I guess that's the price you have to pay in order to enjoy true anonymity. I don't mind about higher costs compared to using a centralized exchange, as long as I'm able to get BTC without bringing unwanted attention (not that I'm doing anything illegal by the way). In times of increasing government surveillance, we'd need to remain under the radar in order to help protect our freedom. Bitcoin was created as a means to escape the system, so it's best to do everything in the most "Peer-to-Peer" manner possible. Bisq, Hodlhodl, and Localcryptos are all we need to exchange Bitcoin in a truly anonymous way.
I'll be locking this thread as I've already found the answer to my question. Thanks, everyone!