Pages:
Author

Topic: Bitcoin Vs the Banks debate - your ideas please - page 2. (Read 4756 times)

full member
Activity: 187
Merit: 100
>> Is Bitcoin just a redistribution of wealth from one group of people to another?

All commerce is a redistribution of wealth from one group of people to another.  Voluntary redistribution of wealth is a good thing.

When properly structured, the wealth flows to those that truly add value, and only voluntarily based on a win-win transaction.

I'll leave it up the reader to decide whether the current banking system, and 'quantitative easing' meet that criteria.



The question I would like asked and answered:

"Why would a bank not accept a business involved in Bitcoin?  It looks and smells like capricious behavior.  It seems to me that the bank's job should be to make sure deposits are safe, and only withdrawn by the owner directly or through a negotiable instrument.   I understand turning down a loan request because the perceived risk might be higher than say a widget manufacturer.  But where is their risk with deposits and withdrawals?"
 
Tron
Founder, CoinCPA


If you are quietly involved in criminal activities it is unwise to draw additional attention and publicity by offering services officials might take an interest in.
full member
Activity: 588
Merit: 107
>> Is Bitcoin just a redistribution of wealth from one group of people to another?

All commerce is a redistribution of wealth from one group of people to another.  Voluntary redistribution of wealth is a good thing.

When properly structured, the wealth flows to those that truly add value, and only voluntarily based on a win-win transaction.

I'll leave it up the reader to decide whether the current banking system, and 'quantitative easing' meet that criteria.



The question I would like asked and answered:

"Why would a bank not accept a business involved in Bitcoin?  It looks and smells like capricious behavior.  It seems to me that the bank's job should be to make sure deposits are safe, and only withdrawn by the owner directly or through a negotiable instrument.   I understand turning down a loan request because the perceived risk might be higher than say a widget manufacturer.  But where is their risk with deposits and withdrawals?"
 
Tron
Founder, CoinCPA
full member
Activity: 146
Merit: 100
I'd really like to get everyone's feedback on something. I have managed to get some free space London's O2 which is a huge venue and a bit of a coup. I know I am insane and have thrown myself in waaay too far at the wrong side of the pool but I'm doing it anyway and want to get people here involved.

This is what the venue looks like on the inside:


It has a 16x9 foot screen behind it as well on which I plan to place Mr Antonopoulos : )

The concept
A live adversarial debate on the state of Bitcoin following the hacks on its ecosystem. Here are some initial thoughts:

The issue I want to address is that while Satoshi got the protocol locked down pretty tight his innovation didn't allow for human error. It's all very well having a really secure piece of software but if exchanges etc have sloppy code then it is all undermined.

Trowing technology at some of the problems we face is not going to make them go away. Is Bitcoin just a redistribution of wealth from one group of people to another?

Code is the new law. Are coders the right people to be deciding what's right and what should be legislated?

Barclays have PingIt and there are many other emerging p2p payment networks so is Bitcoin even necessary as a standalone currency? Why can't the banking system simply integrate Bitcoins open source code in to their existing infrastructure?


I do not hold these views myself, I just want to address them as I hear them being raised by critics and think they need exploration.

Andreas Antonopoulos and I will be taking part, Max Keiser will be appearing later in the evening but have asked if he can attend earlier. I even have received interest from Barclays and Lloyds to take part in the debate.

I want your ideas, suggestions and questions that you would like to see addressed. I can select key questions from this thread and raise them on the day.

EDIT 27/3: Speakers for the panel are now confirmed and 110 people already signed up

EDIT 22/3: Andreas has had to cancel along with some other speaking arrangements https://twitter.com/aantonop/status/447102361815617536

Am working hard now on finding a replacement, any ideas/help are welcome.
Pages:
Jump to: