WTF, drop it in water?
How about making multiple copies of it, perhaps writing it down on a laminated paper with a market to be water proof.
If you keep it on a small note paper somewhere in the house then of course it gets messed up.
I agree when you make the paper wallet you should not make 1 print only of it. It would be crazy if you did to have it in a area with water around it. When you store safely you would be smart to have at least a copy always stored away.
I do like hardware wallets more and more. Also 2nd factor devices. I see these becoming more and more popular in future. Which is likely a very good thing.