Pages:
Author

Topic: How exchanges treat the stolen Money? - page 3. (Read 771 times)

member
Activity: 394
Merit: 14
November 25, 2019, 07:39:51 AM
#33
For sure stolen funds normally goes in and out of Binance however no exchanges can detect whether those funds are stolen, but they can only flag stolen funds that are huge with questionable source but for smaller funds consider no chance.
I think if the one who stole the funds will see that they are transferred to the exchange, it is still possible to write to the support service of the exchange and at least freeze the withdrawal of funds.(I have no exact information, it's just my guesses)
sr. member
Activity: 868
Merit: 333
November 25, 2019, 07:36:41 AM
#32
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
As long as you have strong evidence I think they will be responsible for the report you make.
But if you say an opinion, I think they clearly won't want to respond to your report because hacking is hard to find proof of because of internal factors.
I think even if you have strong evidence, they will need to investigate further and ask for more detailed information to determine that the funds are really hacked or stolen.

Yes, it will be another thing that they might not respond to the report since it will be hard for them to know and will gather proof that the report is legit and not a fraud.
sr. member
Activity: 1918
Merit: 268
20BET - Premium Casino & Sportsbook
November 25, 2019, 07:33:58 AM
#31
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
I think it's true of some people who say here, because we don't have solid evidence to show it is your money, whereas they are stealing your funds and even though you also know what exchanges they use to sell your bitcoin, it will be in vain if we complain let alone report the owner of the exchange, because they maintain the convenience of their users and it is impossible to do let alone freeze their users' money, that way will worsen the name of the exchange, if it is a false accusation
hero member
Activity: 2520
Merit: 783
November 25, 2019, 07:28:15 AM
#30
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
if you have some evidence maybe the exchange will freeze the user account
usually exchange just freeze the account of the suspect to stop them from using their platform
but I'm not sure if they will give back the funds to the owner


For many years of staying on crypto space I don't see any exchange who freeze the account of possible attacker repays the affected users and I don't actually know what will happen since it's still a mystery on where does the money goes if certain case will happen. But actually know the hackers got fast hands and they will be detected late and already withdraw huge amount and provably if they are left maybe a little percentage only which cannot cater all the user who's funds are stolen.
sr. member
Activity: 962
Merit: 269
CryptoDirectories.com
November 25, 2019, 07:24:34 AM
#29
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
if you have some evidence maybe the exchange will freeze the user account
usually exchange just freeze the account of the suspect to stop them from using their platform
but I'm not sure if they will give back the funds to the owner
hero member
Activity: 1302
Merit: 577
avatar and signature space for rent !!!
November 25, 2019, 07:19:28 AM
#28
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
As long as you have strong evidence I think they will be responsible for the report you make.
But if you say an opinion, I think they clearly won't want to respond to your report because hacking is hard to find proof of because of internal factors.
And the procedure is takes that long before you can give all the requirements needed the hackker move the funds already in another wallet and you will not know where wallet it is only exchange knows the details of that transaction. But hacker will do anything to make it hard for them to be tracked so he will use different exchange to make it more successful to havr clean BTC.
member
Activity: 476
Merit: 88
Online Cryptocurrency Exchange
November 25, 2019, 07:13:21 AM
#27
There had been some cases already, where stolen funds got frozen by exchanges. As well, with FATF recommendations coming into force, there will be a requirement to verify both sending and receiving parties. This aims to exclude stolen funds from being used. This will have some side effects, like removal of privacy coins from the list of available coins/tokens.
sr. member
Activity: 617
Merit: 253
CryptoTalk.Org - Get Paid for every Post!
November 25, 2019, 07:08:00 AM
#26
If a hacker is smart enough to hack your wallets and steal your funds, don't you think they would be smart enough to liquidate that find without being caught? They would probably just deposit the funds in an exchange and withdraw it almost immediately, making it untraceable before the exchange would even have the chance to know about it, anybody can open an exchange account, infact a single person can open hundreds of accounts and operate them from the same device.
Ofcourse. Hackers are not definately dumb. They will definately have an exit plan. Infact they will plan it before the hack. If the huge amount of money is being transferred anonymously then it is really risky for any hacker to liquidate. As you can see many exchanges and ICO hacked stolen funds are still not completely withdrawn.
sr. member
Activity: 868
Merit: 267
SecureShift.io | Crypto-Exchange
November 25, 2019, 06:58:49 AM
#25
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
As long as you have strong evidence I think they will be responsible for the report you make.
But if you say an opinion, I think they clearly won't want to respond to your report because hacking is hard to find proof of because of internal factors.
sr. member
Activity: 1330
Merit: 291
November 25, 2019, 06:49:24 AM
#24
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
I don't think it is there responsibility to help you track your stolen funds because there are so many factors that need to be taken into consideration. Things like how would the exchange be sure that you are the original owner of the said funds been transferred to there exchange because your own identity is not known to the exchange and that will make it difficult for the exchange company to help you recover your said funds.
sr. member
Activity: 644
Merit: 257
Worldwide Payments Accepted in Seconds!
November 25, 2019, 06:33:17 AM
#23
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?
If your money is hacked and then deposited into an exchange of course the exchange will not be held responsible because it is not their fault but your own fault

If the money was hacked on the exchange and the incident happened on the exchange internal system then I think they are held responsible for this. The exchange can't refund if youre hacked into youre own fault but if the exchange is proven to be he one hacked including money of the trader then I think they should replace the loss money.
sr. member
Activity: 2240
Merit: 270
SOL.BIOKRIPT.COM
November 25, 2019, 06:23:46 AM
#22
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?

What proof do you have in terms of actually proving that the funds involved are the exact funds that you got hacked for?

It's all 'he she, she said'. Unless you have rock solid proof I think it's unreasonable to assume that exchanges will freeze someone's account in particular just because someone complained that he/she may be the hacker/scammer behind a fraud.

Of course, you could try, but I doubt the outcome will be positive.

In some cases of a theft or unwise hack, for example 7m tokens worth millions of dollars is stolen from a project developer Wallet might be transfered to Binance to be sold immediately, if Binance got wind of the information, the either suspend deposits or freeze deposits. In most cases the indices can easily be calculated in huge volume transactions but them cryptocurrency decentralisation makes it uneasy most times
This deserves more concern than the hack from an unknown Identity. Scams need to prosecuted at all cost. When they are not contolled people could take law into their hands. Imagine an ICO scammer from my investment walking on my street and I saw him. He wont leave unhurt. Exchanges are incapacitated in a way, they dont monitors transfer to know which comes from a hack or scam but I think at a point where such transaction is noticed exchange involved can be notified.but things had changed, some exchanges even benefits from the scam.
sr. member
Activity: 784
Merit: 251
November 25, 2019, 06:20:07 AM
#21
It cannot be ascertained, depending on the exchange and the amount of funds stolen. if something like that happens, it might be purely a user error, because the exchange has strong security. The exchange cannot confirm or detect whether the withdrawal is from you, but as far as I know, an exchange that has more security uses 2FA code, so it is impossible to hack, unless your email and mobile number have been taken over by the hacker. maybe if you lose a large enough fund, most likely it can be returned or you are assisted by the exchange.
hero member
Activity: 966
Merit: 502
November 25, 2019, 06:06:25 AM
#20
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?

What proof do you have in terms of actually proving that the funds involved are the exact funds that you got hacked for?

It's all 'he she, she said'. Unless you have rock solid proof I think it's unreasonable to assume that exchanges will freeze someone's account in particular just because someone complained that he/she may be the hacker/scammer behind a fraud.

Of course, you could try, but I doubt the outcome will be positive.

In some cases of a theft or unwise hack, for example 7m tokens worth millions of dollars is stolen from a project developer Wallet might be transfered to Binance to be sold immediately, if Binance got wind of the information, the either suspend deposits or freeze deposits. In most cases the indices can easily be calculated in huge volume transactions but them cryptocurrency decentralisation makes it uneasy most times
hero member
Activity: 2870
Merit: 594
November 25, 2019, 05:45:51 AM
#19
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?

Sad to say that exchanges will not act on any 'supposedly' stolen money. I mean how can you give them proof that it was stolen in the first place? Sad to say that they won't act on it.

And just imagine if everyone will complain about it, then how will exchange treat the case. I guess this is one drawback of this market, it's free and open, just saying.
TGD
hero member
Activity: 1288
Merit: 620
Wen Rolex?
November 25, 2019, 05:41:15 AM
#18
I am curious to know, how Exchanges treat the stolen money or hack money? Are they really aware of it? Just think, your fund has been hacked and transferred from your wallet to another wallet and then it's deposited to an exchange. If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?

Most of the hacker used Bitcoin Mixer Services to loss track of the hack BTC or other cryptocurrency. They are smart enough to do that and I believe this is basic from them. So exchange will never determine if BTC came
from hackers or not and also hackers usually sold there BTC over the counter or in deepweb. They will never sell there hack BTC to a place that might gonna exposed there privacy itself.
sr. member
Activity: 2338
Merit: 273
DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook
November 25, 2019, 05:36:59 AM
#17
if there are errors from users about some level of exchange security that is not being used, then they will not do anything, this is already included in the terms and conditions. However, if the hacks occur on the core exchange system, so far they have carried out a backup and maintenance process between hot and cold wallets, they ensure that user funds are not reduced at all with a fast refund program.
copper member
Activity: 2324
Merit: 2142
Slots Enthusiast & Expert
November 25, 2019, 05:22:36 AM
#16
If the thief is stupid enough not to use tumbler services, the exchange could freeze the account (with its balance). Moreover, exchanges usually have an alert system and mechanism to wait for some more confirmation for withdrawal. It gives them a sufficient window (time) to make sure no problem for the withdrawal, as mentioned earlier.

But usually, the stolen fund will first "washed" through tumbler services, or dealt over the counter (OTC). So "mainstream" exchanges could not do anything except standard KYC/AML practice.
hero member
Activity: 924
Merit: 520
November 25, 2019, 05:08:13 AM
#15
If you claim to the exchange about the money, Are they not responsible for taking necessary action? What do you think?

Most probably exchanges will not do any action even if you claim that the assets are yours because if they do so, this policy would be subjected to abuse.

Imagine a regular user depositing 10BTC to Binance and a malicious person could very well froze that assets if he claims he's the original owner of it and it was stolen! This scenario won't be good for an exchange business because no one will ever use it if he knows his funds could be frozen anytime by just a simple claim of ownership from somebody else.

In the first place, its our duty to safeguard our funds so that we will not face such issues - trying to recover lost funds within an exchange which I think would be futile.

Though I guess, this will not be always the case and that if you could produce a court order to freeze that account's assets, then I think that exchange would heed to that order but it would still be subjected for litigation and could be contested which could also be a long and tedious process. Imho.
sr. member
Activity: 567
Merit: 270
November 25, 2019, 03:22:35 AM
#14
If a hacker is smart enough to hack your wallets and steal your funds, don't you think they would be smart enough to liquidate that find without being caught? They would probably just deposit the funds in an exchange and withdraw it almost immediately, making it untraceable before the exchange would even have the chance to know about it, anybody can open an exchange account, infact a single person can open hundreds of accounts and operate them from the same device.
Pages:
Jump to: