Not sure if they are a scam or not but I've asked the following questions on the telegram channel but I GOT KICKED OUT for no reason. I didn't say anything offensive. I didn't insult anyone. All I wanted was answers to a few questions before I can make up my mind to invest. Here are the questions again. I urge people to *NOT* invest in bitindia until someone from their team answers the following questions:
1) Referring to following tweets by Vitalik -
https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/922802902019608577https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/922809246508400645 A "completely" decentralized exchange cannot do fiat. Since bitindia boasts of a decentralized exchange that would connect to fiat, I really want to understand how would that happen. If what Vitalik is saying is true, bitindia is either *not* a completely decentralized exchange or they are not truthful about (or will change their mind later) connecting to fiat.
2) They are trying to hide how much money they have raised so far. They seem to change the contract every few hours to obfuscate the users but the whole point of this system is transparency. Can they publicly share all contract addresses so that folks can audit how much money they have raised so far? I would be more confident throwing in some money if I know others are chipping in too. Seems like a terrible strategy on they behalf to not reveal their number. Their marketing guy should be fired (in my opinion).
3) They are not clear on how much are they trying to actually raise. I've heard numbers as big as 100 million USD. Why are they not publishing their target USD/ETH number on their website? Also, to be honest, I don't understand why they need that kind of money. Considering they are based in a small town in India, their development costs should be very less. Including all other expenses as well, even a figure of 5 million seems like a lot to pull this project off.
s
4) Their team looks really unimpressive. None of the founders have any experience on working on any cryptography/cryptocurrency related tech projects before (let's discount the fact that McAfee himself is not gonna contribute jack shit). They just seem to have bitcoin trading/trading systems experience which is not impressive at all. Also, one of the founders seemed to have been a part of another failed ICO (Cove identity). Forget the project, I'm not even sure if they will be able to pull off this ICO (I hope people don't lose a lot of money here).
5) Founders have reserved a 25% equity for themselves. Isn't that number huge? Satoshi Nakamoto kept 1 million of the 21 million BTC (<5%). Keeping 25% of the currency in the hands of a few individuals always raises my eyebrows because these whales, more often than not, try to monopolize the market using their control that they leverage on the currency. Might also hint on the fact that the team might be greedy.
6) The project seems to have terrible marketing. The concept of decentralization ends nation states / borders. Decentralized exchanges are meant to be used worldwide. What do they mean by "Decentralized exchange for the streets of India"? I don't get it. Can only people from India use this exchange? If yes, how are they decentralized then? If not, what's up with fake India based marketing?
Really looking for *genuine* answers to these questions before I put a single ether down.