BTC spot ETF: Wall Street's Trojan horse

Vincom

member

Activity: 182

Merit: 46

₿itcoin maximalist

Quote from: Abiky on March 26, 2024, 07:53:54 AM

Well, institutional investment companies have only been able to acquire around 1℅ of the circulating supply (particularly BlackRock). The rest is held by centralized exchanges, and self-custodied wallets. People just need to stop selling their coins to these entities to avoid monopolizing BTC in the long run.

Selling P2P or F2F (Face-to-Face) to another person ensures Bitcoin remains an equitable cryptocurrency for all. As long as the core Blockchain network remains decentralized, there should be nothing to worry about.

I doubt that investors will continue to self-custody BTC if they see the convenience and popularity of spot BTC ETFs. I don't think ETF funds need to self-accumulate BTC, they just need to secure the amount of BTC in their budget to be able to issue ETFs. They will buy and I believe there will always be people willing to sell in the market, problem is just price and volume.

I still believe that BTC will continue to exist in the future as a valuable asset, I'm just worried about investor sentiment: they may want something as simple as ETFs instead of having to do the complex task of buying, storing and protecting private keys.

Abiky

legendary

Activity: 3220

Merit: 1363

www.Crypto.Games: Multiple coins, multiple games

Quote from: Vincom on March 24, 2024, 04:53:02 PM

We are seeing the positive impacts of spot BTC ETFs on the entire crypto market, and we enjoy this because we are making a profit from the price increase of the tokens. As you said, things could get worse when BTC becomes a financial instrument like others in the hands of the Wall Street wolves, and we will only be like sheep and be deprived of the core values of Bitcoin that Satoshi tried to build. I'm afraid that at some point, the majority of BTC will be held in ETFs instead of being self-custody by real users.

Well, institutional investment companies have only been able to acquire around 1℅ of the circulating supply (particularly BlackRock). The rest is held by centralized exchanges, and self-custodied wallets. People just need to stop selling their coins to these entities to avoid monopolizing BTC in the long run.

Selling P2P or F2F (Face-to-Face) to another person ensures Bitcoin remains an equitable cryptocurrency for all. As long as the core Blockchain network remains decentralized, there should be nothing to worry about.

Vincom

member

Activity: 182

Merit: 46

₿itcoin maximalist

Quote from: Abiky on March 22, 2024, 09:24:52 PM

I neither support the securitization or tokenization of BTC. It makes Bitcoin look like a product or investment tool instead of a currency. The approval of spot ETFs is certaintly the degeneration of BTC as it integrates itself into the corrupt financial system it was meant to replace in the first place. Large institutional investment companies will acquire all of the BTC (or most of it), leaving us with no ability to self-custody our coins (therefore increasing centralization). The network itself will remain decentralized, though. Only if most of the miners and node operators aren't owned by institutions, governments, and/or companies.

Price-wise, ETFs are good for Bitcoin because they add greater demand on the market. But they're bad because of the reasons mentioned earlier. Everybody wants to make money, so no one will care if BTC becomes centralized as long as they turn a profit. The future is not as bright as we thought it would be. Lets enjoy the ride while it lasts.

We are seeing the positive impacts of spot BTC ETFs on the entire crypto market, and we enjoy this because we are making a profit from the price increase of the tokens. As you said, things could get worse when BTC becomes a financial instrument like others in the hands of the Wall Street wolves, and we will only be like sheep and be deprived of the core values of Bitcoin that Satoshi tried to build. I'm afraid that at some point, the majority of BTC will be held in ETFs instead of being self-custody by real users.

InCap Live

newbie

Activity: 4

Merit: 0

Quote from: hatshepsut93 on March 22, 2024, 06:24:41 PM

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?

It can't be called degeneracy because Satoshi and Core developers didn't put any features in Bitcoin that would prevent centralized use of it. The very nature of Bitcoin allows such use. There nothing anyone can do to stop insitutions from buying BTC and locking it in ETF. So it's rather a sign of maturity, that Bitcoin survived long enough to be recognized by the mainstream economy as a valuable asset and not a temporary mania.

And it's possible to theorize about negative effects of centralization of a large part of supply, but it's important to take a step back and remember that everyone is free to use Bitcoin however they like, including selling it to ETFs. Because ETFs can't really tell you how to use your coins either.

You nailed it hatshepsut93! Please give this person some rep if you can. BTC is supposed to be about freedom and people can voluntarily participate in centralized activities and institutions if they want to.

bluebit25

sr. member

Activity: 1708

Merit: 295

https://bitlist.co

IMO, the BTC spot ETF creates a historic milestone for bitcoin and the cryptocurrency market. This event is bringing a lot of positive changes by the time it is confirmed.

1. yep
2. the maturity
3. I think that negativity is only due to the perspective of looking at the problem, the reality is that there are problems associated with any subject but we are in an exciting market phase so the positivity prevails more.

Abiky

legendary

Activity: 3220

Merit: 1363

www.Crypto.Games: Multiple coins, multiple games

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

I would like to know your opinion on this issue:

Do you support securitization or tokenization?
BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?
Does BTC spot ETF have any negative impact on BTC and the crypto market?

I neither support the securitization or tokenization of BTC. It makes Bitcoin look like a product or investment tool instead of a currency. The approval of spot ETFs is certaintly the degeneration of BTC as it integrates itself into the corrupt financial system it was meant to replace in the first place. Large institutional investment companies will acquire all of the BTC (or most of it), leaving us with no ability to self-custody our coins (therefore increasing centralization). The network itself will remain decentralized, though. Only if most of the miners and node operators aren't owned by institutions, governments, and/or companies.

Price-wise, ETFs are good for Bitcoin because they add greater demand on the market. But they're bad because of the reasons mentioned earlier. Everybody wants to make money, so no one will care if BTC becomes centralized as long as they turn a profit. The future is not as bright as we thought it would be. Lets enjoy the ride while it lasts.

hatshepsut93

legendary

Activity: 3024

Merit: 2148

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?

It can't be called degeneracy because Satoshi and Core developers didn't put any features in Bitcoin that would prevent centralized use of it. The very nature of Bitcoin allows such use. There nothing anyone can do to stop insitutions from buying BTC and locking it in ETF. So it's rather a sign of maturity, that Bitcoin survived long enough to be recognized by the mainstream economy as a valuable asset and not a temporary mania.

And it's possible to theorize about negative effects of centralization of a large part of supply, but it's important to take a step back and remember that everyone is free to use Bitcoin however they like, including selling it to ETFs. Because ETFs can't really tell you how to use your coins either.

pinggoki

sr. member

Activity: 1666

Merit: 426

Quote from: coolcoinz on March 20, 2024, 02:15:56 PM

I don't think there's any risk here and no threat to bitcoin from ETFs.

For now, there's no foreseeable risk or threat to bitcoin, we all know how sneaky the banks are when it comes to finances and I don't think that they're any different when it comes to bitcoin ETF, they're probably figuring out how to make the most money out of it while at the same time giving the people that have invested in bitcoin and their ETFs the illusion that it's in our favor, I'm sure that they're doing that even though it's just a theory, I think that it's an illogical thing for them to do if they let things be and not do anything about it, at least that's my take on this one.

In regards to the question of OP if this is a maturization or degeneration of BTC, I think that it's a maturization, the degeneration part is the ordinals and inscriptions that's causing the transaction fees more expensive than usual, anything that improves bitcoin to me is a maturization, the opposite would always be degeneration or downgrade.

Vincom

member

Activity: 182

Merit: 46

₿itcoin maximalist

Quote from: Darker45 on March 21, 2024, 08:51:29 PM

First off, tokenization has been around before 2017.

In a sense, we can consider it a Trojan horse. After all, with this offer, the market is attracted to it, an option that is completely centralized, off the chain, with a number of layers of middlemen, in custody, and so on. Furthermore, the full sense of ownership, control, transparency, and others are also compromised. This is the same market which should have been convinced of the philosophies of Bitcoin.

All in all, what's being compromised with the advent of spot Bitcoin ETFs are no less than the main principles of Bitcoin. There's no more peer-to-peer with spot Bitcoin ETFs. Bitcoin is money no more.

May be true, may be not. But we can also say that with spot Bitcoin ETFs it is traditional finance that's invading Bitcoin. There are compromises from both sides.

There's no such thing as a free lunch

BlackRock and other ETF providers have been trying very hard to get spot BTC ETFs, their purpose is to profit from the management fees of traditional investors. They want BTC to come to the traditional market, not to bring traditional investors to the crypto market to buy and custody BTC themselves. They don't care about the decentralization or self-custody of Bitcoin!

The positive impact of spot BTC ETFs is very clear, and we have to trade off some of the risks and potential of the crypto market to get it. I hope that we are not too naive and spot ETFs can really help BTC and the crypto market develop in the long term with more users and new money flow.

Darker45

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 1860

First off, tokenization has been around before 2017.

In a sense, we can consider it a Trojan horse. After all, with this offer, the market is attracted to it, an option that is completely centralized, off the chain, with a number of layers of middlemen, in custody, and so on. Furthermore, the full sense of ownership, control, transparency, and others are also compromised. This is the same market which should have been convinced of the philosophies of Bitcoin.

All in all, what's being compromised with the advent of spot Bitcoin ETFs are no less than the main principles of Bitcoin. There's no more peer-to-peer with spot Bitcoin ETFs. Bitcoin is money no more.

Quote from: tranthidung on March 18, 2024, 08:29:28 PM

Having Bitcoin Spot ETFs is a big achievement for Bitcoin community as we are already invaded further into TradFi (Traditional Finance) and we have less worry about accusations, attacks like Bitcoin is a fraud.

May be true, may be not. But we can also say that with spot Bitcoin ETFs it is traditional finance that's invading Bitcoin. There are compromises from both sides.

Vincom

member

Activity: 182

Merit: 46

₿itcoin maximalist

Quote from: coolcoinz on March 20, 2024, 02:15:56 PM

I don't think there's any risk here and no threat to bitcoin from ETFs.

Ultimately we can't stop someone from buying. If ETFs want to buy bitcoin and people want to buy ETF shares, the market is working as intended.
Even if they buy a lot of bitcoin the only concern I might have is what happens if they go bankrupt or lose it? People's lives will be destroyed and they could easily choose self-custody and have the same profit with much more safety.

ETFs pump price, so I can't say no to that. They also popularize bitcoin in the media. Would you buy time on national TV to advertise bitcoin? I guess not, but ETFs do. They not only talk good about their funds but also about the underlying asset.

We all see the positive impact of BTC spot ETFs, but the negative impacts will always exist alongside them. As I mentioned in the topic, I am worried that the BTC market or the crypto market may be invaded by large institutions in the traditional financial market and the values of Bitcoin may be forgotten when investors are encouraged to participate in owning spot ETFs instead of self-custody BTC.

BTC was created by Satoshi with the purpose of decentralizing financial instruments in the economy, but spot ETFs are making the opposite happen. I understand that everyone is equal in participating in and using the Bitcoin network, but what BTC spot ETFs offer may go against the decentralized value of Bitcoin.

coolcoinz

legendary

Activity: 2814

Merit: 1192

I don't think there's any risk here and no threat to bitcoin from ETFs.

Ultimately we can't stop someone from buying. If ETFs want to buy bitcoin and people want to buy ETF shares, the market is working as intended.
Even if they buy a lot of bitcoin the only concern I might have is what happens if they go bankrupt or lose it? People's lives will be destroyed and they could easily choose self-custody and have the same profit with much more safety.

ETFs pump price, so I can't say no to that. They also popularize bitcoin in the media. Would you buy time on national TV to advertise bitcoin? I guess not, but ETFs do. They not only talk good about their funds but also about the underlying asset.

Vincom

member

Activity: 182

Merit: 46

₿itcoin maximalist

Quote from: pooya87 on March 19, 2024, 03:08:33 AM

I disagree. As you've already guessed ETF guys don't go on the usual centralized exchanges to purchase bitcoin to be able to affect the price like the way you described.

Additionally they don't constantly buy bitcoin to be able to contribute to the constant rise. Instead they make bulk purchases every time they want to offer for of their ETF crap to more people who sign up. That means even if they were to affect the market, their effect should be instant and one time only not a constant rise over weeks or months.

It would be like saying "a whale that made a one time purchase of something like 10000BTC is the reason for the rally that lasted 2 months"! Such one time purchase could shock the market and cause a rise in a couple of hours but it won't last for 2 months.
At the end of the day, the rise that we saw (from $30k to $60k in 4+ months) is the result of actual money coming into the real market purchasing real bitcoins not the money that goes into ETF purchasing IOUs. One of the major reasons for it is the upcoming halving.

In any case I like you title when you refer to ETF as a trojan horse but I don't really agree with the rest of your topic.

BTC spot ETF has a real impact on BTC price and the entire crypto market, I believe it is the reason that created a new history for BTC when we have a new ATH before Halving. Besides the media impact, although the money flow into Spot ETF does not directly create buying pressure on CEXs, it has a positive impact on price volatility through many ways and stages. I will probably present this in a separate topic in the future for us to discuss.

Even though I see such a positive impact, I still realize that Spot ETF is eroding the core value of BTC, which is the self-custody of assets that Satoshi always encouraged: ordinary investors choose not to buy BTC but buy spot ETF, and the storage of BTC is entrusted to large investment funds, and these funds become intermediaries that manage and charge fees from investors. That is clearly not what I want for the development of the crypto market.

Reatim

sr. member

Activity: 2828

Merit: 357

Eloncoin.org - Mars, here we come!

Quote from: Die_empty on March 19, 2024, 02:23:20 PM

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

Do you support securitization or tokenization?
BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?
Does BTC spot ETF have any negative impact on BTC and the crypto market?

I don't support any innovation that is that has the potential of distorting the natural operations of Bitcoin. The coin is designed to be a decentralized currency that should be used without intermediaries.

Bitcoin ETF has attracted so much publicity and money to the Bitcoin industry but as you rightly pointed out it might be a Trojan horse. It is because it moves people to centralisation thereby defeating the purpose of Bitcoin. These institutions have the funds to carry out expensive and captivating commercials that will make people gradually forget that they can buy real Bitcoin without any intermediary.

That is definitely possible but I think even with much effort, it won’t get that far.

There are a lot of investors who were against ETFs but I think it helps to propel the
price upward but it does not mean I will be favoring centralized way of purchasing
bitcoin than its counterpart. I believe that a lot of people feel the same way. From an
investor’s point of view, the emergence of ETFs is a good thing allowing more people
to buy bitcoin. It’s not that they can’t buy it themselves but rather it’s the thought of
having a trusted, credible and reliable place to buy bitcoin in is what makes them favor ETFs.

With this in mind, I hope bitcoin becomes mainstream enough that we can go back to its
original purpose which is to become a payment method through a peer to peer
transaction. [/list]

InCap Live

newbie

Activity: 4

Merit: 0

Allowing people to buy ETF shares is a big victory for Bitcoin, with many new people and dollars flowing in. A percentage of those investors will eventually be interested in learning more about owning and protecting real BTC. Fees and "paying the higher prices for each transaction" will make great income for the ETF companies, and help motivate the savvy investors to start looking for better ways.

Die_empty

hero member

Activity: 686

Merit: 987

Give all before death

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

Do you support securitization or tokenization?
BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?
Does BTC spot ETF have any negative impact on BTC and the crypto market?

I don't support any innovation that is that has the potential of distorting the natural operations of Bitcoin. The coin is designed to be a decentralized currency that should be used without intermediaries.

Bitcoin ETF has attracted so much publicity and money to the Bitcoin industry but as you rightly pointed out it might be a Trojan horse. It is because it moves people to centralisation thereby defeating the purpose of Bitcoin. These institutions have the funds to carry out expensive and captivating commercials that will make people gradually forget that they can buy real Bitcoin without any intermediary.

Some people believe that these rich investors will soon have the power to manipulate the market at will. They might be able to create FUD or FOMO but the impact will be minimal and short.

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

This innovation allows traditional investors to easily purchase exposure to Bitcoin through ETF, bypassing the complexities of directly acquiring and storing BTC themselves.

I don't know the process of buying Bitcoin Shares through any ETF but I don't think buying Bitcoin directly and storing it is that complex. Anybody who can handle am online banking app can comfortably manage a Bitcoin wallet. [/list]

Aanuoluwatofunmi

sr. member

Activity: 672

Merit: 416

stead.builders

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

Do you support securitization or tokenization?

It all depends on the adopted mode of application to these, if it will not create a loophole to the expected security measures and privacy of every users then its as a good and welcomes idea to see into action, what people needs is their privacy and any modification that will renders such into vulnerable is as better as nothing.

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

BTC spot ETF is the maturity or degeneration of BTC?

We shouldn't get it all wrong, they are both for the growth and development of the bitcoin network, but we must not forget that bitcoin spot ETF have to depend on bitcoin market price and these has no any negative impact on the way of expectations to the market performance of bitcoin.

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

Does BTC spot ETF have any negative impact on BTC and the crypto market?

No

pooya87

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 10611

Quote from: Vincom on March 18, 2024, 07:57:40 PM

The BTC spot ETF has unlocked tens of billions of dollars in investment from traditional markets, fueling a surge in the price of Bitcoin. Notably, even though these ETF providers are currently acquiring their Bitcoin on the OTC market, the impact on the broader market is undeniable.

I disagree. As you've already guessed ETF guys don't go on the usual centralized exchanges to purchase bitcoin to be able to affect the price like the way you described.

Additionally they don't constantly buy bitcoin to be able to contribute to the constant rise. Instead they make bulk purchases every time they want to offer for of their ETF crap to more people who sign up. That means even if they were to affect the market, their effect should be instant and one time only not a constant rise over weeks or months.

It would be like saying "a whale that made a one time purchase of something like 10000BTC is the reason for the rally that lasted 2 months"! Such one time purchase could shock the market and cause a rise in a couple of hours but it won't last for 2 months.
At the end of the day, the rise that we saw (from $30k to $60k in 4+ months) is the result of actual money coming into the real market purchasing real bitcoins not the money that goes into ETF purchasing IOUs. One of the major reasons for it is the upcoming halving.

In any case I like you title when you refer to ETF as a trojan horse but I don't really agree with the rest of your topic.

davis196

hero member

Activity: 3150

Merit: 937

Quote

A surprise twist: instead of tokenizing securities, we've seen the securitization tokens with the launch of the BTC spot ETF in January [4]. This innovation allows traditional investors to easily purchase exposure to Bitcoin through ETF, bypassing the complexities of directly acquiring and storing BTC themselves. The BTC spot ETF has unlocked tens of billions of dollars in investment from traditional markets, fueling a surge in the price of Bitcoin. Notably, even though these ETF providers are currently acquiring their Bitcoin on the OTC market, the impact on the broader market is undeniable. As the price of Bitcoin rises, the entire crypto market expands, creating opportunities for crypto investors to profit.

Are you suggesting that Bitcoin is a token? Grin

I don't get the whole point of your forum thread. Are you complaining about the Bitcoin spot ETFs? Are you one of the people, who think that Blackrock and the institutional investors will "take control over Bitcoin" via the ETFs? I guess that this is your main thesis here.
Bitcoin spot ETFs are just financial derivatives. They don't change how the Bitcoin blockchain works. They can only influence the BTC price.
If the ETFs help in pumping the price everyone is happy. If another bearish market occurs, I can assume that most Bitcoiners will start b*tch and complain about the ETFs

tranthidung

legendary

Activity: 2310

Merit: 4085

Farewell o_e_l_e_o

Currently, there is no tokenized of Bitcoin Spot ETFs, they are shares on stock market.

If there is anything to be deployed for tokenization of Bitcoin Spot ETF shares, it will not be different than Wrapped tokens. In cryptocurrency market, we have many Wrapped Bitcoin tokens (altcoins) and it already happened some years ago.

Having Bitcoin Spot ETFs is a big achievement for Bitcoin community as we are already invaded further into TradFi (Traditional Finance) and we have less worry about accusations, attacks like Bitcoin is a fraud.

Topic: BTC spot ETF: Wall Street's Trojan horse (Read 321 times)