Topic: How scary could the US SEC ban crypto staking be a sight? (Read 249 times)

You are right. If you keep your coins on exchanges, you are still a bit safe because a bad rumour could make you withdraw your coins before something bad happen to the exchange.
But staking your coins with take some days to cool down in most Exchanges and this is riskier than keeping coins there.

We cannot deny that the SEC's connection with the crypto world is really influential. Even though we sometimes understand that the SEC does things like this and destroys the crypto world, it seems like this will never end. The SEC will continue to look for loopholes to create another FUD like this. It becomes one of the controllers. I think this news will certainly affect the crypto market and there will be a possibility for the market to drop because of this FUD. However, we seem to be more prepared if the FUD comes from the SEC. Maybe the results won't be as bad as when they were with XRP back then. What's more, it seems that the SEC often does this and eventually returns to normal again.

There’s a lot of crypto investors losses their money because of staking, so this rumor might have a good reason as well since SEC is not against crypto at all, probably its against to their policy which they think is not good. If this is going to happen, DEX will be a better option to many and I think liquidity will not be affected that much as we have many options already and this is just a US SEC which I believe doesn’t represent the every country.

Yeah right, it's been ages since bitcoin and other crypto is existing. Fud like this is not new, only those people who just met crypto through some influencers in Twitter and some other places are the target of this Fud, but those who knew crypto so well will not believe in this. Maybe yes, I can't deny the fact that it causes the coin to some dump or dip but it always happen, and after days or weeks it will recover.

I agree.  Kraken has almost no move to show that they are providing services in the right direction.  And easily handcuffed.  Look at coinbase - Paul Grewal, they make claims and evidence that their staking products are not securities in disguise to refute the SEC's allegation.  https://twitter.com/iampaulgrewal/status/1624173847888171008?s=46&t=r0atquMLEL2jVhZvoq-0qA

I think there is reason to believe that Lido, Rocket pool, FXS are accurately reflecting user adoption as short-term rally values ​​gain momentum.  I believe that if the SEC continues this FUD-like crackdown, betting on decentralized exchanges represents the direction of the next market.

A crypto ban in America? This is FUD, this will not happen, there is too much money involved in the industry. Accordingly, there are interests of people with a lot of capital and opportunity in this industry, there will be no ban. After a wave of speculation, this theme will subside and no one will remember about it. About the ban of cryptocurrency in various large countries they talk all the time, even in China this ban did not take place completely. So who will ban something that can be used to make money or even to launder money. The FTX case showed perfectly that even big politicians were involved in cryptocurrency.

It should not have an effect on bitcoin but retail investors do not care, they see more regulation and immediately assume all the market is going to be affected, which then turns into a reality as they sell their coins and then this strengthens the idea that this is the case, this explains why bitcoin is going down again, but smart investors will immediately realize the mistake those people are committing and take advantage of the cheap price at which bitcoin is trading right now.

I think Kraken got scared and did everything that the SEC told them to, even though this decision of banning their staking services was completely arbitrary and should not have been made so rashly. Kraken should have held up its own in court against the SEC's decision. All this panic about staking is premature.

If anything this only shows me how weak willed Kraken actually is and how easy it is to scare and manipulate centralized service providers into doing what the government wants, even if there is no legislation or legality behind it.

Just another example of why nobody should trust centralized exchanges.

There are consequences if SEC pursues this because surely they are stifling the industry and as a result developers are going to move out of US and the harder for thier regulators to actually reach these developers. The taxes that supposedly go to the US government may go to some other country instead.

Not your key, not your coins indeed as users are also pushed out of the CEX and they'd be staking on thier personal wallet.

Staking coins on an exchange is just like keeping coins there and when bad things happen the staker will lose everything and the exchange will easily give reasons for being hacked. So this move by SEC is not a scary thing, in fact it should be supported because this regulation is like supporting a campaign that is always echoed by crypto lovers, not your key, not your coin.

I don't see how stopping staking will affect bitcoin!!!!
First, Bitcoin has nothing to do with Proof of Stake and it has nothing to do with Altcoin, so I don't see how it is affected by this ban.
Secondly, even if these rumors are true, they are still only fears, and then they are only in the United States, and companies that wish to pursue staking can operate in any country other than the United States that does not prohibit staking.
In the end, I see no reason for Bitcoin to fall as a result of this news.

Altcoins are weak by their designs that can be easily used for scam as well as very vulnerable to hacks, attacks and regulatory attempts.

Altcoin developers can create their coins from thin air, by pre-mine their coins, pre-mint their tokens and can mint more tokens if they want. Staking is one of most attractive features from altcoins but it is like a favorite feature for Ponzi scheme. Early investors, early stakers will get real high APYs but late comers will be burden by risk of price falls, collapses and they mostly won't get actual high APY at the end for their investment. It is kind of lie from altcoin developers to altcoin investors.

If anything can be done to stop this, I think it is good and I support this regulation too.

Bitcoin is strong by its design. Nobody can be able to create more Bitcoin than 21M and if you want to have it, mine it with mining ASICs or from exchanges. No passive income by staking Bitcoin like altcoins. Less inflation and no impermanent loss risk for investors.

It should be, knowing that Bitcoin is PoW; but negative news concerning regulations negatively affects prices for the entire industry overall. Regulations will almost always scare the crap out of retail "investors".

Praise the Lord and Hallelujah! Its about time they start to crack down hard on all these stupid crap coins.

Ethereum is total centralized garbage, and became even much more centralized after moving from PoW to PoS.

Its only scary to people propagating lies. For example Cardano. Cardano is one of the most centralized projects ever and they claim not to be all the time. I even detailed a little document of evidence about it for fun:
Evidence 1: Around 16% of ADA coins in circulation were given to the project’s founders, who could remain among the biggest Cardano whales today. The remaining 84% was allocated to other investors.
[capital.com/cardano-who-owns-most-ada-whales-control ]
As you can read here a substantial portion of the supply was initially distributed to insiders of the project, there is no need for me to explain that this is not decentralized.
Evidence 2: 75% of the validator set is made up by only 25 staking pools. as opposed to bitcoin or ergo where the nodes enforce SOFT FORK updates, these 25 validators control what is and is not the proof of stake chain cardano thereby putting all other users at risk of malicious updates by the economic minority.
[https://cardanoscan.io/pools ]
Evidence 3: IOHK making posts claiming to be 100% decentralized (context: the founder of cardano claiming that Cardano is decentralized, like satoshi nakomoto sticking around for 20 years putting his name on everything bitcoin selling tons of bitcoin and claiming it is decentralized) [https://heraldsheets.com/cardano-ada-is-now-100-decentralized/ ] Not even Ethereum lies to their own users this much, propaganda leads to DELUSION. so I highly recommend you STOP propagating the narrative that Cardano is decentralized or unfortunately Ergo will just suffer continuously in its VC funded shadow.

Pretty much every other proof of stake protocol works in this way or in even more disturbingly centralized and Potemkin village type ways. Down with the shitcoins. On the other hand the regulators will regulate bitcoin too if they are to be trusted with more power. For that reason I am willing to side with shitcoins, simply because the government has not proved that they will respect bitcoin (USERS) in any way.

It’s only in the US as far as I am able to see so far. As usual we will see panic sellers reacting but it shouldn’t really do much to bitcoin in the medium to long term. Staking is a scam any way, YOU are the yield. Just another load of panic dumping across the entire crypto space. We’ve seen much worse before & we will again. Nothing to see here, move on.

Yes, it is true that if the rumors of a ban on staking in the US by the SEC materialize, it could have a significant impact on the crypto market. If the staking ban.
A ban on staking could result in a decrease in liquidity, which could lead to a drop in the overall crypto market capitalization. This in turn could lead to increased volatility and a decrease in the value of cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin. However, it is important to note that these are just rumors and speculations at this point, and it is difficult to predict the exact impact that a ban on staking would have on the crypto market. It is always important to do your own research and consult with a financial advisor before making any investment decisions.

Kraken has just agreed to shutdown their staking services in a deal with the SEC.


That's insane. But it confirms the SEC is looking to bar US citizens from staking through exchanges.

Looks like in the future US citizens will just have to stake themselves directly on protocols rather than use the convenience of third party stakers like exchanges.

I think this will hurt Ethereum a lot. Because ETH has much harder staking (forces you to have 32 ETH and you basically have to run a staking node, whereas lots of other coins you just stake through a validator and only the validators have to run a staking node) that means that most people in the US would have to stop staking ETH, while they could continue staking other PoS coins. If indeed the SEC does eventually ban 3rd party staking services which it certainly looks like they are planning after making Kraken shut down their staking.


This is the sort of just blind bad regulation the industry doesn't need. We need exchanges transparent and held accountable, insurance for people's exchange holdings, and attempts to stop scams and illegal activity. What we DON'T need is just randomly banning crypto services just because the head of the SEC is on an anti-crypto power trip.

fixed that for you
right now users are STUCK with the coins being locked
yes they can 'aftermarket' sell ownership rights of their stake but that stake is still locked(whomever owns it cant remove it) untill the upgrades

what you will find out is that
ethereum sat at $1.5k when PoW due to there being a underlying "non zero" bottom cost (mining) of ~$900 meaning the price was speculating at a 1.6x premium just before Pos detonation/merge

however due to locks and crossborder arbitrage. that market price stayed speculative high. (check the market wiggle.. Eth does not have its own dependant price discovery of random wiggles that are independent.. they are instead ghosting btc wiggles due to arbitrage at a 1:14 rate difference but majority of the time btc ups cause eth ups and btc downs cause eth downs.. tracing btc and not being independant)
but the underlying non zero bottom value did drop last year. it dropped by 95% due to the Pos change from Pow costs
now it sits way below $40 wholesale cost to acquire eth

so with alot of stakers making HUGE profits of the $40-$1.5k spread of value:premium speculation means that the 2023 eth price of $1.6k is a speculative bubble high now of a 40x speculative gap.. instead of last springs 1.6x

so when they get the chance to remove stake and then spot market sell the coins they accumulated in the last year. expect a mass sell off.

in short. the stake lock caused a log delay in the PoS value:price CORRECTION
.. but it will happen

The last time Brain Armstrong tweeted about a rumor turned out to be true so this could also be true. Before this rumored crypt staking ban comes out there is already a continuous crackdown against the industry the latest being Binance suspending USD bank transfers.

What I have read was this is very timely since a month from now, ETH Shanghai update will be launched and more users can stake ETH. Articles today are published about this being a coordinated attack on ETH.

It should only affect ETH or other staking tokens but the BTC dropped today though which I guess could be one of the effects.