Pages:
Author

Topic: Bitcoinica charges for open positions, pays you for storing funds on them (Read 3058 times)

hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500
Can someone explain this to me like I'm 5?

From here

Quote
When you open a trade, you sell one currency and buy another. Since the currencies charge different interest rates, you can either collect interest (positive swap) or pay interest (negative swap).

If you borrow a low-rate currency to buy a high rate currency, you should earn interest. If you do the opposite, you pay.

Let's say you are trading USD/JPY. If you want to long USD/JPY what you are in fact doing is buying USD with your JPY. However, since you don't actually have any JPY, you need to borrow it first and use a part of your margin as collateral for that loan. Once you have borrowed the necessary amount of JPY, you can use it to buy USD and there is your trade. Now, since you actually borrowed the JPY, you have to pay interest on that loan at the prevailing rate until you have paid back the loan (closed your trade), and since you are holding USD, you are being paid interest on that sum for as long as you are holding it. The difference between what you are paying and what you are collecting in interest is what your swap will come out to be.
donator
Activity: 980
Merit: 1004
felonious vagrancy, personified
Can someone explain this to me like I'm 5?

Dear little legitnick,

Since you are five years old, you should not be using Bitcoinica.

Happy?
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
  • Oh dear #2.  The BTC bought with your 100,000 USD are no longer worth 100,000 USD.

When Bitcoinica users are making net losses, the losses are deducted from their own accounts. You still get your $100,000.

Yes; I was too hasty with that point.  Withdrawn.  I've gotten my Bitcoinica issues the wrong way around.  My worry is that you can't cover profits; not losses... but that's been covered in a different thread, so let's not reopen it here.

My other point stands though...

  • Oh dear #1.  Bitcoinica can't just liquidate random positions to get you your 100,000 USD; this is therefore not a demand-deposit account.  You'll have to wait for those longs to liquidate.

Are you going to operate some sort of 10 day notification period for withdrawls?

Are you going to assume all deposits are fair game for use as reserve, or will it be opt-in?

When our customers have deposited a lot of money into Bitcoinica, we will set out a fixed reserve for withdrawals and liquidation of positions during redflag events. We will make sure that everyone is able to withdraw on demand. And we have also got a Trusted Mt. Gox account that allows $100,000 of withdrawals everyday.
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
Zhountong:  you have plans to create its own exchange? I think it will help the inflow of fresh money ..

No, there're no plans for independent exchange now. We will continue using Mt. Gox.
hero member
Activity: 616
Merit: 502
Zhountong:  you have plans to create its own exchange? I think it will help the inflow of fresh money ..
legendary
Activity: 1222
Merit: 1016
Live and Let Live
this is bound to help solve the liquidity problems on bitcoinica... and a very natural and smart solutions...

Z  +1 on the swaps  Grin
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 502
  • Oh dear #2.  The BTC bought with your 100,000 USD are no longer worth 100,000 USD.

When Bitcoinica users are making net losses, the losses are deducted from their own accounts. You still get your $100,000.

Yes; I was too hasty with that point.  Withdrawn.  I've gotten my Bitcoinica issues the wrong way around.  My worry is that you can't cover profits; not losses... but that's been covered in a different thread, so let's not reopen it here.

My other point stands though...

  • Oh dear #1.  Bitcoinica can't just liquidate random positions to get you your 100,000 USD; this is therefore not a demand-deposit account.  You'll have to wait for those longs to liquidate.

Are you going to operate some sort of 10 day notification period for withdrawls?

Are you going to assume all deposits are fair game for use as reserve, or will it be opt-in?
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
  • You deposit 100,000 USD at Bitcoinica
  • Bitcoinica lifts the "*" and uses your USD to buy BTC for leveraged long risk takers
  • Leveraged risk takers lose when market moves against long risk takers
  • One week later, you want your 100,000 USD back
  • Oh dear #1.  Bitcoinica can't just liquidate random positions to get you your 100,000 USD; this is therefore not a demand-deposit account.  You'll have to wait for those longs to liquidate.
  • Oh dear #2.  The BTC bought with your 100,000 USD are no longer worth 100,000 USD.

I'll say it again: Bitcoinica is backing its users net imbalance (at best).  That means they are relying on their users to make a net profit.  If their users make a net loss, then Bitcoinica makes a net loss.  When it's their own reserves... well whatever; but this new plan is to use your money instead of their own as reserve.  What happens then when their users make a net loss?


When Bitcoinica users are making net losses, the losses are deducted from their own accounts. You still get your $100,000.
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 502
  • You deposit 100,000 USD at Bitcoinica
  • Bitcoinica lifts the "*" and uses your USD to buy BTC for leveraged long risk takers
  • Leveraged risk takers lose when market moves against long risk takers
  • One week later, you want your 100,000 USD back
  • Oh dear #1.  Bitcoinica can't just liquidate random positions to get you your 100,000 USD; this is therefore not a demand-deposit account.  You'll have to wait for those longs to liquidate.
  • Oh dear #2.  The BTC bought with your 100,000 USD are no longer worth 100,000 USD.Withdrawn

I'll say it again: Bitcoinica is backing its users net imbalance (at best).  That means they are relying on their users to make a net profit.  If their users make a net loss, then Bitcoinica makes a net loss.  When it's their own reserves... well whatever; but this new plan is to use your money instead of their own as reserve.  What happens then when their users make a net loss?.Withdrawn.
legendary
Activity: 1458
Merit: 1006
Yes. You're right. 17% risk free. Paid daily. (...) We are short of USD now, and that's why the interest rate is so high.

Would be time to head for the bank. Except... Are you insured against any losses of deposited funds?
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
Wait, do i understand tha right? You are paying 17% anno, for my usd balance on Bitcoinica?Huh

Yes. You're right. 17% risk free. Paid daily. But the interest rate is a variable, depending on the supply and demand of money.

We are short of USD now, and that's why the interest rate is so high.
hero member
Activity: 532
Merit: 500
Can someone explain this to me like I'm 5?
full member
Activity: 131
Merit: 100
Wait, do i understand tha right? You are paying 17% anno, for my usd balance on Bitcoinica?Huh
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
Zhountong: please do make an official announcement explaining all the terms and possible situations for your users, because when I looked it up first I was confused really hard (and I'm still not certain that I understand fully how this works).

Sure, I will do it in a few hours on the forum. Thanks for your support!
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
Is this related to the new "swap" column; and "unrealized swap" summary item?

Yes, exactly. But they don't count towards your currency balance until February 16 UTC.

So if you close your position before we start settling the swaps, you won't be affected by this change.
hero member
Activity: 607
Merit: 500
Zhountong: please do make an official announcement explaining all the terms and possible situations for your users, because when I looked it up first I was confused really hard (and I'm still not certain that I understand fully how this works).
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
so ppl who started LONG at 2 will be kinda "forced" to liquidate or they will have to pay fees for that position

It's not significant. At current rate (which could be highest in history), it costs $0.21 per hour to maintain a 5,000 BTC long position start at $2, or just $5.04 per day, or just 0.7% of unrealized profits per month.
hero member
Activity: 504
Merit: 502
Is this related to the new "swap" column; and "unrealized swap" summary item?
vip
Activity: 490
Merit: 502
Today's interest rates:

Pages:
Jump to: