The way to spend specific UTXOs has been changed in new versions of electrum (4.0.x).
To do so, go to "Coins" tab, select UTXOs you want to spend, right-click and select "Spend". After that, go to "Send" tab and make the transaction. Electrum will spend only selected UTXOs.
You can also use "shift" and "control" buttons to select multiple UTXOs.
Note that if you have selected any UTXO, you see "Coin control active" message at bottom of the window.