking for this kind of information.

In practice, you can use that info to train an AI trader bot or test your strategy (bot or manual).

You can use the tick by tick data to extract all kind of useful info (point and figure, technical analysis, etc...)

Ok, now I understand why you guys needed such information.

And so you are asking if everyone here is interested to the bot that you are going to create?

Well there's a lot of bots already, but if you have something unique to offer then why not?

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: butka on March 27, 2019, 02:40:57 AM

Does it mean the spreadsheet contains every individual trade ever made on every currency pair?

If so, I can see why this information can be pricey, but I still have a problem to see the usability in trading. Can you share something about how people use these data in practice?

Yeap I am talking for this kind of information.

In practice, you can use that info to train an AI trader bot or test your strategy (bot or manual).

You can use the tick by tick data to extract all kind of useful info (point and figure, technical analysis, etc...)

butka

full member

Activity: 434

Merit: 246

I have a problem to understand these raw data

Quote from: glaz330 on March 26, 2019, 08:01:30 AM

raw Binance historic data...

Does it mean the spreadsheet contains every individual trade ever made on every currency pair?

If so, I can see why this information can be pricey, but I still have a problem to see the usability in trading. Can you share something about how people use these data in practice?

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: Zadicar on March 26, 2019, 06:26:07 PM

...since the cost too was very high and why would you have to make a service from raw trading data when most people can do it on their own?

I don't think that the average trader can make a service like this, (I am talking for tick by tick raw data), since it is a very challenging (+expensive) project.

Since the prices out there is out of reach for many traders (like me), I was thinking to only charge a fair amount after expenses.

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

Quote from: BitMaxz on March 26, 2019, 06:46:52 PM

They don't need to pay for raw or historical data for trading because you can just get it free from well-known tools online.

Check this sample of historical data below.

- https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/binance-coin/historical_data/usd
- https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/binance-coin/historical-data/

So you don't need to offer a service like this because no one would be interested.

Thank you for your answer.

I am talking for tick by tick raw data - all trades.

Can you find this kind of info for free?

Ty in advance!

BitMaxz

legendary

Activity: 3374

Merit: 3095

Playbet.io - Crypto Casino and Sportsbook

They don't need to pay for raw or historical data for trading because you can just get it free from well-known tools online.

Check this sample of historical data below.

- https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/binance-coin/historical_data/usd
- https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/binance-coin/historical-data/

So you don't need to offer a service like this because no one would be interested.

Zadicar

legendary

Activity: 1386

Merit: 1020

DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook

Just use it for your own good mate, you might make a fortune on that. So far, i think no one has fall for it as you mentioned since the cost too was very high and why would you have to make a service from raw trading data when most people can do it on their own? A lot of information is widely scattered all over the internet and people can just simply use it to analyze everything.

glaz330

newbie

Activity: 21

Merit: 0

20190731
As of today I have stored the following dates for all BTC pairs

Code:

20190324_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190325_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190326_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190327_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190328_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190410_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190411_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190412_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190413_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190414_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190415_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190416_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190417_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190418_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190419_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190420_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190421_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190422_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190423_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190424_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190425_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190426_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190427_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190428_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190429_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190430_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190501_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190502_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190503_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190504_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190505_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190506_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190507_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190508_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190509_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190510_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190511_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190512_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190513_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190514_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190515_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190522_15_25_06.db.tar.gz
20190523_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190524_07_33_07.db.tar.gz
20190525_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190526_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190526_21_23_53.db.tar.gz
20190527_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190527_05_47_29.db.tar.gz
20190527_06_14_09.db.tar.gz
20190528_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190529_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190530_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190531_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190601_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190602_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190603_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190604_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190605_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190606_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190607_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190608_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190609_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190610_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190611_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190612_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190613_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190614_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190615_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190616_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190617_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190618_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190619_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190620_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190621_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190622_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190623_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190624_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190625_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190626_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190627_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190628_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190629_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190630_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190701_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190702_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190702_09_50_47.db.tar.gz
20190702_10_09_46.db.tar.gz
20190703_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190703_07_06_45.db.tar.gz
20190703_10_19_43.db.tar.gz
20190704_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190705_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190706_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190707_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190708_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190709_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190710_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190711_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190712_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190713_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190714_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190715_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190716_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190717_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190718_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190719_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190720_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190721_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190722_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190723_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190724_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190725_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190726_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190727_00_00_00.db.tar.gz
20190728_00_00_00.db.tar.gz

20190402

Github link with first dataset

ORIGINAL QUESTION

Hello there,

I am trying to understand who is going to pay 1500+ $ for raw Binance historic data... https://coinograph.io/binance-historical-data/ | https://www.kaiko.com/pages/kaiko-pricing

I am trying to develop such a service but with a fee of 100~200 $.

What do you think?

Will anyone here, be interested in such service?

What price do you think is fair?

Thanks a lot.
G

Topic: Binance Raw trading data - page 2. (Read 575 times)