Topic: Feature that should be added - page 2. (Read 2560 times)
I agree, if Bitcoin Core wallet doesn't have this feature then it should definitely be added, Electrum has it and I use it, this way you keep all your funds safe in the offline wallet and when you want to make a transaction, you make it, sign it and take it to the online electrum and broadcast it from there.
This is what I mean..
One should have an offline computer, I'd like to sign a transaction on it, burn it to a CD and post it onto the blockchain from my online computer.
Isn't this exactly what offline signing as supported by, for example, Armory, is?
maybe he want this to work directly with core, without the need to download a specific spv client for any new feature
This. I don't want to have 15 different wallets for 15 different reasons.
I use bitaddress.org and core, would be nice if that is all I would have to use.
This is what I mean..
One should have an offline computer, I'd like to sign a transaction on it, burn it to a CD and post it onto the blockchain from my online computer.
Isn't this exactly what offline signing as supported by, for example, Armory, is?
maybe he want this to work directly with core, without the need to download a specific spv client for any new feature
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
maybe a donation to pay for their time would sway them to divert resources away from security and onto user-friendly.
Really Franky .... We should not encourage bribery as a method to influence Bitcoin development
Or should we sell out to the highest bidder, when crappy ideas pass their table? spazzdla - The whole idea with a online network, is to process transactions on the fly on the Blockchain in real time.. If you want to do that, rather go for a off-chain solution like Xapo, where you can do as many
transactions as you want, and only pay a fee when it goes on-chain.
its not bribery.. its realizing that if its something you cannot do yourself (submit code to the github), then you pay someone to do it for you.
otherwise demanding people do something without payment, is a form of slavery.
'bribery' is to coerce, 'payment' is to pay for services offered.
i agree that the fundamental security of the network protocol should not be a matter of financial debate. but secondary features that do not affect the network, and would take the dev teams time away from the fundamentals. should be paid for
This is what I mean..
One should have an offline computer, I'd like to sign a transaction on it, burn it to a CD and post it onto the blockchain from my online computer.
Isn't this exactly what offline signing as supported by, for example, Armory, is?
legendary
Activity: 3010
Merit: 1028
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
these features already available in few bitcoin wallet , even they have offline wallet feature for storage
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
maybe a donation to pay for their time would sway them to divert resources away from security and onto user-friendly.
Really Franky .... We should not encourage bribery as a method to influence Bitcoin development
Or should we sell out to the highest bidder, when crappy ideas pass their table? spazzdla - The whole idea with a online network, is to process transactions on the fly on the Blockchain in real time.. If you want to do that, rather go for a off-chain solution like Xapo, where you can do as many
transactions as you want, and only pay a fee when it goes on-chain.
My issue isn't fees it's security. I don't want to type my passprhase on an online computer. I will look into Xapo though.
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
maybe a donation to pay for their time would sway them to divert resources away from security and onto user-friendly.
Really Franky .... We should not encourage bribery as a method to influence Bitcoin development
Or should we sell out to the highest bidder, when crappy ideas pass their table? spazzdla - The whole idea with a online network, is to process transactions on the fly on the Blockchain in real time.. If you want to do that, rather go for a off-chain solution like Xapo, where you can do as many
transactions as you want, and only pay a fee when it goes on-chain.
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
What are you talking about? The Bitcoin core wallet? Which wallet? If you want a wallet that does this, the Feature is already available for almost all wallet. (Sign message)
And if you want offline signing, the feature is already available as well; https://bitcoinarmory.com/
This is what I mean..
One should have an offline computer, I'd like to sign a transaction on it, burn it to a CD and post it onto the blockchain from my online computer.
Seeing as security is pretty much the #1 issue.. this seems rather important to me.
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
What are you talking about? The Bitcoin core wallet? Which wallet? If you want a wallet that does this, the Feature is already available for almost all wallet. (Sign message)
And if you want offline signing, the feature is already available as well; https://bitcoinarmory.com/
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
What are you talking about? The Bitcoin core wallet? Which wallet? If you want a wallet that does this, the Feature is already available for almost all wallet. (Sign message)
And if you want offline signing, the feature is already available as well; https://bitcoinarmory.com/
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
bitcoin-core is 99% about protecting the network by decentralising the blockchain.. so features will be a secondary thing.
much like banks SWIFT network has nothing to do with Visa's contactless NFC features.
but if you want the feature added to bitcoin-core, there is nothing stopping you talking to the dev team.. as im pretty sure that comments on this forum dont really register on the dev teams radar as a place to get feature requests..
plus because it's not really essential to the security of the network, maybe a donation to pay for their time would sway them to divert resources away from security and onto user-friendly.
Under file it should have "Write offline transaction" and "Put offline transaction online" or something along those words. Already has sign/verify message, sweet feature.
Jump to: