[Discussion] Taro: A new protocol for multi-asset Bitcoin and Lightning

ABCbits

legendary

Activity: 2870

Merit: 7490

Crypto Swap Exchange

Quote from: fillippone on October 21, 2023, 05:47:08 AM

An exciting, yet puzzling news caught my attention the other day:

Paolo Ardoino sees RGB as 'best opportunity' to issue stablecoins on Bitcoi

I find it's weird that Liquid (which is one of Bitcoin Sidechain) isn't mentioned as comparison. He holds position at Bifinex which support Liquid based USDT.

Quote from: fillippone on October 21, 2023, 05:47:08 AM

Why RGB?
We know that Taproot Assets is a copycat of RGB, but we also know that it has better documentation and probably a better team. He was referring to RGB as the protocol per se or RGB as "Asstet transfer protocol on BTC L2?" opening the competitive race between RGB and TARO?

I find it's unsettling to see 2 similar protocol compete, especially when Taproot Asset is based on RGB. If people behind Taproot join RGB or vice versa, we could see faster/more efficient development.

fillippone

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 16328

Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Quote from: ABCbits on October 22, 2023, 05:53:15 AM

I find it's unsettling to see 2 similar protocol compete, especially when Taproot Asset is based on RGB. If people behind Taproot join RGB or vice versa, we could see faster/more efficient development.

As I understand, Ardoino is a fan of L2 solution, actually both of them:

The Block released an interview with the Tether CEO:
Bitfinex's Ardoino expects 'quantum leap' in Bitcoin scaling solution adoption

Quote

However, he also appears to be a fan of Taproot Assets — which aims to transform Bitcoin into a scalable multi-asset network without compromising its core tenets — calling it "the future we deserve."

In this interview so he clarifies he is confident in the L2 scaling solutions, and open to the best protocol emerging from the competing one (TaAs and RGB) or even new ones that could emerge).

fillippone

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 16328

Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

An exciting, yet puzzling news caught my attention the other day:

Paolo Ardoino sees RGB as 'best opportunity' to issue stablecoins on Bitcoi

tl;dr

Quote

Quick Take

Paolo Ardoino called the RGB protocol the “best opportunity” for issuing stablecoins on Bitcoin.
Ardoino said RGB is the “rightful successor” to Omni for Tether’s USDT stablecoin issuance.

Why RGB?
We know that Taproot Assets is a copycat of RGB, but we also know that it has better documentation and probably a better team. He was referring to RGB as the protocol per se or RGB as "Asstet transfer protocol on BTC L2?" opening the competitive race between RGB and TARO?

d5000

legendary

Activity: 3906

Merit: 6249

Decentralization Maximalist

Thank you for linking the news

I think NostrAssets (mentioned in one of the articles) is quite an interesting approach. I've not looked at it in detail, but it seems to combine the Nostr communication protocol (which is used for messaging and similar communication activity, it has also a protocol extension for marketplaces) and Taproot Assets for DeFi-Lightning applications. There seems to be no whitepaper however, so investigating its inner workings could be a bit bothersome ...

There could be interesting synergies as Nostr uses the same kind of cryptography as Bitcoin (and thus, TA and Lightning) does. For example, I could imagine temporary addresses being used as identification in the Nostr network but only valid for one payment to maximize privacy when trading TA assets. (I'm willing to overlook that the NostrAssets team seems to come originally from the BRC-20 bubble Wink

)

cygan

legendary

Activity: 3304

Merit: 8633

Crypto Swap Exchange

Quote from: fillippone on October 18, 2023, 12:20:27 PM

✂️
Today Lightning Labs released their first main net alpha of the product: Taproot Assets v 0.3 where developers and tester can start playing with financial assets issued on chain!

for this release, there is also a very detailed article that also shows why TA provides builders with all the tools needed to make bitcoin a multi-asset network, but in a scalable manner that maintains bitcoin's core values
https://lightning.engineering/posts/2023-10-18-taproot-assets-v0.3/

fillippone

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 16328

Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Lightning Labs rebranded their first product ~~rgb~~ TARO as Taproot Assets, and today they are launching their first mainnet alpha.

Taproot assets is a protocol for issuing assets on the Bitcoin blockchain that can be transferred leveraging the Lightning network.

The protocol is described here:
Taproot Assets

Quote

Taproot Assets (formerly Taro) is a new Taproot-powered protocol for issuing assets on the bitcoin blockchain that can be transferred over the Lightning Network for instant, high volume, low fee transactions. At its core, Taproot Assets taps into the security and stability of the Bitcoin network and the speed, scalability, and low fees of Lightning.

For a brief explanation of the protocol, here there are the FAQ.

Today Lightning Labs released their first main net alpha of the product: Taproot Assets v 0.3 where developers and tester can start playing with financial assets issued on chain!

illusive_moose

newbie

Activity: 29

Merit: 19

As for updates on Taproot Assets:

1.) Yes there has been a change because Tari Labs filed a lawsuit against Lightning Labs that Taro sounds too similar. as a result Lightning Labs decided to rebrand rather than fight the lawsuit.

2.) The Taproot Assets Protocol Deamon tapd that run on top of LND is now pretty stable. It sometimes crashes when you don't wait for one black between making transactions.

3.) Taro Assets now only works on-chain. The part with making lightning channels is not yet started but they have some blueprints on how to do it.

As for Tiramisu wallet:

1.) We deployed a test Taproot Assets store that can be found here
https://tapd-store.tarowallet.net
This can be used for testing of your TAPD node.

2.) We newly track testnet asset prices as you can see here
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/3

3.) We support a bunch of faucets also intended for testing
NFT faucet:
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=nft
Other currency faucets:
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=7
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=3
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=8

4.) We maintain a list of NFTs and fungible currencies that you can sell, buy, send, receive or mint your own:
Currencies
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/57
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/3
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/56
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/5
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/7
NFTs
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/121
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/94
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/102
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/115

5.) Here is our web wallet:
https://testnet.tarowallet.net

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6152

Someone from the Arabic local board just brought this to my attention[1]: It looks like Taro has rebranded to "The Taproot assets"[2] and released a new update (0.20.0v) a few days ago

[1] https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/--5453391
[2] https://docs.lightning.engineering/the-lightning-network/taproot-assets
[3] https://github.com/lightninglabs/taproot-assets/releases

DaveF

legendary

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6320

Crypto Swap Exchange

Quote from: ?? on ??

Quote from: OmegaStarScream on March 17, 2023, 03:26:44 AM

Bad news for the project. It looks like they're not going to be able to develop the project any further or even announce the next stage of the protocol until this is sorted out:

Quote from: https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/03/16/lightning-labs-taro-project-faces-halt-as-judge-issues-temporary-injunction-for-trademark-infringement/

Lightning Labs’ Taro Project Faces Halt as Judge Issues Temporary Injunction for Trademark Infringement
-snip-
On Wednesday, Judge William H. Orrick issued a temporary injunction forcing Lightning Labs to halt further development of Taro until the project has been sufficiently rebranded. In its complaint, Tari argued that it and Lightning “compete in the same digital blockchain ecosystem, provide similar, and in some instances identical, goods and services, market to similar developers and users, and appear on the same blockchain platforms.”
-snip-

This is ridiculous. Even though there's only 1 character difference (Tari and Taro), it has different spelling and reference (Taro refer to vegetable, while Tari refers to "newly minted coin"[1]). It's a shame both party (Tari Labs and Lightning Labs) works on open source, but Tari Labs decide to attack Lightning Labs.

[1] https://tarilabs.com/faq/

I do not see it as that big a deal, you can continue to develop and test and work on it, you just can't release market it. So development continues without public releases until they come up with a new name. Stupid, but this is why a lot of huge international mega corps spend more time working on naming and branding then they do on some products. Unless they have some other reason to stop development I don't see it being more then a waste of time and money. And having to give money to lawyers.

Lawyers gotta lawyer, but there is a solution: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=35rErQtJ6uA (warning ~~some~~ a lot bad words)

-Dave

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6152

Bad news for the project. It looks like they're not going to be able to develop the project any further or even announce the next stage of the protocol until this is sorted out:

Quote from: https://www.coindesk.com/business/2023/03/16/lightning-labs-taro-project-faces-halt-as-judge-issues-temporary-injunction-for-trademark-infringement/

Lightning Labs’ Taro Project Faces Halt as Judge Issues Temporary Injunction for Trademark Infringement
-snip-
On Wednesday, Judge William H. Orrick issued a temporary injunction forcing Lightning Labs to halt further development of Taro until the project has been sufficiently rebranded. In its complaint, Tari argued that it and Lightning “compete in the same digital blockchain ecosystem, provide similar, and in some instances identical, goods and services, market to similar developers and users, and appear on the same blockchain platforms.”
-snip-

fillippone

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 16328

Fully fledged Merit Cycler - Golden Feather 22-23

Quote from: illusive_moose on February 08, 2023, 12:57:45 PM

I have created a web wallet for Taro that you can find here
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/

You can use it to test your taro nodes.

The wallet is now only active on testnet but will move to main net as soon as I can.

I have also created a Taro NFT faucet that you can find here
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=nft
(went with tarot cards as NFTs, sorry I know it is lame)

as well as some standard fungible asset faucets
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=294
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=293

Hope it helps you with testing and development.

This is an incredibly well done work.
I will play on this, and for sure I can see this kind of use being moved up quickly from base layer to L2 solutions, due to fees.
OF course I hope that people will exchange more interesting stuff than jpg's on TARO, but I understand futile uses are a necessity in the first place.

illusive_moose

newbie

Activity: 29

Merit: 19

For those who are interested here are a few NFTs and currencies that I have minted on Taro represented as summary website pages.

An initial test NFT
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/308

A girl investing in Bitcoin NFT
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/332

Diamond hands NFT
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/328

You can get more NFT for testing of your node here https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=nft

A test fungible currency called Beckycoin
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/currencies_public/294
there is a faucet for this currency as well here https://testnet.tarowallet.net/walletapp/faucet/?currency=294

Right now I am including the images into metadata resulting in pretty long genesis_bootstrap_info as well as long invoices. Lightning Labs have a PR to fix this https://github.com/lightninglabs/taro/pull/249 .

[ Sorry the images are not showing here ]

illusive_moose

newbie

Activity: 29

Merit: 19

Hi,

sorry, I am now only supporting the testnet legacy adresses (P2PKH) .

Not ideal I know.

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6152

Quote from: illusive_moose on February 15, 2023, 08:53:35 AM

-snip-

Thanks for the response. I've also tried to send BTC from the wallet, and apparently, there's a problem decoding the address (tb1....):

Code:

Invalid character '0'

Or should the address be a taproot one in order for this to work?

illusive_moose

newbie

Activity: 29

Merit: 19

Quote from: OmegaStarScream on February 14, 2023, 03:51:20 AM

Quote from: illusive_moose on February 09, 2023, 05:49:15 AM

Hi,

thanks for your reply.

Yes. Right now it is a CUSTODIAL web wallet. Developing a non-custodial Taro wallet is possible but it would require more implicated approach. I know that privacy-wise there are MILES to go. I am planning to expose an API and release a web app but this is what we have for now.

As for the license - yes I will add this to my TODO list. You are correct this is kind of crucial.

As for username and password - I decided to only go with the basic necessities. I am intentionally not collecting emails.

Is there something wrong with generating invoices? I filled in the description and clicked the button, but I wasn't given anything and the page just keeps refreshing every few seconds.

Hi,

thanks for the feedback.

Right now some operations can be kind of slow.

It is because at the time I wrote the web app tarod would crash if you tried to mint and generate invoices at the same time.

It would also break if you try to mint multiple assets in the same block.

So the web app waits with generating the invoice until all minting requests are processed.

It is a very shitty UX I am sorry and have added this on my list of things to fix.

Also thanks a lot for giving this a test ride - very helpful.

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6152

Quote from: illusive_moose on February 09, 2023, 05:49:15 AM

Hi,

thanks for your reply.

Yes. Right now it is a CUSTODIAL web wallet. Developing a non-custodial Taro wallet is possible but it would require more implicated approach. I know that privacy-wise there are MILES to go. I am planning to expose an API and release a web app but this is what we have for now.

As for the license - yes I will add this to my TODO list. You are correct this is kind of crucial.

As for username and password - I decided to only go with the basic necessities. I am intentionally not collecting emails.

Is there something wrong with generating invoices? I filled in the description and clicked the button, but I wasn't given anything and the page just keeps refreshing every few seconds.

n0nce

hero member

Activity: 882

Merit: 5834

not your keys, not your coins!

Quote from: digaran on February 09, 2023, 12:49:51 AM

Quote from: n0nce on February 08, 2023, 06:10:31 PM

...snip....

Maybe this could be a sweet dream for miners when more people adopt NFT/ smart contracts on bitcoin, but this could also become their nightmare. Using block space to store contracts ^{[emphasis mine]} related to some marketplace and their business conduct, just because they pay the fees for it is not gonna cut it.

Hey hey hey, hold our horses! Wink

Check your facts mate. Taro and RGB are built on Lightning and not on L1. There are no contracts filling up the blockchain in any of this, that's the whole beauty of it.

Just something to get you started..

Quote from: https://lightning.engineering/posts/2022-4-5-taro-launch/

Today we’re excited to announce Taro, a new Taproot-powered protocol for issuing assets on the bitcoin blockchain that can be transferred over the Lightning Network for instant, high volume, low fee transactions.

Quote from: https://rgb.info/

RGB is a protocol to issue and transfer assets and more generic rights through the use of customizable off-chain smart contracts.

The protocol leverages the paradigm of client-side validation to keep all the RGB specific transaction data off-chain, using the Bitcoin blockchain only as a commitment layer to protect from double spending. This enables greater scalability, as the blockchain usage is reduced, better privacy, as no data is visible to the blockchain observer, and more flexibility, as the protocol is not constrained by the data structure of Bitcoin transactions.

illusive_moose

newbie

Activity: 29

Merit: 19

Quote from: dkbit98 on February 08, 2023, 02:11:48 PM

Quote from: illusive_moose on February 08, 2023, 12:57:45 PM

I have created a web wallet for Taro that you can find here
https://testnet.tarowallet.net/

This wallet is still in alpha experimental stage of development, but why do I need to create online account with username and password, instead of downloading wallet and installing it on my computer?
I am not interested in creating and using any altcoins or nft with this wallet, but I would consider using it as alternative for stable coins.
Another problem I have with this wallet is that I can't find any information about license, so you might want to add this on website.

Hi,

thanks for your reply.

Yes. Right now it is a CUSTODIAL web wallet. Developing a non-custodial Taro wallet is possible but it would require more implicated approach. I know that privacy-wise there are MILES to go. I am planning to expose an API and release a web app but this is what we have for now.

As for the license - yes I will add this to my TODO list. You are correct this is kind of crucial.

As for username and password - I decided to only go with the basic necessities. I am intentionally not collecting emails.

digaran

copper member

Activity: 1330

Merit: 899

🖤😏

Quote from: n0nce on February 08, 2023, 06:10:31 PM

...snip....

Maybe this could be a sweet dream for miners when more people adopt NFT/ smart contracts on bitcoin, but this could also become their nightmare. Using block space to store contracts related to some marketplace and their business conduct, just because they pay the fees for it is not gonna cut it. If we could e.g. move 500KBTC and use 4MB of block space paying the normal fee, why should we allow someone to send a few 100 $ worth in bitcoin paying the normal fee and occupying the same amount of space?

Why on earth should the bitcoin community allow centralized third parties to use our buses to get home faster while leaving us waiting longer and longer, paying more and more as time passes? After all we only get 1 bus every 10 minutes. We need to either shut up and get used to it ( not happening ) or *we should do something about it.

There are countless shitcoins out there, if people are interested in NFT/ smart contracts, they should start hugging them instead.

*= either stop this before it's too late, or scale up the network.

n0nce

hero member

Activity: 882

Merit: 5834

not your keys, not your coins!

Quote from: digaran on February 08, 2023, 01:25:28 PM

IMO, this kind of stuff is not healthy for bitcoin right now, this will devalue the bitcoin itself as the money goes to things other than bitcoin.

That's wrong on a few levels.
For one: technologically (my main field), there is nothing wrong with NFT or other experiments on L2, since it doesn't touch (i.e. bloat, spam, block, sabotage in any way) the blockchain.

Secondly, Bitcoin's value (in terms of dollar valuation) is not dependent on development money at all. No matter whether there is more or less development going on in a certain time frame and whether or how high that development is funded, the dollar valuation fluctuates completely independently.

Lastly, it is not guaranteed that 'money going into Taro / higher layer protocols' reduces 'money going into Bitcoin L1 development'. People investing into Taro / NFTs on L2 development are actually most probably not the same ones who donate to Bitcoin Core developers.
Even though that's not a guarantee either, it is far from guaranteed that 'the money goes to things other than bitcoin'; there is not one 'the' money.

Topic: [Discussion] Taro: A new protocol for multi-asset Bitcoin and Lightning (Read 998 times)