I think Silk Road will do more for getting rid of gang violence than anything the police could ever do.
This is an intriguing possibility. Imagine how much the gang violence in Mexico and Central America might be reduced, if demand for the services of those gangs were reduced by access to Silk Road, et al.
This is not an endorsement of Silk Road, et al., but an observation about priorities. Until recreational drugs are seen by regulators everywhere as a public health issue—as they are in the Netherlands, Portugal, and some other countries—rather than as a criminal issue, an step in the direction of less violence should be seen as a conditionally good thing.
Once again, engineers and entrepreneurs show the way.
Um...so long as contraband remains contraband the services of these groups will be in demand. The cartels will continue to battle over transit routes and supply chains unless the West eliminates the need by decriminalizing chemical and botanical experimentation and use. We are a long ways from that. We have guns to sell to the cartels, Wars on this and that to fund, and morality police to justify.
SR caters to tech savvy white guys that pay premium prices for their respective fix. It keeps the customer and the dealer relatively out of harm's way, if they are both smart. They are rarely both are smart. The busts will still happen, but in the traditional sense (guy in blue smells reefer, buyer is loose, seller is followed from his supplier. Most of the dealers still deal locally, and many of the buyers are local dealers. If you do not agree, read the SR forum.
I do not transact on SR because I have neither the desire nor need for the wares. I admit that I was curious about the marketplace after hearing about it as a result of following Bitcoin. The main intrigue for me now is the unique escrow process, and the fact that there are more scammers here and other places selling legal wares than are on SR selling stolen CCs, fake IDs, and illicit substances. Fascinating. I'm happy it exist to meet demand because it keeps otherwise non-violent people out of the morgue and out of prisons. I wish they would do away with the criminal products that have real world victims (stolen paypal, CCs, etc). Individual liberties stop where others' liberties begin blah, blah, blah.