Topic: freebitco.in "Browser Mining" - is it worth it? - page 9. (Read 20725 times)

To put it in a way that's easy to understand: To mine bitcoin with your browser (aka: with your CPU) it's like tring to empty an ocean with a spoon. Now think about how much this is worth and you have your answer if you should do it or not. This is beside the additional risk of instaling some sort of malware.

Nobody can tell you what to do, but comparing the risk (high risk) and the rewards (practically 0) I'm shure you will make the right decision.

Trying freebitco.in mining, gives me around 25 sat an hour with a PC. Interesting only on a computer/device you don't pay energy for.
No risk of overheating btw, CPU of modern devices slows himself when getting too hot.

I was curious so I tried it with moonbitcoin yesterday and it installed a "bitcoin miner" in the "cache" directory of my browser. It has been identified as a riskware by my anti-virus so I deleted it.

I am a chosen one by freebitco.in but I won't activate mining, I think it is useless for the moment.

You're right there is no danger overheating. There's even a control slider so you can select the % of CPU to use. I'm pretty sure it is mining Monero, from the payout rate to H/s, it fits. I've done some testing and calculated that if you're using the PC anyway then using a little bit of CPU to mine in the background is actually profitable on most modern hardware.

I don't really think you'll overheat or kill your hardware with in-browser mining. It's limited to specifications allocated to your browser, so it might slow down performance but that's it. The flip side is that you're likely to make precisely nothing with this if they are actually using your hash rate to mine Bitcoin. If you manage to get anything out of this, my guess is that they are mining Monero. Or maybe they are just using you for ad revenue and paying out like a faucet.

its not worth it for my friends experience in telegram he use that but its like coinpot you can really earn,not big and total waste of time,try bonus bitcoin,moonbitcoin,moondoge,moonlitoshi its like that,see is to believe so try it

I checked it out and I have to say things like this are never worth the effort and the risk. you are risking over heating and killing your hardware after all. and at the very least you will shorten the life of your hardware while getting paid a very small amount which is negligible.

if you want to mine you have to do it more seriously, with real equipment (an ASIC miner or some GPU rigs) and with cheap electricity. all the rest of the methods will never be worth the damage.

its complete not worth as i can see when i sue my cpu to other direct mining pool i get more hash rate then in freebitco .may be they using this hash to mining in differ pool get more rate and provide less to us as i can see there rate .

So best will be mine direct to good pool or if you need more hash mine in new pool with less hash so you get better share and profit

It updates about every 5 minutes. I'm getting ~20 sats/hr at 13H/s so you made need to wait a bit longer.

Of course it's not worth it. Do you actually think that sitting there and letting the browser run consuming your electricity and your computer is going to ever pay off for you? This is something that may have two or three years ago produced a small effect but it is something that is never going to earn you good. Time is to move on something which is more productive and profitable.

Maybe if you had read the thread before posting you wouldn't have been so wrong.

What you need to mine with depends on the coin you are mining. A GPU is not the only thing you can profitably mine with. This looks like it is mining XMR which is suited to CPU mining. As I posted earlier I have actually tested the service, with the right CPU you could make a profit. It's best if you just leave a browser tab at a low % usage in the background while you're using the PC for something else then you are only paying for the extra CPU usage which is minimal.

No, that doesn't worth to you at all and you will be paying huge electricity bill for mining also you need high GPU PC that handle for mining.

I think that's explained well and looking unto the promising effect of the mining cpu, maybe that's not yet performing for a long time. The computer hardware might be overworking for several hours doing the mining operations. For me it still not worth it for now since, using personal computers in mining doesn't conform to the actual performances of dedicated mining gpu's.

This is not any kind of income. You are wasting your money on electricity and potentially reducing your productivity from the noise and lag generated by the mining activity. I'm not even sure why freebitco.in decided to implement this, it probably will generate them a ridiculously amount of profit as well from the commissions.

It is not worth it at all if you have no cheap electricity and new miners capable of calculating many GH/s or even TH/s per second.

And if you do why the hell would you mine for freebitco.in? Either solo mine or join a pool as magneto said!

Unless you have free or close to free electricity, have the equipment to do it, you don't mind your computer overheating all the time and possibly shortening your CPU's lifespan with close to no reward then sure, go ahead and do it.

Trust me, in the end you won't even make enough to cover transaction fees for a single bitcoin transaction.

Not worth it at all and i would assume that freebitco.in takes some commission as well. If you had the right equipment, free electricity, and a whole farm of computers then i think joining a pool with no fees or little fees would make the most sense.

I did check out my profile on freebitco.in and found out that the experimental mining was not available for me. The above comments conclude that even if we try the experimental mining of freebitco.in it would not be a good option to stick to that for long. The rewards are obviously quite less for the amount of time our PC stays active. I know that it depends on the CPU power and processor on how much rewards we get but still it is less for the amount of time we spend on it.

OK, I agree that statement is a bit misleading. We both know that CPU mining BTC directly would be insane in 2017, it really has to be mining something else and XMR is the most likely candidate. I guess that the majority of their userbase isn't really going to have a clue what they are on about if they put that info on the site.

Edit:
Coinwarz numbers on XMR 13H/s @ 8.5w gives $1.05 profit anually.

I don't belong to the trial group, so i cannot check by myself, however, the op posted following image in his very first post:

It clearly states: "use your browser to passively mine bitcoin", it's right in the first, bold, line in the screenshot.



I'm sorry i must have missed the part where you said it was probably XMR... I won't re-do the calculations to see if XMR mining would be profitable. I was just digging into the info i found in this thread and must have missed your initial conclusion.

Where did they claim to be mining BTC? That would be crazy and wasn't even worth your time running the numbers on. As I stated at the start they're most likely is mining XMR and trading it for BTC. I'm sure they'll confirm in good time.

As for the calculations, my ones are based on actual result whereas yours is based on mining BTC which is not what is happening. I stand by making breakeven on my first day of testing with an old i5. Of course, if you want to come up with some conspiracy theories that something more sinister than mining XMR is going on then I'll leave you to enjoy yourself.

Since people were saying this is not some kind of experiment, and a lot of nonsense was being posted, even claimed they could break even... I decided to digg a little bit deeper.

I have to admit, i was a bit lazy, so i used this post to get the formula daily revenue:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.8221939


Offcourse, the block reward dropped to 12.5, so we have to exchange 25 to 12.5 in the above formula

So, the revenue = the hashrate (H/s) * 491512500  / 281474976710656 / Difficulty * 144
If we use this formula to calculate the dayly revenue of an antminer S9:
1.4e+13 * 491512500 / 281474976710656 / 1103400932964* 144 = 0.00319045009

coinwarz is a pretty reliable mining calculator used by lot of people, at this moment, it reports a dayly revenue of 0.00319050. I think this proves the formula is relatively correct.

abhinav_thakur01 reported a hashrate of 1-2 H/s

Plug 2 H/s into the above formula:
2 * 491512500 / 281474976710656 / 1103400932964* 144 = 4.56 e-16 = 0.0000000000000005 BTC/day = 0.00000005 satoshi's/day = you'll need to mine over 50.000 years to mine a single satoshi at a speed of 2 hashes per second.

If we re-read TheQuin's statement, and combine it with abhinav_thakur01 speed report, then plug everything into coinwarz with a 10 cent/kwu power cost

link
We see that the net loss of such a mining operation would be ~$7/year, simply because (luckily) the power draw was only 8.5 watt. The net loss is calculated this way: the income of your mining is 0 (nill, nothing, zip) minus the power costs (~$7/year) gives a net loss of ~$7/year.

A re-state my previous theories about freebitco.in browser mining... i'm pretty sure one of these theories (or a combination of these theories) is the correct one:

• OR they're not bitcoin mining like they claim, but mine a coin that is still cpu-only minable, but still pay you in BTC
• OR they're performing some other task in the background... Don't know which one tough
• OR they just use the browser mining as a trick to keep you on their page... They subsidise your account for staying with them 24/7, watching adds

And as a final wacko theory i wanted to add this link: http://www.csl.mete.metu.edu.tr/Electromigration/emig.htm
It's an interesting read for everybody that claims there is no harm at running your cpu at 100% for long times (or overclocking your cpu).
I know it's not completely on-topic,  but it's still interesting nonetheless