Pages:
Author

Topic: Chargebacks (Read 3897 times)

hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 05, 2014, 06:13:52 AM
#46
When using an irreversible payment method, consumers have to make a conscious effort to transact with businesses that have a solid history of being honest and trustworthy,
Well. that excludes every Bitcoin exchange.
Quote
or use escrow.
Bogus escrow services are a big problem. There are probably more fake ones than real ones for eBay. The various Bitcoin escrow services are rather flaky - many are run anonymously, but hold your money.

Nobody was suggesting using an eBay escrow service,  lol. What use would that be with bitcoins?

As you well know, there are several totally trustworthy bitcoin escrow services here at bitcointalk. Stop creating problems which don't exist.
legendary
Activity: 1204
Merit: 1002
January 05, 2014, 03:18:50 AM
#45
When using an irreversible payment method, consumers have to make a conscious effort to transact with businesses that have a solid history of being honest and trustworthy,
Well. that excludes every Bitcoin exchange.
Quote
or use escrow.
Bogus escrow services are a big problem. There are probably more fake ones than real ones for eBay. The various Bitcoin escrow services are rather flaky - many are run anonymously, but hold your money.
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 04, 2014, 10:36:37 PM
#44


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.

Exactly. But most consumers are "protected" from knowing about chargebacks, how they work, how much they cost, how they stop people from buying things, how they increase prices. Too many people have been "educated" by credit card companies. Time for change.

I don't know how many normal people with credit cards really know about chargebacks. Most people only find out about them when something goes seriously wrong. I don't think I knew about them until I started working with e-commerce projects as a developer, and I'd had a credit card for many years before then.

I did my first chargeback last year, ~14 years after getting my first credit card. I suspect many people are like me.

Fraudsters on the other hand... it's a weapon for them!

Believe me, in the US at least, every consumer I have come across knows about chargebacks. With my domain registration biz, I have had literally hundreds of threatened chargebacks, and dozens of actual chargebacks. As a merchant, it costs me a bomb. The consumer gets away without a scratch. And this is when they've done something stupid like register a domain with the wrong spelling and only notice a few weeks later, lol. They call and threaten a chargeback if I don't give them a refund. If I do the refund, I end up paying for the domain myself. If I don't do the refund and they do the chargeback, the merchant processor charges me a $100 fee.

I don't like chargebacks Smiley

It's definitely a big problem, but dealing with BTC I've seen a lot of people being scammed by comapnies not delivering the products and then the consumer is left out of pocket. It's a shit situation either way.

Sure. People are getting scammed every day on these forums. Sad but true. But its because the sellers are anonymous, and the buyer pays some or all up front. People should never do that.

In the real world, where companies care about their reputation, it will be a lot less of a problem i.e. they will have a stated refund policy, which they will honour, regardless of how you pay for something.
legendary
Activity: 1232
Merit: 1195
January 04, 2014, 02:39:45 PM
#43


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.

Exactly. But most consumers are "protected" from knowing about chargebacks, how they work, how much they cost, how they stop people from buying things, how they increase prices. Too many people have been "educated" by credit card companies. Time for change.

I don't know how many normal people with credit cards really know about chargebacks. Most people only find out about them when something goes seriously wrong. I don't think I knew about them until I started working with e-commerce projects as a developer, and I'd had a credit card for many years before then.

I did my first chargeback last year, ~14 years after getting my first credit card. I suspect many people are like me.

Fraudsters on the other hand... it's a weapon for them!

Believe me, in the US at least, every consumer I have come across knows about chargebacks. With my domain registration biz, I have had literally hundreds of threatened chargebacks, and dozens of actual chargebacks. As a merchant, it costs me a bomb. The consumer gets away without a scratch. And this is when they've done something stupid like register a domain with the wrong spelling and only notice a few weeks later, lol. They call and threaten a chargeback if I don't give them a refund. If I do the refund, I end up paying for the domain myself. If I don't do the refund and they do the chargeback, the merchant processor charges me a $100 fee.

I don't like chargebacks Smiley

It's definitely a big problem, but dealing with BTC I've seen a lot of people being scammed by comapnies not delivering the products and then the consumer is left out of pocket. It's a shit situation either way.
member
Activity: 84
Merit: 10
January 04, 2014, 01:26:52 PM
#42
Possible solutions that I see:

New companies can seek a bond that guarantees their transactions. This bond would have to be issued by a reputable bonds company or insurer. This gives the customer the assurance that they can make a claim against a company's bond if they fail to deliver.

Independent association that vets the reputation of a business. Sort of like the Better Business Bureau (BBB). People can register complaints against a business and the association will work towards a voluntary resolution that satisfies both parties. Companies will be rated highly if they are complaint-free, next if they resolve complaints quickly, all the way down to scammy companies with "F" ratings. Companies can advertise their ratings. Association should be funded by current bitcoin businesses who want to promote the integrity of bitcoin - based transactions and businesses.
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 04, 2014, 08:13:01 AM
#41


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.

Exactly. But most consumers are "protected" from knowing about chargebacks, how they work, how much they cost, how they stop people from buying things, how they increase prices. Too many people have been "educated" by credit card companies. Time for change.

I don't know how many normal people with credit cards really know about chargebacks. Most people only find out about them when something goes seriously wrong. I don't think I knew about them until I started working with e-commerce projects as a developer, and I'd had a credit card for many years before then.

I did my first chargeback last year, ~14 years after getting my first credit card. I suspect many people are like me.

Fraudsters on the other hand... it's a weapon for them!

Believe me, in the US at least, every consumer I have come across knows about chargebacks. With my domain registration biz, I have had literally hundreds of threatened chargebacks, and dozens of actual chargebacks. As a merchant, it costs me a bomb. The consumer gets away without a scratch. And this is when they've done something stupid like register a domain with the wrong spelling and only notice a few weeks later, lol. They call and threaten a chargeback if I don't give them a refund. If I do the refund, I end up paying for the domain myself. If I don't do the refund and they do the chargeback, the merchant processor charges me a $100 fee.

I don't like chargebacks Smiley
sr. member
Activity: 245
Merit: 250
January 04, 2014, 07:50:34 AM
#40


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

Biggest source fraud in the world?  its not even the biggest source of credit card fraud, which is skimming/cloning. 

The whole argument seems focused on online consumer business, yet i find these to be cheaper than brick&mortar where there is less use of cards and far fewer chargebacks (presumably though i have no evidence, but there are less scope for claims, no failed delivery, product not right etc.).  I conclude that there are higher overheads for a bricks&mortar than an online shop, suggesting the CC fees aren't as big an issue as claimed. 
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 250
January 04, 2014, 07:20:40 AM
#39


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.

Exactly. But most consumers are "protected" from knowing about chargebacks, how they work, how much they cost, how they stop people from buying things, how they increase prices. Too many people have been "educated" by credit card companies. Time for change.

I don't know how many normal people with credit cards really know about chargebacks. Most people only find out about them when something goes seriously wrong. I don't think I knew about them until I started working with e-commerce projects as a developer, and I'd had a credit card for many years before then.

I did my first chargeback last year, ~14 years after getting my first credit card. I suspect many people are like me.

Fraudsters on the other hand... it's a weapon for them!
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 04, 2014, 02:04:03 AM
#38


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.

Exactly. But most consumers are "protected" from knowing about chargebacks, how they work, how much they cost, how they stop people from buying things, how they increase prices. Too many people have been "educated" by credit card companies. Time for change.
hero member
Activity: 1036
Merit: 500
January 04, 2014, 01:48:32 AM
#37


So lets then assume consumers aren't willing to?  Where does that leave the proposition that Bitcoin use will become widespread common currency?  I agree with the OP, chargeback is an advantage of Bitcoin that only benefits seller and as most people are buyers, the advantage is overstated.


No, the advantage is clear and huge. Chargebacks are the main vector of credit card fraud and probably the biggest source of all fraud in the world.

This leads to higher prices for goods and services which are passed directly to the consumer.

By eliminating these excessive fees, Bitcoin allows businesses to operate with much lower margins which has a massive benefit to everyone.

Furthermore, credit cards as they exist today are simply exploitive of the 99%. I own a couple simply for credit score purposes.

If you cant afford to buy something or cant be sure you trust the company you are buying from, you shouldnt be buying the product at all. Period.
sr. member
Activity: 434
Merit: 250
January 04, 2014, 01:19:04 AM
#36
use escrow if you dont trust them.
sr. member
Activity: 294
Merit: 250
January 03, 2014, 10:59:33 PM
#35
it's in a businesses best interest to behave nicely. If they rip people off they cannot succeed ultimately as a business. It is in a customers best interest (selfish interest) to behave maliciously. They don't have a reputation they have to keep. They can rip off a business and move on. So it makes sense to have the burden of trust placed with the customer rather than the business.

That aside..... it's perfectly possible to have chargebacks with bitcoin. If a site like ebay accepted bitcoin they could keep transactions off the blockchain and therefore reverse when they want to.
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 03, 2014, 09:36:25 PM
#34
In nearly all the posts I read regarding Bitcoin people mention that irreversible transactions are fantastic and the way forward.
 
I can understand this from the point of view of businesses but not from the point of view of the consumer. Why would people switch to start paying in BTC if they have no comeback should whatever it is they purchased not be as described or not received?

I read it all the time, people saying how they sent x thousands of $ to a random company they found on the internet in expectation that they would receive BTC in return - of course many people get ripped off and have no comeback as they are sending payments by non reversible methods.

If Bitcoin will continue to gain ground it will not only change how payments are sent and received but will change the very nature of how things are done leading to a survival of the fittest scenario where people not blessed with a large amount of common sense end up penniless and destitute.

I have read so many sob stories on this forum from people who have sent money for BTC to a company with no address listed on their site based in some backward country that it makes you think how could someone be so stupid? I have also read recently someone who sent money 3 times to the same company as each time they gave an excuse as to why they needed more? I mean come on!

Just wondering if the general consensus from long time Bitcoin users is that if someone is stupid enough to send money to a company that is so obviously not legitimate they deserve to loose their money?



Confidence Chains can support chargebacks natively.  This capability is critical to conducting e-commerce.

http://altchain.org.

-bm

Chargebacks are not critical to conducting e-commerce, sorry.
sr. member
Activity: 280
Merit: 257
bluemeanie
January 02, 2014, 01:03:06 PM
#33
In nearly all the posts I read regarding Bitcoin people mention that irreversible transactions are fantastic and the way forward.
 
I can understand this from the point of view of businesses but not from the point of view of the consumer. Why would people switch to start paying in BTC if they have no comeback should whatever it is they purchased not be as described or not received?

I read it all the time, people saying how they sent x thousands of $ to a random company they found on the internet in expectation that they would receive BTC in return - of course many people get ripped off and have no comeback as they are sending payments by non reversible methods.

If Bitcoin will continue to gain ground it will not only change how payments are sent and received but will change the very nature of how things are done leading to a survival of the fittest scenario where people not blessed with a large amount of common sense end up penniless and destitute.

I have read so many sob stories on this forum from people who have sent money for BTC to a company with no address listed on their site based in some backward country that it makes you think how could someone be so stupid? I have also read recently someone who sent money 3 times to the same company as each time they gave an excuse as to why they needed more? I mean come on!

Just wondering if the general consensus from long time Bitcoin users is that if someone is stupid enough to send money to a company that is so obviously not legitimate they deserve to loose their money?



Confidence Chains can support chargebacks natively.  This capability is critical to conducting e-commerce.

http://altchain.org.

-bm
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 02, 2014, 06:22:49 AM
#32
Everyone is saying Escrow, but as a business owner, I don't want a middle man in my transactions with my customers.  No way.  I don't know what the alternative could be, but that will not fly IRL. 

Small businesses will need to develop a strategy to handle this concern from their customers, for sure. 

The strategy is to become "trusted", and to offer + give refunds to unsatisfied customers. Not sure how this mechanism will develop with bitcoin but I'm sure some service will step in.

As a business owner, you should be delighted at the the prospect of accepting customers from round the globe that previously got turned down automatically by credit card companies because they come from "high fraud" countries. The age of truly global commerce is just about to happen.

So the middleman/escrow is only for untrusted accounts, as they gain rep.?  That makes sense.  That's true that a refund will be simple to accomplish, but as someone pointed out, going from untrusted > trusted could be a very challenging task for small businesses.  Local businesses it's much easier to handle that situation, with face to face transactions. 

I'm definitely excited to be able to accept a new global customer, and a new form of currency!!  For small businesses that sell online, this is great!

I am a merchant. I sell domain registrations and other domain services. Our "merchant processor" blacklists probably 100 countries because of fraud. That would instantly go away with bitcoin. Of course the customers would have to trust me to deliver the service, but there are many ways to show you are trustworthy as a merchant. For example, I've been in business 10 years. That helps. Plus delivering the "goods" every time. And if you have any dispute, which can always happen, show good faith, just as you would with any kind of customer, whether they are paying with an irreversible currency or not.
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
January 01, 2014, 11:01:42 PM
#31
Everyone is saying Escrow, but as a business owner, I don't want a middle man in my transactions with my customers.  No way.  I don't know what the alternative could be, but that will not fly IRL. 

Small businesses will need to develop a strategy to handle this concern from their customers, for sure. 

The strategy is to become "trusted", and to offer + give refunds to unsatisfied customers. Not sure how this mechanism will develop with bitcoin but I'm sure some service will step in.

As a business owner, you should be delighted at the the prospect of accepting customers from round the globe that previously got turned down automatically by credit card companies because they come from "high fraud" countries. The age of truly global commerce is just about to happen.

So the middleman/escrow is only for untrusted accounts, as they gain rep.?  That makes sense.  That's true that a refund will be simple to accomplish, but as someone pointed out, going from untrusted > trusted could be a very challenging task for small businesses.  Local businesses it's much easier to handle that situation, with face to face transactions. 

I'm definitely excited to be able to accept a new global customer, and a new form of currency!!  For small businesses that sell online, this is great!
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 01, 2014, 10:52:12 PM
#30
Everyone is saying Escrow, but as a business owner, I don't want a middle man in my transactions with my customers.  No way.  I don't know what the alternative could be, but that will not fly IRL. 

Small businesses will need to develop a strategy to handle this concern from their customers, for sure. 

The strategy is to become "trusted", and to offer + give refunds to unsatisfied customers. Not sure how this mechanism will develop with bitcoin but I'm sure some service will step in.

As a business owner, you should be delighted at the the prospect of accepting customers from round the globe that previously got turned down automatically by credit card companies because they come from "high fraud" countries. The age of truly global commerce is just about to happen.
member
Activity: 98
Merit: 10
January 01, 2014, 10:30:32 PM
#29
Everyone is saying Escrow, but as a business owner, I don't want a middle man in my transactions with my customers.  No way.  I don't know what the alternative could be, but that will not fly IRL. 

Small businesses will need to develop a strategy to handle this concern from their customers, for sure. 
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
January 01, 2014, 10:19:03 PM
#28
Another issue then is who sends to the escrow agent first?

Say I want to sell 1BTC for $750 - If I send the BTC to the escrow agent and then the buyer negates on the deal then I have lost time and effort.

Also if I'm running an online business for example I would not want to ship anything until the money was safely in my account/wallet. You have to bear in mind that you still need to trust the escrow agent - I don't want to have to trust anyone or trust that the escrow agent will find in my favour in case of an issue.

I really hope that a solution that is not escrow can be found to this issue.

Escrow really isn't that difficult. Its works quickly and efficiently 99% of the time. If you don't want to use it, fine. Just buy off big retailers that you trust.

Or just keep using ebay / paypal and the mess that is!
full member
Activity: 154
Merit: 100
January 01, 2014, 10:02:54 PM
#27
Another issue then is who sends to the escrow agent first?

Say I want to sell 1BTC for $750 - If I send the BTC to the escrow agent and then the buyer negates on the deal then I have lost time and effort.

Also if I'm running an online business for example I would not want to ship anything until the money was safely in my account/wallet. You have to bear in mind that you still need to trust the escrow agent - I don't want to have to trust anyone or trust that the escrow agent will find in my favour in case of an issue.

I really hope that a solution that is not escrow can be found to this issue.
Pages:
Jump to: