Topic: GameKatana - Crash - Provably Fair - page 2. (Read 563 times)
Lack of information about this game
Are you in a hurry to launch your gambling site? I just checked the site but it looks very bad for first impression, it looks like a website designed by non experienced designer/developer.
You are going to provide pvp based game but first impression is not good at all, how could you announce it while it does look like unfinished project? My suggestion, take the site down first while you are working on it until everything is ready and good to be re-announced. Otherwise, most people here wont be back to visit your site if they see how bad your site is at the moment.
You are going to provide pvp based game but first impression is not good at all, how could you announce it while it does look like unfinished project? My suggestion, take the site down first while you are working on it until everything is ready and good to be re-announced. Otherwise, most people here wont be back to visit your site if they see how bad your site is at the moment.
Your site is too much unprofessional and I am not confident spending my money on this site. You should do two things instantly. First make a friendly layout of your site and secondly, create a login option in your site. Without login, it will be difficult to track and contact the support in case any mishap happens with our deposits.
On a serious note: once I landed on the page, I don’t know where I’m heading to afterwards. UI seems ti be very unintuitive with little to no effort in making it easier for the newbs to understand. I understand the PvP aspect of gambling, but with the site design it feels as if I’m thrown into some kind of a void. It definitely needs a lot more effort and tweaking to do aesthetic-wise and possibly the way you generate addresses for deposits.
very unprofessional, quickly put with no efforts made to make the site appealing. it's the typical site that a scammer would make(not that I'm saying you are).
if you want to attract gamblers you'll have to do better than this OP, or gamblers will just ignore your site.
if you want to attract gamblers you'll have to do better than this OP, or gamblers will just ignore your site.
There are many issues about his new unfinished gambling site. I don't know why OP release this too soon and the concept with having no account is the one I really don't suggest with a gambling site, There are many factors a gambler can lose his credits if he plays as a guest/no account like this gambling site who don't even have an option to create one.
If I'm in a gambler point of view, I won't even be bothered not to play in this gambling site especially that this gambling site has too many issues, There are better gambling sites out there. Why would I even play on this
I recommend OP to finish first his gambling site before introducing it into community for more positive feedbacks. Especially you need an edge to fight those good established gambling sites.
If I'm in a gambler point of view, I won't even be bothered not to play in this gambling site especially that this gambling site has too many issues, There are better gambling sites out there. Why would I even play on this
I recommend OP to finish first his gambling site before introducing it into community for more positive feedbacks. Especially you need an edge to fight those good established gambling sites.
I'm sorry OP but this doesn't even look like a site I'd visit , not even talking about trusting my money to
plain and unprofessional are the mildest adjectives that come to mind
it doesn't have a security certificate , the PVP games are tricky to implement a good and reliable provably fair system
but you seem to not bother with it altogether
minimal coding skills and a post on a forum is not enough to start a business , this looks more like a student's essay rather than a book if you get the analogy
plain and unprofessional are the mildest adjectives that come to mind
it doesn't have a security certificate , the PVP games are tricky to implement a good and reliable provably fair system
but you seem to not bother with it altogether
minimal coding skills and a post on a forum is not enough to start a business , this looks more like a student's essay rather than a book if you get the analogy
I do agree with you. You can't feel any professionalism when you visit the site.
If there is no trust, then who would deposit blindly to their site?
PVP games are already very hard to attract players.
And with their site's interface, I don't think they will attract high-rollers here.
I've gone ahead and read into your provably fair methodology.
There's a problem here which immediately stands out to me, you're not using an external source of randomness to pull the results.
Ontop of an external random source, it needs to be unknown untill both players are in the match as well, and verifiable beforehand that it wasn't changed.
Like I said earlier this can be accomplished by either using random.org's ticket API OR using something such as the hash of an unmined bitcoin block.
The reason you generating a random winner and hashing it with a salt beforehand and displaying the hash to the user, isn't random, is due to the fact the house could know who wins in this case.
Ontop of the house being able to know who the winner or loser is, they can purposely make games under their own accounts as well in which are wins for them and still seem "provably fair"
There's a problem here which immediately stands out to me, you're not using an external source of randomness to pull the results.
Ontop of an external random source, it needs to be unknown untill both players are in the match as well, and verifiable beforehand that it wasn't changed.
Like I said earlier this can be accomplished by either using random.org's ticket API OR using something such as the hash of an unmined bitcoin block.
The reason you generating a random winner and hashing it with a salt beforehand and displaying the hash to the user, isn't random, is due to the fact the house could know who wins in this case.
Ontop of the house being able to know who the winner or loser is, they can purposely make games under their own accounts as well in which are wins for them and still seem "provably fair"
This is very disturbing as provable fairness is very vital aspect in gambling site.
I've gone ahead and read into your provably fair methodology.
There's a problem here which immediately stands out to me, you're not using an external source of randomness to pull the results.
Ontop of an external random source, it needs to be unknown untill both players are in the match as well, and verifiable beforehand that it wasn't changed.
Like I said earlier this can be accomplished by either using random.org's ticket API OR using something such as the hash of an unmined bitcoin block.
The reason you generating a random winner and hashing it with a salt beforehand and displaying the hash to the user, isn't random, is due to the fact the house could know who wins in this case.
Ontop of the house being able to know who the winner or loser is, they can purposely make games under their own accounts as well in which are wins for them and still seem "provably fair"
There's a problem here which immediately stands out to me, you're not using an external source of randomness to pull the results.
Ontop of an external random source, it needs to be unknown untill both players are in the match as well, and verifiable beforehand that it wasn't changed.
Like I said earlier this can be accomplished by either using random.org's ticket API OR using something such as the hash of an unmined bitcoin block.
The reason you generating a random winner and hashing it with a salt beforehand and displaying the hash to the user, isn't random, is due to the fact the house could know who wins in this case.
Ontop of the house being able to know who the winner or loser is, they can purposely make games under their own accounts as well in which are wins for them and still seem "provably fair"
We switched a new design and will keep going to improve it.
I am aware our site has some weak points but we are developing it with your feedbacks.
And about the provably fair: We have a provably fair system i didn't say anything about it in the topic, so you probably assumed we don't.
I will now edit the post and explain how it works.
Thank you.
I am aware our site has some weak points but we are developing it with your feedbacks.
And about the provably fair: We have a provably fair system i didn't say anything about it in the topic, so you probably assumed we don't.
I will now edit the post and explain how it works.
Thank you.
Few pointers that are purely objective,
If you're doing PvP you need a viable provably fair system in place with an external source of random.
This can be accomplished by drawing the winners either from random.org tickets, or unmined bitcoin / a different blockchains block.
You'd have to show proof of using X random source when a player joins, i.e creating a random.org ticket beforehand or using a chosen unmined block's hash to draw the result.
If you're doing PvP you need a viable provably fair system in place with an external source of random.
This can be accomplished by drawing the winners either from random.org tickets, or unmined bitcoin / a different blockchains block.
You'd have to show proof of using X random source when a player joins, i.e creating a random.org ticket beforehand or using a chosen unmined block's hash to draw the result.
I'm sorry OP but this doesn't even look like a site I'd visit , not even talking about trusting my money to
plain and unprofessional are the mildest adjectives that come to mind
it doesn't have a security certificate , the PVP games are tricky to implement a good and reliable provably fair system
but you seem to not bother with it altogether
minimal coding skills and a post on a forum is not enough to start a business , this looks more like a student's essay rather than a book if you get the analogy
plain and unprofessional are the mildest adjectives that come to mind
it doesn't have a security certificate , the PVP games are tricky to implement a good and reliable provably fair system
but you seem to not bother with it altogether
minimal coding skills and a post on a forum is not enough to start a business , this looks more like a student's essay rather than a book if you get the analogy
Your website is very plain. It's plain in a way that why it only shows "create match" on the very first page?
Check the website guys and see what I'm talking about that "very plain". This website has to be developed and how could you get trust from gamblers if your website isn't even made well.
Check the website guys and see what I'm talking about that "very plain". This website has to be developed and how could you get trust from gamblers if your website isn't even made well.
I have been tried to create a deposit address, but its took long time and I had wait couple of minutes but still it was on loading. OP is website is under construction? I don't know what was exact reason that I won't create deposit address. On the other hand you should add more info on your website l, its looking like a blank page. Also you should be more creative to create ANN thread, just buy copper membership and you will able to create good design. It's also most important to attract gamblers. Even check deposit also just loading...........
For me creating a deposite address was in a second but, I was not happy with the layout and the less professional design of the website. OP your team has to improve it. Since, there is no registration required my primary concer will be my opponent player as it can be a bot that I might be playing with.
Since nobody didn't like the design, i informed my developers for a new design.
I have been tried to create a deposit address, but its took long time and I had wait couple of minutes but still it was on loading. OP is website is under construction? I don't know what was exact reason that I won't create deposit address. On the other hand you should add more info on your website l, its looking like a blank page. Also you should be more creative to create ANN thread, just buy copper membership and you will able to create good design. It's also most important to attract gamblers. Even check deposit also just loading...........
For me creating a deposite address was in a second but, I was not happy with the layout and the less professional design of the website. OP your team has to improve it. Since, there is no registration required my primary concer will be my opponent player as it can be a bot that I might be playing with.
Since nobody didn't like the design, i informed my developers for a new design.
I have been tried to create a deposit address, but its took long time and I had wait couple of minutes but still it was on loading. OP is website is under construction? I don't know what was exact reason that I won't create deposit address. On the other hand you should add more info on your website l, its looking like a blank page. Also you should be more creative to create ANN thread, just buy copper membership and you will able to create good design. It's also most important to attract gamblers. Even check deposit also just loading...........
For me creating a deposite address was in a second but, I was not happy with the layout and the less professional design of the website. OP your team has to improve it. Since, there is no registration required my primary concer will be my opponent player as it can be a bot that I might be playing with.
You project not yet ready at all. You still have more development to make it real. At leats you should have an F.A.Q to give an explain; how it's works, about who you are, how we trust you, how about provably fair ... etc.
I have been tried to create a deposit address, but its took long time and I had wait couple of minutes but still it was on loading. OP is website is under construction? I don't know what was exact reason that I won't create deposit address. On the other hand you should add more info on your website l, its looking like a blank page. Also you should be more creative to create ANN thread, just buy copper membership and you will able to create good design. It's also most important to attract gamblers. Even check deposit also just loading...........
Sorry for the problem. I got some messages about the payment check system. So we needed a short maintenance to automate it.Now after the deposit our system should approve it automatically.
You now should be able to generate your deposit address.
Thank you for care.
There is no serious effort from the owner of this new site gamekatana to attract users to play on his site. Insecure website, non provably fair game while it is pvp based game, bad design of the website as well as bad ANN thread. Owner do not even introduce about what kind of game is this, how does it works in more details etc. No one will try this site obviously.
I have been tried to create a deposit address, but its took long time and I had wait couple of minutes but still it was on loading. OP is website is under construction? I don't know what was exact reason that I won't create deposit address. On the other hand you should add more info on your website l, its looking like a blank page. Also you should be more creative to create ANN thread, just buy copper membership and you will able to create good design. It's also most important to attract gamblers. Even check deposit also just loading...........
Are you serious with this kind of design?Next, how can i trust you up with my funds?
Next, how can we verify if the other players arent part of the house?
Next, how to verify to those who won?
Jump to: