Topic: Bitcoin or Gold - page 4. (Read 2335 times)

Any investment that can make a profit can also cause us to lose money.  While both are considered potentially profitable investments, don't be naive and think that they won't lose you money.

As fuguebtc also said, profit or loss will depend on our knowledge and strategy and not decided by the market. If you have no knowledge or come up with a bad strategy, you will suffer serious losses even if bitcoin has great growth potential. Both are financial markets and the market is like a battlefield where there will be winners and losers. If you don't have a better strategy than others, you will become liquidity for others and vice versa.

It seems that we judge it wisely between bitcoin or gold with their respective advantages, it all depends on people to choose the investment itself and they also think about the advantages and disadvantages they will get, which investment is better depends on your risk tolerance to assess more carefully, depending on the purpose of the investment strategy, which you apply, with the amount of capital that you can handle the loss, taking into account the amount of utility you will get, the better depending on the market and type of asset, for investment purposes and deciding on all that.

Of all the investments we make, investors are interested in ensuring their losses are minimal by holding a portion of your portfolio in precious metals. This provides protection against losses that stocks can experience during a trend, and it is still effective today, and is used as a long-term investment.

That's right, bro, both are profitable investments, so no one has a problem choosing between the two, sometimes there are those who prefer investing in gold because when they buy and collect it, they can wear it as body jewelry, and they can also lend the gold. those are relatives who need it, because most ordinary people prefer objects that they can see with the naked eye and in the form of jewelry, if bitcoin is for those who rely on digital technology, however both are equally good for us to invest, when we have a lot of savings we can We use it to invest partly in Bitcoin and partly in gold, so that our investment in Bitcoin and gold is equal, because we won't lose if we invest in both.

It's not about fairness or anything because whether it's bitcoin or gold, both are good aspects to invest in since they can provide good returns and it's undeniable that until now bitcoin and gold have their own markets.
When we are in the gold community then surely they will consider gold better than bitcoin because of the advantages that gold provides and vice versa when we are in the bitcoin community then surely bitcoin will be the first choice with all the uniqueness and advantages that bitcoin has because consciously or not at this time bitcoin and gold have their own uniqueness so it is quite natural if both are still an option.

In this case I think the choice depends on ourselves now because seeing from its existence it is certain that they (bitcoin and gold) are a good thing so make our own choices and that does not mean when we choose one of bitcoin and gold we can consider the one that is not our choice is bad because the concept is not like that.

... and gold just hit an all time high of $2500.99 an ounce. 😋

 To be fair, gold or bitcoin are both potential investments and can bring profits. And profits will come from our knowledge and skills, not their decisions, so choosing gold or bitcoin is each person's choice because each person has their own strengths.


Investing in gold will be easier than investing in bitcoin if you learn about it. You find it difficult to invest in gold because you have never learned about it, just like many people say that investing in bitcoin is very complicated. Simply because they have never tried it and have experience with it, but if they take the time to try it, they will also realize that investing in bitcoin is not as difficult as they think.

Frankly, the reason we chose bitcoin is for profit. I believe that no one hates making a lot of money so in every debate about bitcoin and gold, most will choose bitcoin because its profits are more significant than what gold gives us.

Bitcoin can be more profitable than gold in terms of the uptrend of the cryptocurrency market, bitcoin can be more profitable but I think that is more likely to happen with longer trades than short trades because unlike altcoins, bitcoin doesn't experience skyrocketed increase in worth and I think bitcoin is even more stable than some of those altcoins. But when it comes to investing in gold, it doesn't depreciate in value like that and is more stable and guaranteed for pretty much lower risk takers to the bitcoin investments.

Heard many debates about Bitcoin and gold for investment. Many people think that gold is the best investment, while many people think that Bitcoin is the best investment. Everyone is right based on their own opinion. The price of gold does not fluctuate in the same way that the price of Bitcoin fluctuates i.e. is volatile.

I would give Bitcoin the highest priority when it comes to investing in these two assets. Because I am as familiar with the Bitcoin market as I am not familiar with the gold market, I have been able to gain a fair amount of experience with Bitcoin investing which makes it easier for me to invest in Bitcoin. As Bitcoin has risen steadily since its creation even hit all-time highs in history, perhaps it hasn't risen so high since the creation of gold. If we invest in Bitcoin as planned and hold it for a long time, it may give us more returns than gold.

I just finished reading through this thread, and I am not exactly sure where to start since surely as several members already mentioned, the bitcoin versus gold question has gone through several threads, and frequently ends up getting thrown into almost any thread in which the measuring of bitcoin's value versus price performance versus inevitability might be called into question.

Surely members here are going to be biased towards bitcoin, yet I was still surprised that there were so many members seeming to not really seeming to know the difference between bitcoin and gold sufficiently enough to articulate why the question of bitcoin versus gold is not merely some kind of a toss up in terms of advantages/disadvantages of each, even though surely we could assess almost any comparative investment in that kind of a way to suggest advantages/disadvantages of each.

So maybe a starting assessment might amount to what would be the purpose of investing into bitcoin as compared with gold, if there might be some question about whether bitcoin might be a hedge against dollar/fiat - based systems, so a kind of sound money, yet we should also be able to appreciate that largely bitcoin has been eating gold's lunch in the past 15-ish years, even though bitcoin really did not get much of any kind of a price discovery until it first having a price around 14 years ago.

So surely in some sense bitcoin has a bit of an unfair advantage over gold in the price discovery department since bitcoin happens to be so early in its adoption levels, so yeah, as some other members mentioned gold has had thousands of years of adoption, and bitcoin maybe only has around 1% of the world's adoption, even though maybe there is a question regarding the extent to which the whole of the world's population will end up adopting gold in one way or another, so even indirect involvement in bitcoin could end up affecting various monetary systems, yet there are also some technological barriers to adoption too, whether bitcoin is being used directly by people or if bitcoin might be merely bing used in certain ways behind various financial systems that come into being in the coming years.

Some members in this thread have mentioned gold's market cap being in the ballpark of $16 trillion and bitcoin's market cap being in the ballpark of $1.1 trillion which truly shows that bitcoin is currently priced at around 1/15th the size of gold...and if we look at various macro value systems (such as in what kinds of assets/currencies/monetary instruments value is currently stored in the world), we may well be able to appreciate that bitcoin's actual value is likely around 1,000x or greater than gold in terms of various monetary properties that had also been mentioned in this thread, which are verifiability, recognizability, durability, divisibility, scarcity, transportability, fungibility and perhaps even things like costs of storage and/or security and there may well be .

Whether bitcoin's price has to go up or gold's price has to come down in order to meet relative expected future fair values could take 50-200 years to work out the reaching of these fair values, so in the meantime, it seem that bitcoin is going to continue to eat gold's lunch unless some of the value assessment in regards to bitcoin's comparative value might be mistakenly measured.

Think about the whole matter in terms of where the total of the world's monetary value is currently being held in currencies, assets, properties, stocks, bonds, commodities, derivative products, art and collectables, and surely some of the representations of value is efficient and effectively representing value, but frequently these days a lot of premium value is held in a lot of items based on debasement of money and various kinds of debt instruments and debt relationships.

Gold has not historically backed the extra premium values of where value is held based on various aspects of gold's own inefficiencies, including the cumbersome nature of it's physicality, so even if we might not agree upon bitcoin's ability to back the various premium values in terms of bitcoin being a more efficient store of value, there still might be some agreement that bitcoin might be able to continue to absorb some of that value - in regards to Gresham law type principles, and even if it might not reach 1,000x gold's market cap, we might be able to agree that bitcoin is likely worth more than 1/15th of gold's market cap, and if you cannot agree, then you have a right to put your value wherever you like, even if bitcoin continues to take that value away from gold since more and more people are recognizing bitcoin as amongst the best places to hold value, if not the best currently available.


You are going to have fun staying poor if you believe that the debate between bitcoin's value versus gold's value is that much of a coin toss.  Yeah, sure there are folks in each camp, but that does not mean that the gold farts are actually understanding bitcoin well enough in order to understand and appreciate how gold has been taking market share from gold and likely going to continue to do so, since bitcoin is ultimately so much better than gold, but it still takes a while for value to continue to flow into bitcoin.


Yes.  You recognize the trend, which is likely going to continue, even though of course, no guarantees..

 

Nice short and fairly basic video, though it still might be too basic in terms of capturing some of the monetary dynamics that are currently going on between bitcoin and gold..


Of course, anyone starting to invest, might ONLY start out with cash and then add one investment at a time, so then there can be a question when it becomes necessary to diversify beyond just one investment, for example starting out with bitcoin and cash.

So if a person starts out with bitcoin and cash, then it could take a few years before the bitcoin investment might start to add up to something that is necessary to diversify beyond the two starting assets... and so the cash component would usually also include various kinds of back up funds such as an emergency fund, reserves and float, and so the back up funds and the bitcoin investment size could grow at the same time, even to have 3-6 months of expenses that are in the backup funds and an equivalent amount in bitcoin. If a guy is building up these funds at only 10% of his income, it could take 5-10 years just to reach the above described levels.

Of course if someone is coming into bitcoin and they already have savings and backup funds, and other investments, then they are starting from a different (and more advanced place), but I doubt that it is even accurate to presume very many folks to already have good investment practices (and cashflow management practices) prior to coming to bitcoin, so it seems a bit presumptuous also to presume that anyone needs to start out their investment in a diversified way unless they already have investments, then by definition they are more diversified than the normal beginner investor.. and I am more likely to presume that and overwhelming majority of folks are under invested and under savings rather than presuming that they are starting with much of anything.

If you are not starting with anything, then there is no need to start with both bitcoin and gold, yet if you are starting with something then what you already have might affect whether you might be ready to add both gold and bitcoin, and surely if you are ONLY able to add one, then why be fucking around with shitty ass and inferior gold unless you have some already existing investment into it or knowledge about it, and even then, it seems like a dumb place to invest as compared to bitcoin... but yeah, if you cannot resist investing into gold, then you would have to figure out your allocation.. probably no more than 5% the size of your bitcoin, but hey whatever guys can do what they like, if they believe that there might be some  justification to invest much if anything into gold.


I don't see why there is any need to invest into anything beyond just bitcoin and cash when first starting out , and it could take a few  years before your investment portfolio is big enough to start to add other assets. 

Traditional assets of differing classes would usually be described as stocks, bonds, properties, commodities and cash/cash equivalents.

It would also be dumb to include crypto into any supposed attempt to diversify assets - unless you limited any crypto to less than 10% of the size of your bitcoin holdings, and perhaps only after you built the bitcoin portion.. but crypto and shitcoins are already correlated to bitcoin, so there is no use diversifying into them, unless you are a gambler and you cannot resist gambling and so you want some gambling fix.

I still don't see why there would be any presumption to diversify, unless you are already starting out with various assets in your investment portfolio, and if that is the case, the size of your bitcoin position would first be developed in accordance with whatever other assets that you have in your investment portfolio and of course, in accordance with your 9 individual factors, which is the case that you need to account for your 9 individual factors no matter if you are a beginner investor or if you already have some investments/savings.


Which largely means that gold has barely even kept up with inflation (or the debasement of the dollar), and yeah in the future gold might do better, but I have my doubts.

Even if we were to strike bitcoin's first few years as being unfair and maybe start out with bitcoin at $1,000-ish (either starting in 2013 or maybe we could start from late 2016/early 2017 when bitcoin was around $1,000, so then we see that bitcoin has gotten right around a 60x price appreciation during that time.

The future is not known, yet there is no real evidence that the strength of bitcoin's investment thesis is getting any weaker against gold in the past 7-11 years, and surely the evidence seems to be getting stronger, including if we consider the ongoing building of bitcoin's various network effects (as outlined by Trace Mayer - specifically looking at increasing financialization through ETF spot products, and I am not even claiming that the ETF spot products are not attempting to manipulate Bitcoin in the process of their ways of holding bitcoin and/or the extent to which they maintain enough of a backing of whatever BTC they are supposedly representing by the ETF shares that they issue).


That seems like a silly proposition to suggest that you would have to choose one or another, even though even if there is a choice, I see little to no reason to own any gold, especially since bitcoin serves the same role.. and yeah, I suppose if push comes to shove, then maybe there might be some value in keeping some gold coins in case of an Armageddon.. but even that seems a bit silly.. but there are folks who are preppers who are preparing for Armageddon scenarios, so a bit of gold might fit in that... but still would not justify more than a few percentage points the size of the bitcoin holdings, since any of our preparations should not go beyond the likelihood of such a thing happening.. maybe 1% odds, and yeah after March2020, maybe the odds have gone up, but are the  odds of Armageddon greater than 10% even from the greatest of doomer/gloomers?. ..


Surely in recent times, nations are likely increasingly considering the possibility of adding bitcoin to their various kinds of reserves, and the fact that they are hesitant likely shows how early we continue to be in how bitcoin factors into political consciousness, even though so many folks are getting surprised about how much it had been raised in some of the latest of political talking points even from presidential candidates.


Even though you are quibbling with BitGoba in regards to how widespread bitcoin knowledge is, there is probably quite a bit of truth that even a lot of members of this forum are pretty weakly informed about bitcoin besides considering bitcoin as a kind of number go up technology or that bitcoin is somehow related to crypto (one of the various crypto options), so yeah, it could well be part of the reason that the world's population is probably ONLY around 1% invested into bitcoin, and perhaps even less or unwittingly not realizing that they are way under invested into bitcoin, and so it is likely still going to take awhile for bitcoin to get into the consciousnesses of people in terms  of its power and paradigm shifting dynamics in the way that value is stored, transmitted and empowering to individuals to hold value and information in bitcoin in self-sovereign ways that are ongoingly under attack too by various government and financial institutions that don't want people to be able to hold their own bitcoin and to be able directly transact with it.  A lot more obstacles in terms of transacting value directly between individuals using gold as compared with bitcoin.. but still bitcoin systems are in the process of ongoingly being worked upon and even attacked.


Volatility is generally in the upwards direction with bitcoin, so yeah there could be folks who are not able to figure out a way to invest into bitcoin for 4-10 years or longer., so they get caught up upon short term thinking about bitcoin rather than figuring out a way to invest a reasonable amount that is based on their discretionary income.. and yeah another problem is that people are not used to investing or figuring out ways to make sure that they have actual discretionary income that they can invest for 4-10 years or longer.


They might both have pros and cons, but it would be stupid to try to act like gold is even close to being equal to bitcoin in terms of the strength of their respective investment theses, but hey whatever, you do what you like if you want to believe that the comparison between bitcoin and gold is more or less a coin toss.


That sounds really dumb to me, to just put half into each... but I suppose if you don't know what you are investing into, then you may well end up making those kinds of seemingly ill-thought-out decisions.


You are thinking that bitcoin's current market value limits its upside potential and potentially considering that gold might have similar kinds of odds as bitcoin in terms of going up in price based on a seemingly bias towards unit values of bitcoin $60k sounds a lot to you so then $120k sounds like a lot too.

You seem a bit lost, and you might need to consider bitcoin in terms of market cap rather than getting caught up in regards to its unit value.

Perhaps you also might be helped by considering bitcoin in terms of satoshis rather than bitcoin.. but hey whatever, you are not the first person who thought that bitcoin's upside potential was limited, and the same kinds of talking points were made during the 2015/2016 period when there were thoughts about $1k to $5k being bitcoin's upper-side price potentials.

I am not really wanting to try to persuade you if you cannot see it, but if we think about bitcoin as having about a $1.1 trillion market cap, then we can consider how large of a market cap it might get easily and how much of a market cap might be difficult for it to achieve.  Another issue with bitcoin is that it likely has way less actual bitcoin than what is represented by the market cap due to the lost coins, but at the same time, we likely continue to have a decent amount of ongoing shenanigans with third party custodians claiming to have more coins that they do (and that is very risky for those 3rd party custodians if they get caught in that kind of a situation).   Value is likely held in around $900 trillion worth of various instruments, currencies, properties, assets, bonds, derivatives, or maybe even close to $1 quadrillion in today's dollars.. and so then my own number only brings us 900x to 1,000x of today's prices.. but bitcoin is likely contributing to the creation of more value too, just like other paradigm shifting dynamics in the world increased the possible value in the world that came from improved transportation, electricity, gun powder, steel, and other paradigm shifting inventions/discoveries. Bitcoin seems to be one of those paradigm-shifting inventions/discoveries... but hey whatever, if you believe that it is going to be difficult for bitcoin to double in price/market cap, then that's on you.


Sure.  Ways to get in and out of an investment would be important, so if someone is already used to investing in gold, then he knows where he can buy it and sell it, but even the verification process for gold seems problematic in the event that any of us might be wanting to deal with physical gold, and even if we have one or two places that we can buy/sell gold in person, if those places don't want to deal with you during a time that you would like to buy/sell your gold, then it seems difficult to help folks into becoming comfortable transacting in gold.

Bitcoin seems easier to get in and out of it, even though surely there are many of us in bitcoin who would like to have more face to face options to transact, yet also part of the tax treatment of bitcoin can cause some disincentives to transact but also the number go up technology will sometimes cause some folks to not want to sell, even though there might be some folks willing to receive bitcoin, but more devopment will also help in bitcoin in terms of potentially having more folks willing to transact in bitcoin, yet I suspect that many places are no where to even close to as open about being able to transact in bitcoin as El Salvador, so it could take quite a bit of time for less hostility to develop.. so there could be questions about those abilities to get in and out of bitcoin and how much KYC might also be involved when bitcoin does not natively require any KYC beyond just having compatible onchain wallets or perhaps compatible lighting wallets.


At least market cap is the more appropriate measurement, and surely it could take some time for more and more normies to begin to recognize and appreciate bitcoin as the superior place to put value, so in accordance with Gresham's law, more and more value will continue to flow into bitcoin, as compared to other kinds of currencies and/or other kinds of assets.  So you might be correct that more value has to flow into bitcoin to contribute towards bitcoin becoming more and more recognized, yet we already have institutions and/or governments putting $100s of millions into bitcoin or taking out $100s of millions from bitcoin, sometimes on a daily basis, so there is ability to move large chunks of value in and out of bitcoin in short term ways and still not move the BTC price very much - not that we always know which buys and/or which sells are contributing towards BTC price moves and while at the same time, sometimes witnessing a large variety of theories in terms of who might be buying and/or who might be selling.

Gold is a fixed real asset whose value increases periodically and you can own it as a real and stable asset. I see no reason to compare gold with bitcoin. If you want to start or increase your investment with Bitcoin, you should be aware of its volatile price and it can give you high profits through long-term investment.By depositing bitcoins you can increase your alternative asset flow and use a portion of disposable income. At the same time you must keep a pile of fixed assets as the future maintenance of your family should be prioritized.

The value of Gold is great, investing on it is profitable even though it takes a while but I just like the fact that it's price is stable, whereas Bitcoin depends on it's volatility to increase in price though it's not stable like Gold but that's what makes it a good commodity for investment the ability to reduce and increase, giving investors an opportunity to accumulate more and take profits when there's an upsurge, Gold investment is mostly done by very wealthy people only but anyone could own Bitcoin so far the person is working or has something that generates income and when it comes to popularity I think Bitcoin is becoming widespread across the globe with a fast pace, it is the best Alternative to fiat currency and with years to come the popularity of Bitcoin could attract the business sectors at large to consider using it more for transactions. However, I wonder who the OP bought Bitcoin from 20 years ago, it might be in another realm cause I don't think Bitcoin existed on planet earth by then.

The both the Bitcoin and the Gold investments everyone has his own advantage, but the only things that is there is that people said that what have advantages also have the disadvantages, so the Bitcoins investment has been becoming a popularity that everyone knows about unlike the Gold that is only fews of people that knows about it. For me I will not give anyone one advice to invest in Gold how rather recommended him a Bitcoins to h to begin his investment, especially newbies that never know how does the Gold investment operates.

maybe gold can give us a more stable investment, but I trust bitcoin more for my long-term investment. It's simple, bitcoin has a better potential for price increase compared to gold, people can also invest in bitcoin more controlled, and you can do DCA on bitcoin without any hassle.

The type of investment you mentioned, gold and bitcoin have their own advantages. Generally gold is considered a safe haven but especially in times of economic uncertainty. And since such precious metal has been permanent for a long time, familiarity and it is accompanied in the form of gold coins and jewellery.

On the other hand, Bitcoin is also a very historical currency and people in almost every region know about this Bitcoiner. We all know how profitable Bitcoin is. But there are many investors who held it long ago and will do well today.

If you want to invest in bitcoins, you need to know the basics such as how to buy and store bitcoins, and how to manage them. In this case, you should invest with a well planned and monitor the market changes. However, this also comes with high risk so you should research well before investing. There may also be safer investment options like gold that provide long-term protection.

Anyone can invest in bitcoin with the smallest amount of capital they have, but the barrier when investing in bitcoin is that not everyone knows how to buy and store it themselves. Some basic knowledge is required to get started with bitcoin, and that's a barrier for people of a generation like our parents or grandparents. Meanwhile, investing in gold is easier for them.


I believe that up to 99% of us choose bitcoin because its returns are superior to gold, but we also need to remember that the higher the returns, the higher the risks. Bitcoin is not as safe as we think, besides volatility, legality and liquidity are issues that cannot be compared to gold.

In general, both are good but there will still be advantages and disadvantages, and it will depend on each person's preferences to make the appropriate choice.

I don't think that bitcoin investment is good for short-term neither gold because they are called investment and the best way to make good profit from them is when you hodli and keep them for a long time because their values increases overtime.

Bitcoin is easy to invest in by everyone both the rich and the poor because you can buy as little as @$10 every week from your discretionary income for a long term to increase the amount of bitcoin you have. Bitcoin is new and the fast rate of growth is something that makes it worth investing in more than gold because if bitcoin gives you the opportunity to control your wealth yourself without a third-party.

Gold is good but I prefer bitcoin because it gives big profits than gold and no one will know if you have bitcoin without you telling them making your wealth a secret. A modern asset like bitcoin is good because of its great potential.

First, you can't buy Bitcoin 20 years ago because Bitcoin is not 20 years old, Bitcoin was only introduced in 2009. Maybe you can imagine if you invested in Bitcoin in 2009 or 2010 maybe now you are one of the richest people, but that is also impossible because at first when Bitcoin was introduced many people did not believe in Bitcoin and would not have thought Bitcoin would be like it is today.

Both of these investments, both BTC and Gold, must be included in our current portfolio because both have their own advantages and have their own characteristics for the future.

However, if you want to quickly get a lot of profit in the long term, BTC is the best choice but you must be prepared for the risk because its fluctuating price can give you a heart attack.

However, if you want to be safe, you can choose gold, because gold has been tested for thousands of years, and gold can also be processed into jewelry, currency, electronics, and so on. The choice is yours, but what is certain is that if you ask on this forum, people will definitely advise you to invest in BTC.

I choose Bitcoin, if you buy and hold gold for 10 years you will never compare the profit you will make holding Bitcoin for that long to that of gold, Bitcoin will change your life for good.
Bitcoin is one of the best investment right now in the world.
And it took Bitcoin some years to get to this point but it took gold thousand's of years to get to this point it is right now, so just imagine what will happen to Bitcoin in the next 10 to 20 years by then Bitcoin will be way more bigger than Gold.
I choose Bitcoin over and over again.

In terms of returns: gold is thousands of years old and it took hundreds of years to reach the level of stability it has today. Meanwhile, bitcoin is only 15 years old and adoption has yet to take place worldwide so it is too early to say that it will enter a period of gold-like stability. Not to mention, look at gold's capitalization of more than 16 trillion while bitcoin is just over 1 trillion, it is still too small or nothing compared to gold. That would make it considered a higher-risk asset, but its youth and smallness also give it room to grow stronger.

Bitcoin is not yet the main trend of the financial market, how can an asset with a small capitalization and not yet adopted worldwide become the main trend of the world financial market?