Pages:
Author

Topic: Getting Wikipedia to accept Bitcoin donations - Community pledge - page 2. (Read 19110 times)

edd
donator
Activity: 1414
Merit: 1002
So I've tested out the system. They're using Coinbase for processing which has these implications:

1. There is no public Bitcoin address associated with Wikipedia.
2. The amount donated is denominated in USD (thus I cannot specify the exact amount of the pledge).
3. There isn't that much by way of confirmation of the donation - all I get is a Coinbase receipt like https://coinbase.com/orders/c2e107a91057283dcebf7708255650c3/receipt.

Per the rules of the titular pledge, I am now to forward the 8.0728757 pledged bitcoins to Wikipedia. But given the above it's not clear to me how to do that in a way that proves that I have.

I welcome suggestions for the best way to do it.

(PS I believe there was little to no affect of this pledge on their decision, but the money is going to a good cause anyway).

Linking to the receipt provided by Coinbase and the transaction on Blockchain.info would be adequate in my opinion. This would verify that the bitcoins were sent when they were worth the amount in USD as stated on the Coinbase receipt. While this may not specifically prove that the bitcoins came from you, it would be unlikely that you waited to send the 8.0728757 BTC until someone else happened to send that exact amount and were able to access their online receipt.

Disclosure: I don't recall sending a donation to this so I have no stake in the outcome.
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
So I've tested out the system. They're using Coinbase for processing which has these implications:

1. There is no public Bitcoin address associated with Wikipedia.
2. The amount donated is denominated in USD (thus I cannot specify the exact amount of the pledge).
3. There isn't that much by way of confirmation of the donation - all I get is a Coinbase receipt like https://coinbase.com/orders/c2e107a91057283dcebf7708255650c3/receipt.

Per the rules of the titular pledge, I am now to forward the 8.0728757 pledged bitcoins to Wikipedia. But given the above it's not clear to me how to do that in a way that proves that I have.

I welcome suggestions for the best way to do it.

(PS I believe there was little to no effect of this pledge on their decision, but the money is going to a good cause anyway).
WiW
sr. member
Activity: 277
Merit: 250
"The public is stupid, hence the public will pay"
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
Wikipedia has now announced that they are accepting Bitcoin. Stay tuned.

(PS these are amazing news).
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
but I hope we'll be very soon able to donate it to them.

Why not send to JW right now? He said he is forwarding to WM. 

I think this is the way to go. --- no?
Tempting, but Wikimedia needs to officially accept Bitcoin donations. Despite Jimmy's position in Wikimedia, in this offer he is acting as a private individual agreeing to donate sent funds to Wikimedia, not much unlike Bitpay's old drive.
member
Activity: 91
Merit: 10
I too agree that this is a good opportunity. As he is trying bitcoin out, this could show him just how much support is out there.
full member
Activity: 226
Merit: 100
but I hope we'll be very soon able to donate it to them.

Why not send to JW right now? He said he is forwarding to WM. 

I think this is the way to go. --- no?

donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
That's very cool. The thread's subject pledge is too small to bother them with its existence, but I hope we'll be very soon able to donate it to them.

(I never did get around to starting the dialogue with them as originally planned... And of course, by now Bitcoin is popular enough that I'm not really needed for this).
donator
Activity: 674
Merit: 523
Interesting...

Maybe 8btc waiting at 19HHHDya8PNqdVpiCdZYuwKyuWFoU1TC9A soften them a bit : )

Joke aside: it is about freaking time for anyone to start "Playing with BTC"!
full member
Activity: 226
Merit: 100
The outgoing Wikimedia chairman is my partner for the last decade, and I have a long personal involvement in Wikimedia.  In light of my experience, I have to say that I'm amused by this thread......

Why Your Alt-Coin Is No Good Here ....
http://letstalkbitcoin.com/why-your-alt-coin-is-no-good-here/
member
Activity: 77
Merit: 10
Donated. Maybe we just need to wait for Bitcoin to be worth over $10,000.

You just don't reject a $100,000 donation from a fan community, do you? :-)

I currently have a monthly subscription with Wikipedia and I'd much rather donate once a year in Bitcoin.
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
Bumping because I want to donate to Wikipedia.
FWIW, I haven't forgotten about this. My plan is still to contact them when I'm available. If others wish to contact them as well there's no problem; I do however feel that we're at a point where directly approaching them is less needed.
WiW
sr. member
Activity: 277
Merit: 250
"The public is stupid, hence the public will pay"
Bumping because I want to donate to Wikipedia.
legendary
Activity: 1358
Merit: 1003
Ron Gross
FYI, Mastercoin's Bounties feature will include a decenrtalized version of this thread.
Thanks Meni for the inspiration!

https://trello.com/c/KcZ6FfSu/26-spec-for-bounties

Everyone, if you want to learn more, please start with the FAQ.
donator
Activity: 2058
Merit: 1054
Great iniciative, just gave my 0.5 tip to 19HHHDya8PNqdVpiCdZYuwKyuWFoU1TC9A i hope it works.
Hi Meni! What´s gonna happen with the money donated? If it is not going to reach Wikipedia it should reach our pockets back..
Did you read the OP?

It's going to be donated to Wikipedia. Eventually. Until then the rules clearly state the funds will not be returned to donators.
full member
Activity: 180
Merit: 100
Great iniciative, just gave my 0.5 tip to 19HHHDya8PNqdVpiCdZYuwKyuWFoU1TC9A i hope it works.

Hi Meni! What´s gonna happen with the money donated? If it is not going to reach Wikipedia it should reach our pockets back..
sr. member
Activity: 1078
Merit: 254
just found this post. last week after wikipedia asking me for a donation via pop up, i sent them an email similar to what meni is proposing, so far no response:(
newbie
Activity: 52
Merit: 0
As for picking fruit... Wikipedia is no Rosa Parks; it lacks both the Power of Strong Ties & the Power of Weak Ties in my opinion.

To learn more about this concept of Strong Ties & Weak Ties, which was outlined in The Power of Habit by I found this video: http://youtu.be/u8B6_e8SnRs
Pages:
Jump to: