Author

Topic: Bitcoin isn't legalized by RBI (What's the argument here?) (Read 1261 times)

newbie
Activity: 22
Merit: 0

Quote
RBI has not and will never legalize bitcoin, because by constitution they can not do so. There can be only one legal tender in a country printed by the Government, which is and will remain INR. That does not mean bitcoin is illegal. If bitcoin were illegal, then FlipKart voucher, Sudesko coupon, Amazon credit and even mobile recharge cards are all illegal.

This is wrong statement. In India, RBI only have the right to issue or recognize the currency/PNote/legal tender etc.RBI is constituted under special act 1934 (which was happened before Independence), even PM can’t interfere the RBI activities. Such a provision had given under this act1934.Few amendments has happened in the act but till date PM or any constitutional body can’t intervene the RBI activities (may recommend but cant order).

If bitcoin were illegal, then FlipKart voucher, Sudesko coupon, Amazon credit and even mobile recharge cards are all illegal.

Flipkart Vocuker and Amazon credits are not issued by flipkart or Amazon; these are issued by gift card companies(Flipkart- quicksilver, Amazon-GigtBig) and both are licensed under semi-closed prepaid payment instruments by Reserve Bank of India under section 7 of the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007 and mobile recharge comes under closed prepaid instruments( Reference  https://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/NotificationUser.aspx?Id=8993&Mode=0).Some time ago sodexo pass also stopped by RBI warning but later they approached to RBI and get it cleared to issue as a meal pass.
Hence RBI only have the right to consider Bitcoin as a legal tender/currency ; only a matter of time until other central banks considers.
legendary
Activity: 1662
Merit: 1050


No probs mate! Just gets a bit crazy when we hear these things after a lot of work around Bitcoin.

Can truly understand and I myself want to make it a recognized currency. It hurts when I think I am using a currency which is not legalized by RBI and anytime it can get bitcoin users in trouble. When I check the RBI facts of not accepting bitcoins, those facts are right in their own way but when I am doing nothing wrong with bitcoins and earn bitcoins from small jobs and campaigns, I feel bad about it.

Did you get time to check the video link I gave you to see what RBI governor Raghuram Rajan is saying about it ?

Can I start in India?

Bitcoin currency is considered illegal in India.

Not sure if you are Indian or not. But, it is better not to comment on something you do not know. Learn the truth from RBI governor...

http://youtu.be/Mu97yGzO_ok?t=22m29s

RBI has not and will never legalize bitcoin, because by constitution they can not do so. There can be only one legal tender in a country printed by the Government, which is and will remain INR. That does not mean bitcoin is illegal. If bitcoin were illegal, then FlipKart voucher, Sudesko coupon, Amazon credit and even mobile recharge cards are all illegal.
legendary
Activity: 2632
Merit: 1094


No probs mate! Just gets a bit crazy when we hear these things after a lot of work around Bitcoin.

Can truly understand and I myself want to make it a recognized currency. It hurts when I think I am using a currency which is not legalized by RBI and anytime it can get bitcoin users in trouble. When I check the RBI facts of not accepting bitcoins, those facts are right in their own way but when I am doing nothing wrong with bitcoins and earn bitcoins from small jobs and campaigns, I feel bad about it.
legendary
Activity: 1890
Merit: 1000
Landscaping Bitcoin for India!
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/any-bitcoin-atm-exist-in-india-1020840

Your statement was
Quote
Bitcoin currency is considered illegal in India.
This is hugely misleading and incorrect.

Being Legalized is a different topic altogether, which was not the reason why I even posted on that thread.

Hmm...That was a misunderstanding of mine but still the fact lies that bitcoins aren't accepted or recognized by RBI. I changed my statement in that thread.

No probs mate! Just gets a bit crazy when we hear these things after a lot of work around Bitcoin.
legendary
Activity: 2632
Merit: 1094
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/any-bitcoin-atm-exist-in-india-1020840

Your statement was
Quote
Bitcoin currency is considered illegal in India.
This is hugely misleading and incorrect.

Being Legalized is a different topic altogether, which was not the reason why I even posted on that thread.

Hmm...That was a misunderstanding of mine but still the fact lies that bitcoins aren't accepted or recognized by RBI. I changed my statement in that thread.
legendary
Activity: 1890
Merit: 1000
Landscaping Bitcoin for India!
I have myself read that bitcoins are not legalized (not recognized) by the RBI then why can't I say that on this forum? Should I blindly accept that bitcoins is legal when it's not. I too trade in bitcoins but sooner or later I'll stop if the currency is considered unauthorized by the RBI.


I'm shocked when people start accusing me for stating the truth. We should all work together and try to make this currency legal and recognized so that reputed banks too accept this currency as they accept USD, EURO and so on. But well, I guess nobody is interested in doing so.  Undecided

http://www.mondaq.com/india/x/310426/Financial+Services/Bitcoins+Legal+Or+Illegal+In+India

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/any-bitcoin-atm-exist-in-india-1020840

Your statement was
Quote
Bitcoin currency is considered illegal in India.
This is hugely misleading and incorrect.

Being Legalized is a different topic altogether, which was not the reason why I even posted on that thread.
legendary
Activity: 2632
Merit: 1094
I have myself read that bitcoins are not legalized (not recognized) by the RBI then why can't I say that on this forum? Should I blindly accept that bitcoins is legal when it's not. I too trade in bitcoins but sooner or later I'll stop if the currency is considered unauthorized by the RBI.


I'm shocked when people start accusing me for stating the truth. We should all work together and try to make this currency legal and recognized so that reputed banks too accept this currency as they accept USD, EURO and so on. But well, I guess nobody is interested in doing so.  Undecided

http://www.mondaq.com/india/x/310426/Financial+Services/Bitcoins+Legal+Or+Illegal+In+India
Jump to: