Follow up: I'm the guy who sent a transaction with 2.5 BTC fee.. I'm sorry..

Stedsm

legendary

Activity: 3052

Merit: 1273

Quote from: dothebeats on April 08, 2017, 10:04:31 AM

In all honesty, the pool doesn't owe you anything since it's your fault in the first place however they are so kind enough to actually give the fee back even though it costed them some few thousand bucks. It's great to hear that you got your funds back and you are now taking extra caution to ensure everything is okay, and to the people of Antpool, you guys rock.

Agree with you and just think, if this would have happened in real world and OP would have given some extra fiat, do you think the other person would ever give them back to him? No, right? The pool had been great enough here to pay back that amount which the entity lose due to his own mistake. Hats off to Antpool, and everyone please have a look always when sending any amounts to anybody and especially the fee part.

choppork

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Quote from: Red-Apple on April 08, 2017, 07:46:04 AM

Quote from: -ck on April 08, 2017, 05:29:58 AM

I recall a 90BTC fee by mistake a few years ago... they did eventually get their 90btc back.

there was a 291.2409BTC fee equal to $136000 exactly one year ago (2016-4)
https://blockchain.info/tx/cc455ae816e6cdafdb58d54e35d4f46d860047458eacf1c7405dc634631c570d

they said Bitclub (who mined the block) offered to return the amount but i don't see anything returning to that address though Wink

there was some drama on bitcointalk too

The OP made me smile and this post made me think that wasn't unfair. 2.5BTC is probably nothing to those people so they didn't really mind giving it back to the owner. 291BTC is quite a large amount of money so it doesn't make me wonder why didn't the people give it back to the owner. You already hit the jackpot, why even bother.

Quote from: xhomerx10 on April 08, 2017, 09:20:25 AM

I really appreciate you coming back to give us some closure and to explain exactly how the mistake occurred. This is a valuable lesson for anyone attempting to apply the fees manually. Thanks.

Not really sure if this counts as "valuable lesson" since it was just an honest (and low-key dumb, tbh) mistake. It was you who helped him, thanks for making us all smile. Behind all the dramas here on bitcointalk and the endless fighting, something finally gave us some light.

Quote from: dothebeats on April 08, 2017, 10:04:31 AM

In all honesty, the pool doesn't owe you anything since it's your fault in the first place however they are so kind enough to actually give the fee back even though it costed them some few thousand bucks. It's great to hear that you got your funds back and you are now taking extra caution to ensure everything is okay, and to the people of Antpool, you guys rock.

I don't think it costed them that much, though. Since the fee went straight to them. It was just a typical transaction that has very large fee. I might be wrong though.

dothebeats

legendary

Activity: 3542

Merit: 1352

Cashback 15%

In all honesty, the pool doesn't owe you anything since it's your fault in the first place however they are so kind enough to actually give the fee back even though it costed them some few thousand bucks. It's great to hear that you got your funds back and you are now taking extra caution to ensure everything is okay, and to the people of Antpool, you guys rock.

YuginKadoya

legendary

Activity: 3038

Merit: 1169

Wow! a total input of 2.74701244 BTC that is much money for me and I think you needed it the most for you college, and at least they have return what is not meant to be the transaction fee and in your case it is an accident you had made so the next time you are trying to make a transaction just double or triple check it before pressing the send button!

JohnUser

hero member

Activity: 1022

Merit: 725

Quote from: Kprawn on April 08, 2017, 09:32:03 AM

Everyone loves a happy ending

yeap,it make my day

Kprawn

legendary

Activity: 1904

Merit: 1074

Everyone loves a happy ending and this was also a pretty good one in my books. Some whales might think 2 BTC is not such a big deal, but if

something like this happens with people with small amounts of bitcoins and they stop using the technology because of these types of mistakes,

then this is a huge deal. These Wallet providers should give a warning message, when people wants to send huge fees like this. Angry

xhomerx10

legendary

Activity: 3808

Merit: 7912

I really appreciate you coming back to give us some closure and to explain exactly how the mistake occurred. This is a valuable lesson for anyone attempting to apply the fees manually. Thanks.

megynacuna

sr. member

Activity: 756

Merit: 253

Quote from: Voiceeeeee on April 08, 2017, 04:54:54 AM

Hi, so exactly a month ago from now I posted a thread about me panicking due to sending a transaction with a 2.5 BTC fee, which you can see here.

Now, right when I posted this thread I went ahead and opened a ticket with AntPool on my own and I received the following reply the next day.

Quote

Dear Faris,

We have applied your loss for the financial apartment in our company, they will process it soon.

And I will inform you when they pay the 2.5BTC to your wallet address.

Before that, you can release and just wait. You will get your 2.5 BTC loss back. Don't worry about that.

Looking forward to continuing to build your trust and bringing you more added values through our advanced technology and passion.

Beat Regards,
Hugh
Bitmain

Which is basically when I relaxed and knew I'm dealing with a good pool, and of course 4 days after that (or 6 days after the incident), I received my 2.5 BTC!

Now, the reason I'm apologizing is because I basically ignored the massive attention my thread got and everyone who tried to help me. Especially xhomerx10.. I didn't get email notifications nor notifications here on Bitcointalk and I completely forgot about the whole thing.

So yea, I'm sorry for ignoring everyone who tried to help me, I really appreciate it, thank you!

Oh, another thing, nope, I'm not affiliated with AntPool in any way, I'm just a normal user who did a mistake and needed actual help, and I'm very grateful for the help I received.

This is how I did this; I was using Blockchain.info and wanted to send a transaction, I went to Preev.com and entered 2.5 USD to get the amount in Bitcoin and put a $2.5 fee, instead of copying the amount in Bitcoin I copied the USD amount (which is 2.5, so..) and put it in Blockchain. Funny enough, it almost happened to me again that day, though since I check like 5 times now, I noticed it.

To answer another question, no, AntPool did not make me sign a message. They just returned money to the one it was sent from. They asked me if it's my address and I said yea.

The reason I'm not posting this in the original thread is because it was locked by an admin, or that is what it tells me when I try to unlock it anyways.

Quote

This was locked by an administrator. You cannot unlock it.

Thanks everyone.

You're a lucky ass, hope you don't repeat that mistake ever again. Happy all went well for you in the end though.

Red-Apple

hero member

Activity: 1470

Merit: 655

Quote from: -ck on April 08, 2017, 05:29:58 AM

I recall a 90BTC fee by mistake a few years ago... they did eventually get their 90btc back.

there was a 291.2409BTC fee equal to $136000 exactly one year ago (2016-4)
https://blockchain.info/tx/cc455ae816e6cdafdb58d54e35d4f46d860047458eacf1c7405dc634631c570d

they said Bitclub (who mined the block) offered to return the amount but i don't see anything returning to that address though Wink

there was some drama on bitcointalk too

paul gatt

hero member

Activity: 896

Merit: 500

Quote from: Voiceeeeee on April 08, 2017, 04:54:54 AM

Hi, so exactly a month ago from now I posted a thread about me panicking due to sending a transaction with a 2.5 BTC fee, which you can see here.

Now, right when I posted this thread I went ahead and opened a ticket with AntPool on my own and I received the following reply the next day.

Quote

Dear Faris,

We have applied your loss for the financial apartment in our company, they will process it soon.

And I will inform you when they pay the 2.5BTC to your wallet address.

Before that, you can release and just wait. You will get your 2.5 BTC loss back. Don't worry about that.

Looking forward to continuing to build your trust and bringing you more added values through our advanced technology and passion.

Beat Regards,
Hugh
Bitmain

Which is basically when I relaxed and knew I'm dealing with a good pool, and of course 4 days after that (or 6 days after the incident), I received my 2.5 BTC!

Now, the reason I'm apologizing is because I basically ignored the massive attention my thread got and everyone who tried to help me. Especially xhomerx10.. I didn't get email notifications nor notifications here on Bitcointalk and I completely forgot about the whole thing.

So yea, I'm sorry for ignoring everyone who tried to help me, I really appreciate it, thank you!

Oh, another thing, nope, I'm not affiliated with AntPool in any way, I'm just a normal user who did a mistake and needed actual help, and I'm very grateful for the help I received.

This is how I did this; I was using Blockchain.info and wanted to send a transaction, I went to Preev.com and entered 2.5 USD to get the amount in Bitcoin and put a $2.5 fee, instead of copying the amount in Bitcoin I copied the USD amount (which is 2.5, so..) and put it in Blockchain. Funny enough, it almost happened to me again that day, though since I check like 5 times now, I noticed it.

To answer another question, no, AntPool did not make me sign a message. They just returned money to the one it was sent from. They asked me if it's my address and I said yea.

The reason I'm not posting this in the original thread is because it was locked by an admin, or that is what it tells me when I try to unlock it anyways.

Quote

This was locked by an administrator. You cannot unlock it.

Thanks everyone.

This may be a lesson for you, everyone here is always caring and help each other. We are the people who live here, we talk and we make money by bitcoin. We understand each other, so we are always ready to help anyone by our means. Believe it, we always want good things for everyone. Helping each other is essential in this forum, because if we are having a hard time, everyone here is willing to help and support you. 2.5btc is a great amount of money, I'm glad you did not lose that money.

Qartada

hero member

Activity: 546

Merit: 500

Very nice of you to acknowledge the people who supported you in the thread. I wouldn't make this too much about Antpool though - they are only a good pool in the sense that they're a very big one and have a reputation which they don't want to (continue to) damage. The repayment of your funds was interpreted quite poorly, one user even said in your previous thread:

Quote

Wow. A bitcoin company that functions on morals instead of greed. Even more trust than before can be put into hashnest, bitmain and antpool.

Antpool definitely function on greed though, actually they take 2.5% fees when they mine a block and they also take transaction fees - by comparison, KanoPool takes 0.9% fees for the block and don't take transaction fees. Blockchain estimate that there are transaction fees of over 200 Bitcoin per day, and Antpool controls about 16.3% of the hashrate, meaning that they would pull in daily tx fee amount x 0.163 daily, currently around 36 Bitcoin every day, and they also get an expected 23 blocks a day, meaning that they would get 12.5 (block reward) x 23 (expected blocks mined) x (amount of block reward taken by Antpool) 0.025 Bitcoin per day, which is about 7 Bitcoin.

So based on that maths which I like doing, they expect to earn over 40 Bitcoin per day just from running the pool, so returning your fee doesn't make the pool generous - it could just be that they would get very bad PR if they refused to repay, since they're a major pool and many Core supporters are going to (sometimes reasonably) jump on any chance to discredit them.

jtipt

hero member

Activity: 1050

Merit: 529

Quote from: -ck on April 08, 2017, 05:29:58 AM

I recall a 90BTC fee by mistake a few years ago... they did eventually get their 90btc back.

Wow compared to that 2.5 BTC is nothing. But still OP glad to see that you got your BTC back, I also posted in your other thread that its good to see that the miner pool actually did return your btc, it was very generous of then really because they are not obliged to return any BTC received as fees.

LeGaulois

copper member

Activity: 2940

Merit: 4101

Top Crypto Casino

Glad to see your problem is solved. 2.5 BTC is quite a nice amount of cash this days. I think you can consider yourself lucky, i would be very happy if the same happened to me. So to celebrate this, is there any party somewhere ? You can pm me the adress no problem Cheesy

thanks to antpool for the generosity, we rarely see such thing

BitcoinPanther

hero member

Activity: 1918

Merit: 564

I have read your thread about the appeal, its good to know that you had acknowledged the effort done by xhomerx10.

It is reassuring to know that there are people here who are willing to help those who are in distress and the fact that the pool who mined the transaction are willing to return the BTC even it is the fault of the sender due to the fact that it was really needed at their cost since as they had stated, it had been distributed to the miners. I commend you AntPool and xhomerx10, I wish there are more company and people like you in Bitcoin community.

carlfebz2

hero member

Activity: 2926

Merit: 722

DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook

You got lucky you did engage into a good pool and immediately resolved your problem in a matter of week which i consider as a fast response thats why be careful next time on sending or adjusting fee so that this situation wont hapoen to you again and 2.5 btc is huge. This is my first time to hear out this kind of amount of fee

SONG GEET

hero member

Activity: 700

Merit: 500

CryptoTalk.Org - Get Paid for every Post!

You got really lucky to get your bitcoin back even though it was your mistake to send 2.5BTC in fees. You have to thank antpool for giving you back your bitcoins. If that block was mined by any other mining pools you might have lost those bitcoins.

Daniel91

legendary

Activity: 3374

Merit: 1824

I'm happy that you could resolve your issue.
2.5 BTC is really a lot money now.
When I sending bitcoin funds, I always double check everything, you never know.
Usually, when I start any transaction, recommended transaction fee is already added to my transaction.
It's the simplest and easiest way to send money, I think.

Xester

hero member

Activity: 994

Merit: 544

Quote from: Voiceeeeee on April 08, 2017, 04:54:54 AM

Hi, so exactly a month ago from now I posted a thread about me panicking due to sending a transaction with a 2.5 BTC fee, which you can see here.

Now, right when I posted this thread I went ahead and opened a ticket with AntPool on my own and I received the following reply the next day.

Quote

Dear Faris,

We have applied your loss for the financial apartment in our company, they will process it soon.

And I will inform you when they pay the 2.5BTC to your wallet address.

Before that, you can release and just wait. You will get your 2.5 BTC loss back. Don't worry about that.

Looking forward to continuing to build your trust and bringing you more added values through our advanced technology and passion.

Beat Regards,
Hugh
Bitmain

Which is basically when I relaxed and knew I'm dealing with a good pool, and of course 4 days after that (or 6 days after the incident), I received my 2.5 BTC!

Now, the reason I'm apologizing is because I basically ignored the massive attention my thread got and everyone who tried to help me. Especially xhomerx10.. I didn't get email notifications nor notifications here on Bitcointalk and I completely forgot about the whole thing.

So yea, I'm sorry for ignoring everyone who tried to help me, I really appreciate it, thank you!

Oh, another thing, nope, I'm not affiliated with AntPool in any way, I'm just a normal user who did a mistake and needed actual help, and I'm very grateful for the help I received.

This is how I did this; I was using Blockchain.info and wanted to send a transaction, I went to Preev.com and entered 2.5 USD to get the amount in Bitcoin and put a $2.5 fee, instead of copying the amount in Bitcoin I copied the USD amount (which is 2.5, so..) and put it in Blockchain. Funny enough, it almost happened to me again that day, though since I check like 5 times now, I noticed it.

To answer another question, no, AntPool did not make me sign a message. They just returned money to the one it was sent from. They asked me if it's my address and I said yea.

The reason I'm not posting this in the original thread is because it was locked by an admin, or that is what it tells me when I try to unlock it anyways.

Quote

This was locked by an administrator. You cannot unlock it.

Thanks everyone.

I remembered your post back then and I was one of the users who place a comment on your post. At that time you were in panicked and worried that you cannot get back your bitcoin. But anyway I am happy to see you regain your 2.5 btc back, that is a significant amount and I am proud of antpool for being honest on that kind of issue.

-ck

legendary

Activity: 4088

Merit: 1631

Ruu \o/

I recall a 90BTC fee by mistake a few years ago... they did eventually get their 90btc back.

Davkul

full member

Activity: 136

Merit: 100

I don’t care

Quote from: Telepo on April 08, 2017, 05:01:39 AM

Quote from: Voiceeeeee on April 08, 2017, 04:54:54 AM

Hi, so exactly a month ago from now I posted a thread about me panicking due to sending a transaction with a 2.5 BTC fee, which you can see here.

Now, right when I posted this thread I went ahead and opened a ticket with AntPool and I received the following reply the next day.

Quote

Dear Faris,

We have applied your loss for the financial apartment in our company, they will process it soon.

And I will inform you when they pay the 2.5BTC to your wallet address.

Before that, you can release and just wait. You will get your 2.5 BTC loss back. Don't worry about that.

Looking forward to continuing to build your trust and bringing you more added values through our advanced technology and passion.

Beat Regards,
Hugh
Bitmain

Which is basically when I relaxed and knew I'm dealing with a good pool, and of course 4 days after that (or 6 days after the incident), I received my 2.5 BTC!

Now, the reason I'm apologizing is because I basically ignored the massive attention my thread got and everyone who tried to help me. Especially xhomerx10.. I didn't get email notifications nor notifications here on Bitcointalk and I completely forgot about the whole thing.

So yea, I'm sorry for ignoring everyone who tried to help me, I really appreciate it, thank you!

Oh, another thing, nope, I'm not affiliated with AntPool in any way, I'm just a normal user who did a mistake and needed actual help.

The reason I'm not posting this in the original thread is because it was locked by an admin, or that is what it tells me when I try to unlock it anyways.

Quote

This was locked by an administrator. You cannot unlock it.

Thanks everyone.

Wow, This is the first time to hear a very big fee for one transaction and it's unbelievable. I think you must have many bitcoins in your wallet.

First time? Lol, stuff like this happens pretty much everyday. Maybe not that amount, but close or even bigger.

Topic: Follow up: I'm the guy who sent a transaction with 2.5 BTC fee.. I'm sorry.. (Read 1166 times)