Topic: CryptoXChange.com - Be cautious and check before if you get out your BTC or USD - page 2. (Read 3814 times)

Well this sucks.

One more sign it seems... so what can be done to protect other people? Scammertag for the user here? Anything more? Maybe i should change the topic adding scam or something so that users at google checking out the site can see it fast...

really sorry to hear people are having trouble with this place and getting their funds.

I had some issues with cryptox and have tried to warn people.

my issue was with a flaw in their order book.  a user can put an order on the order book which appears to be a valid order, but is unfunded.  There is a bid at $8 USD for 124BTC ($992 total) that I have left there to demonstrate to the operators of the site - it is unfunded and anyone who tries to buy these btc at that price will be disappointed - and the site has done nothing about this issue since July 25, 2012.

This flaw in their system costed me considerably in an arbitrage situation:

• I had funds on mtgox
• Arbitrage condition existed between gox and cryptox (according the flawed order book)
• I transfered funds at my expense from gox to cryptox
• My orders on cryptox revealed the listings in the order book were invalid as they did not fill at the prices expected but simply vanished.  If I hadn't used a limit order I would have triggered orders for a much worse price
• I transfered funds at my expense from cryptox to gox, as there were no advantageous prices on cryptox
• I submitted a help ticket to cryptox complaining of this issue and requesting compensation for my losses due to their error
• Received no response, no feedback, no help, no compensation
• Discovered the cause of the issue, placing an invalid order on the books to demonstrate it, and contacted their help ticket system again
• Received no response, no feedback, no help, no compensation
• Decided to never trust their system again

Everyone should be warned that this has been for a long time a sub-par platform and undeserving of business.  And now it appears they are either extremely negligent or possibly malicious in mismanaging the site, it's capabilities, and user funds.

Hard to say exactly what went wrong but I never really saw any large volume trade there at all (even after the Tradehill collapse).

The website has always been slow (and the trading engine even more so) - it is my guess that they had hoped more volume would have produced more profits which would have let them employ more people and improve the software.

There are no other Aussie BTC exchanges that have really worked so I think the problem is simply that there is not enough demand for bitcoins down under.

I dont know if its unprofitable. I heard they started a big ad-campaign after tradehill died and got many of these traders. Afterwards the service gone down, website slow and so on so that people believed they took more than they could eat. So i doubt they had to less traders. I think more they couldnt manage it like businessmans. Otherwise i dont know why the exchangers stopped working with them. It probably is because of not good businesspractise.

Hopefully it hasn't become the next WBX yet.

It really is a pity that running an exchange in Aus seems to be perhaps just an unprofitable business at this stage.

I dont think ill get them anymore. I know others that yesterday sold their btc there and cant take them out now. They still have the USD. Problem is the same. I think ill cut it as lost and stop feeling angry. It wouldnt help me anyway.

Am not entirely sure if I follow that either, however, certainly it looks as though the bitcoin that you put in was moved out (perhaps along with other deposits).

If your second purchase has not been sent to the same address (which I'm guessing is likely assuming that the address they give you is only for depositing) then it is not really possible to determine your *actual* BTC balance (it is only a figure in their DB).

You mean this: https://blockchain.info/address/1PyuAkLeiGRqh1x1dbnLzKHRcR76YzdZj3

Im not fully sure how to interprete. the incoming payment are my btc i put in yesterday. Then i sold them for getting $82.30 and today i bought btc again. It looks like they werent put into the same address again. Am i right?

Regarding the 29.85BTC... i dont know about that. I created my account at crypto yesterday and got this address. I only put money on that address and then used the website of crypto.

Certainly if their website contains false information it should be corrected ASAP (might be nice if one or other of the businesses concerned could comment). As for your withdrawal issue is the balance amount visible in the bitcoin address assigned to your account or only in their DB?

For myself i see it as proof that they tell me i dont have enough btc to withdraw 3btc while in fact i have 6.4btc with them. Clearly stated in my balance.

And that the still advertised possibilities to withdraw with bitinstant and aurumxchange arent true seems to speak for itself too.

It does seem (from several recent complaint posts) that they are having some troubles recently but I haven't seen any evidence of any "scam" so it might be a little too soon to be posting in this board, however, as I stated in another thread the obviously small volume of BTC traded on their exchange makes it fairly understandable that they might be low on available human resources.

Hopefully they will soon be addressing these recent issues and more hopefully their trade volume will increase.

So yesterday, when btc crashed this website had good opporunity to sell btc. And i checked before aurumxchange would exchange crypto to mtgox-codes. So i transferred 6.7btc to them. Sold them and had 82.30$ then. I went to aurum and wanted to exchange. And only after i filled out everything they told me that they dont exchange them. Today... after i wrote the support of aurum they say that at least after you chose crypto and mtgox. So you can be warned before. But i didnt get that warning.

So then i had usd in crypto and couldnt take it out. bitinstant and aurumxchange arent working with them anymore. mtgoxcodes arent available. and an cryptxchangecode i would be able to create wasnt taken by #bitcoin-otc, here in the forum and in another forum.

So i wrote the support of crypto. Livesupport ist dead anyway. Not one of their messengers work. Only zendesk. And i wrote the owner here in the forum. Named cryptoxchange: https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/cryptoxchange-40345

Today the support wrote me: "Dear user,

We are working with Aurum and Bitinstant to get the withdraw method working back.
We will update you as soon as we get it working."

The owner here in forum was here but didnt answer my pm.

So now i dont trusted them anymore. I decided to get my btc back even when i have to buy them for more. So i bought btc and have now 6.39673062BTC. its written in the balance.

I then tried to withdraw them. Not sufficient balaance. But i entered the same amount. And withdraw is free. The same when i took 0.5% away. Then i tried to withdraw 3BT. Its the half. That should be ennough for a fee. What happened? "Balance is not sufficient".

So that proofs to me that they gone scam. Exchanger dont want to work with them anymore and they dont give out the money of the users.

I would say dont send any more money there. The high price of the Orderbook are maybe fake and a honeypot.

I would be happy you can tell me im wrong... but telling me i dont have enough btc when i have 6.4 and only want 3 is proof for me.

Thanks!
Sebastian