my take is the halving as an event can be priced in, just like that. but the long term supply effects that will be felt over the coming years---that can't be effectively priced in this early. in that way, a lot of us are talking about two different things.
You articulated it better than me. That's what I was clawing towards.
I assume these people are talking long term rather than short term but perhaps they didn't make it very clear. I don't expect anything other than a pump and dump in the next few months myself. If there isn't then it'll be a pleasant surprise.