Topic: [CLOSED] Rollin.io Signature Design Competition - 0.5 BTC in Prizes! (Read 4156 times)

I want to confirm that I have received the bounty, thanks rollin.io team and guitarplinker!


Thank you izanagi and irfan_pak10, well actually nowadays there are many amazing designers and they will be tough competitors someday

hahahah True that lol, Roslin and medUSA were too awesome and now jayce. Good luck friend because you have no competitor like Roslin has madUSA. And it was a strong one.

Regards

Congrats and the best design as always !

It's has been a long time when I start signature designing and it still Roslin or medUSA that always to be a winner
And for now welcome for jayce ERA 

Thanks to rollin.io team for running this contest and choosing me as the 1st winner, I hope my design can help rollin.io to be greater and more popular.  Also thanks to everyone, its really a tough contest, we have many good talented designers here. Good luck!

If I have the right to vote in this Rollin.io Signature Design Contest honestly My 2nd vote will be in this entry. The 1st one is for Jayce of course. Anyway I respect the vote by the Admin and Mod of Rollin.io. Congrats to the winners!

congrats to the winners of this contest,, your design are all great but jayce's design is superb... 

The votes have been tallied and the winners determined! Congratulations to the following people for winning:

1st place: jayce
2nd place: Galer
3rd place: Adriandmen

---

If your name appears in the list above please contact me to claim your prize, and share the signature BBCodes!

Thanks to everyone who participated in this competition, and I'm sorry I'm not able to offer any prizes to any other runners up in this competition.

Now im not sure, or just don't understand why in thread about "design" - exactly "design competition" , you guys start speaking about rates for signature campaign participants?

Or maybe i didn't catch something?

Rates per post assuming they use the avatar:
0.0018/post for Hero+
0.0013/post for Sr. Member
0.0008/post for Full Member

Those are some of the best rates on the forum. Definitely THE best for Hero+, almost the best for Sr. Member and the best for Full Member. Low?

If you compare our campaign rates to other campaigns, we pay much more per post than most other campaigns. We have no plans of increasing our pay rates at this point in time.

there is no any problem in the old signature campaign it is also running much better but the price is much lower. You should have to increase your pay rate we will love it that way.

Thanks for your votes - they've been recorded in the spreadsheet.

We won't be starting a new signature campaign, we'll probably just change the signature designs for the campaign to the either one of the winner's entries, or a combination of signatures from the winners (maybe take a Member and Full member signature from one winner, and a Senior and Hero signature from another winner).

I've changed the spreadsheet so that your submissions will be counted as one signature design.

after signature design competition
rollin io can new open system signature campaign
or still is old signature campaign run and still not accepted new partcipant

My vote:

#1: jayce
#2: aubert (either one of his designs)
#3: Adriandmen (Rasqp.png)

-----BEGIN BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
This is LoyceV (Mod Loyce at Rollin.io) confirming my vote for Rollin.io's Signature Design Competition (https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/closed-rollinio-signature-design-competition-05-btc-in-prizes-1607134): #1 jayce, #2 aubert (either one), #3 Adriandmen (Rasqp.png). Today's date is September 18, 2016
-----BEGIN SIGNATURE-----
1foreverDArUNEX2gVD26vautcx3b8zTZ
HEY4TFxslaJieo2e4SThG/ijhs5xmcr/deHJetoBGbKqSqM6AAE5qUokiE/sY41t36yWs7HxJWFbfvhNlHVkYAE=
-----END BITCOIN SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Staked here on March 8, 2016.
Click to verify.

I'd like to explain how I came to my Top 3. Let me start with this:
From the signatures in the current Rollin Signature Campaign, I like the Full Member design more than Senior/Hero. In my opinion none of the new designs for Full Member can match the old Full Member signature. I suggest to keep the old Full Member signature.

Jayce (my #1) made very nice designs. I like the signatures for Sr. Member and Hero/Legendary most. Member and Full do fit the same style of the design, but different styles might actually be good for more exposure.
If jayce's design will be used in the future, I suggest to make the old Full Member signature optional and let the user who wears the signature choose.

Aubert (my #2) submitted a Standard Version and a Simple Version. They're almost the same. I am not going to pick one of them now, as that could mean he gets votes from different judges on both of them, which could lead to neither one of them being in the top 3. I don't want to give him both #2 and #3, as the designs are too close together to justify two places in the top 3.
If Rollin is going to use this signature in the future, I suggest to keep both options, and let the user who wears the signature choose.
guitarplinker, is it possible to treat my vote (and maybe others' votes too) for aubert as "either one"?

Adriandmen (my #3) won my vote with the Senior Member signature. Hero is nice, but the big red fields make it too screamy. It could be improved by adding WINNER LOSER under the 88, like SRF10 does (link) does, but taking part of another designs would be bad. #3 was a close call between Adriandmen and SRF10. I placed SRF10's design #4 because I don't like the big word "Rollin" in the Member and Full Member designs.

Thanks everyone for the submissions! I'll compile the final spreadsheet in a few moments and then the judging will begin. Here's how the judging will work:

• Six people with ties to Rollin.io will be judging the entries - the admin of the website, four moderators, and myself (the signature campaign manager)
• The votes made by the admin will have a weighting three times more powerful than any of the other judges
• Votes will be done using "points" - an entry will be awarded 10 points if it's a judge's first choice (or 30 points if it's the admin's first choice), 5 points if it's a judge's second choice (15 points if it's the admin's second choice), and 3 points if it's a judge's third choice (9 points if it's the admin's third choice)
• Votes will be filled in on the spreadsheet of entries. Once all judges have cast their votes, the winners of the competition will be announced - the entry with the most points will win first prize, the entry with the second most votes will win second prize, and the entry with the third most votes will win third prize
• I will attempt to have all judges sign a bitcoin or PGP message proving the authenticity of their votes. This will help to ensure fairness, and that I haven't meddled with any of the votes (as I'm the one updating the spreadsheet with votes). I say attempt, because I'm not sure if the three moderators involved in judging have staked private keys anywhere.

If anyone has any questions about the above process, please let me know and I'll do my best to clarify.

---

I've made my top three choices. Please see my signed message below to confirm my choices:


My PGP key can be found on this page.

Lel, :-D

Huh, what do you mean? I'm not using any colors, am I ?

You cannot use colors in the member rank dude. :-)

Here is my second submission. This one is going for a more minimalistic approach.

Just in time haha.

Here is my first submission: