I do actually like your reasoning T.Stuart, and one of your longer posts in another thread did have an influencing affect on my Bitcoin outlook.....
......but when I keep having these dreams (what I describe on OP is not the first time), then I feel compelled to bow out of this shit for now.
If you are dreaming about it then it's getting serious - don't worry, I know the feeling!
All I can say is that the feelings of hope and fear have got to be greatly magnified because this is unchartered territory - "too vast and complex for any of our rational minds to fully comprehend" as you say. That's why we are getting wildly fluctuating opinions from financial experts as well.
But think carefully and it's not so unchartered as it might seem. It's a classic story of a fast-growing Internet company like Twitter, Pinterest, Facebook, etc. It's just decentralised! For want of a better example, it's like bacteria growth. It's viral. From this point you just have to try to work out whether or not we are reaching saturation. Unless I have some seriously messed up reading of the situation, we are nowhere near saturation point at all. We are still very early.
And it is this early bird feeling that also heightens fear. But I would argue that we are in a much stronger position than would be a normal company at this stage. The "early mover" head start has given a very clear advantage to Bitcoin. It has by far the biggest momentum and media coverage and why should that stop? Unless there is a serious conspiracy between media outlets, hedge funds, etc. to promote Litecoin or any other altcoin in a coordinated fashion, why would any of them take over from Bitcoin now? We've heard the ugly news, the controversy, the electricity required, etc. It doesn't matter. Bitcoin has sailed through, resiliant as ever.
I cannot tell you exactly why it is so resiliant, but all the signs are there. Personally I think that since 2008, the worst recession for nearly 100 years, the feeling and mental undercurrent - of resentment towards governments, but also the desire to break out of hopelessness and also, to put it bluntly, greed - has grown incredibly strong, and some of this has been chanelled into Bitcoin. And there is so much more of that feeling left! This is regardless of the fact that Bitcoin is really an ingenious technology and a superb payments system. It is just what is needed for the 21st century.
Why do you think Bitcoin has kept going until now, despite the crashes, corruption, controversy, etc. ?