BitBar "Premine" allegationsIt is always helpful for new coins to be analyzed and vetted out by the community. In doing this, subSTRATA has brought up some potential issues with BitBar's launch. Let's break down his allegations and put this to rest.
1. 60 blocks after the genesis block were premined
This was indeed true, as a testing error. See here for more information, as well as the tester's admission of error. Those bitbars are being donated as a bounty towards the exchange. See the official launch topic here.2. Difficulty for the first 735 blocks was so low that it can't even be shown on the explorer
Several coins launched that exact same way:
* Feathercoin launched with difficulty 0
* Terracoin launched with difficulty 1 (just as low as 0 in effect)
* Chinacoin launched with difficulty 0
* Novacoin launched with difficulty 0
Let's look at the Feathercoin launch, for example:
* Exactly 24 hours after launch (2013-04-17 21:48:40) 2,898,850 Feathercoins had been mined
* There are currently 6,415,200 Feathercoins as of 5/5/13 at 3:20PM EST. This means that around 50% of the total Feathercoin supply as of 5/5/13 was mined in the first 24 hours.
* 20,000 Feathercoins were mined in the first 8 minutes.
* Feathercoin also started with difficulty of 0, just like BitBar.
Beyond Feathercoin, 2 million PPCoins were mined in the first day.
This makes BitBar's launch very similar to other launches of established coins with a trading market behind them. 3. For the premine period, 59.644201 BTB were generated in little less than 4 minutes
See point above. Current BitBar difficulty and block reward is adjusting predictably to handle the load.4. For the difficulty under 0.001 period excluding the premine period, 600.324139 BTB were created in little more than 20 minutes
See point above.So, what's it worth?Well. The value of any cryptocurrency (and any currency in general) is really what people want to pay for it. However, RustyShackleford1950 has a good analysis of potential BitBar value using historicals from a few other coins:
If we want to estimate the exchange value let's compare it against litecoin:
Litecoin:
Network Hash: 16,759,472 kH/s
Total Supply: 17,392,400 LTC
Current value: 3.14 USD/LTC
Bitbar:
Network Hash: 700,000 kH/s
Total Supply: 2,800 BTB
Theoretical value: 815 LTC/BTB.
Which seems insanely high (24BTC/BTB). And it is, it doesn't take into consideration adoption, reputation, age, etc.
So compare it to one of the lamer coins of recent times, feathercoin;
Feathercoin:
Network Hash: 1,133,753 kH/s
Total Supply: 6,505,600 FTC
Current value: 0.22018 USD/FTC
Bitbar:
Network Hash: 700,000 kH/s
Total Supply: 2,800 BTB
Theoretical value: 315.8 FTC/BTB.
Which would value bitbar at about $70 USD/BTB (0.65 BTC), which seems very low (probably due to the problems feathercoin currently has).
So there's a rough high and low point for the exchange to base the price from.
My personal feeling is that around 10 BTC/BTB is a fair price IN THE LONG TERM. Short term price, anywhere between 1.5BTC/BTB - 2.0 BTC/BTB.