How to analyze an ICO project going to be scam or not?

Wind_FURY

legendary

Activity: 2898

Merit: 1823

Quote from: rizkyhiw on February 08, 2017, 12:30:21 AM

Quote from: Wind_FURY on February 07, 2017, 11:12:49 PM

They are all scams. Why do they need to attach a new coin with no use in their platforms? Why not use Bitcoin from the start? The result is still the same. The people who invest in them still dump those coins in an exchange and hold Bitcoin including the founders.

Not all , you cannot say or justifying like that pal
As long as it provide a reasonable profit percentage and run under reliable forum member
I think there is a lot of chance for an ICO become a seripus and legitimate project
You just need to do your own research and make a decision on it!

Ok then prove your point. Please post an ICO project that does not have a ponzi scheme in it. Which ICO do you think can "become a serious and legitimate project" for you?

For your final sentence, since you have done your due diligence and researched on them, tell us what the best ICO project there is and why it is not a scam. I hope you will say it is Ethereum.

MarMoCoin

member

Activity: 112

Merit: 10

Market Mover

Apply some common sense and know what you are trying to achieve.

Use your brain and learn to filter what you read.

wavespump

hero member

Activity: 728

Merit: 500

It is a meaningful question, I have my own conditions:

1. dev team should be famous, or at least they publish their real identities. Anonymous team can be OK, but be cautious to invest.
2. always choose ICO with escrow, read the terms, otherwise Ascendancy scam cheated escrows with 75 btc fund will be repeated.
3. project is innovative, for example, waves, stratis, purevidz and so forth.
4. not overvalued ICO will be profitable, you see stratis is 8X of ICO price, purevidz is 7X.

dihari

hero member

Activity: 910

Merit: 525

Quote from: dwgscale11 on February 08, 2017, 03:52:37 PM

Quote from: dihari on February 07, 2017, 10:49:30 PM

As we know, new coins is born almost every week. ICO is inviting peoples to invest on their project with the promise of big return.
But we have seen many of them disappeared without a trace after hold fund from investors. This make a decrease in the level of trust to invest on new project from new developer.
How do we know if some project is going to be scam? What factors make it different with "good future" project?

Easy. Dont buy scammy ICO premines... Keep bitcoin and litecoin..

Everything else, STAY AWAY LIKE THE PLAGUE!! (eth, ripple, dash, whatever other crap is out there)

Monero & Etc I dont know whether they are scams yet.

If we're not support new coins there will be no development on this crypto currency technology. They come with new work programs and interesting plan work.
It's good for bitcoin to have comparator. It's good on the outside they are scamming or not.

dwgscale11

sr. member

Activity: 335

Merit: 250

Quote from: dihari on February 07, 2017, 10:49:30 PM

As we know, new coins is born almost every week. ICO is inviting peoples to invest on their project with the promise of big return.
But we have seen many of them disappeared without a trace after hold fund from investors. This make a decrease in the level of trust to invest on new project from new developer.
How do we know if some project is going to be scam? What factors make it different with "good future" project?

Easy. Dont buy scammy ICO premines... Keep bitcoin and litecoin..

Everything else, STAY AWAY LIKE THE PLAGUE!! (eth, ripple, dash, whatever other crap is out there)

Monero & Etc I dont know whether they are scams yet.

vincentvincent

sr. member

Activity: 285

Merit: 251

I would ask Spoetnik for advice

harizen

legendary

Activity: 3122

Merit: 1398

For support ➡️ help.bc.game

Quote from: dihari on February 07, 2017, 10:49:30 PM

As we know, new coins is born almost every week. ICO is inviting peoples to invest on their project with the promise of big return.
But we have seen many of them disappeared without a trace after hold fund from investors. This make a decrease in the level of trust to invest on new project from new developer.
How do we know if some project is going to be scam? What factors make it different with "good future" project?

Unresponsive and staying away from those hard questions by the devs is one of the best basis. In most of the cases, there are questions being unanswered even lots of bumps have been done to that question. We can see that in some of the ICO threads.

If a certain ICO have a goal of being a fraud one, we cannot see that honestly since for investors to make such thing as investment in that ICO, all ICO related thing including website design must be properly and professionally made. So a formal site and introduction is a must for ICO devs so that investors will think that they are quiet serious even for an outside look.

That's how risky investing in an ICO is.

fikihafana

sr. member

Activity: 462

Merit: 250

Quote from: Slark on February 07, 2017, 11:05:56 PM

I will tell you the truth. If the scam is good enough you won't be able to spot it that easily. There are however some clear indicators that we are dealing with fraudulent developers:

1. Unrealistic or hyper optimistic goals.
2. Stolen, copied whitepaper or paper without technical details.
3. No transparency, no real names behind the coin, no social media accounts, or fake LinkedIn profiles.
4. Self Moderated thread is usually slightly suspicious too, but that is rather minor fact, might be a way to deter idiots and trolls.
5. No real purpose, or project overly similar to already existing ones.

6. do not trust "SOON" words, if dev say it too much
7. Dev not answer many critical question
8. Dev delete some post without reason

royalfestus

hero member

Activity: 2464

Merit: 519

Quote from: Golftech on February 08, 2017, 04:02:54 AM

Quote from: shield132 on February 08, 2017, 03:58:00 AM

Well, unique logo, design and etc means something good but if we look, nowdays many hypes are doing this to blind people. To my mind it's better to check who are behind the project, how was their past and how seriously are they working on their project because there is less risk if group of developers are experienced people, also active staff is very good. You can't 100% analyze if ICO project is going to scam but these will help you.

well it should be checked before placing any investment, as we knew its always hard to say whether project will be a good one or will turned into scam, and that's the advantage of this forum you will be able to justify alts with the opinion of more experienced members and as time goes a long its always the developers reputations will take place if he is for real or he just wanted to collect funds and skip away.

I found this to be the most reliable information to avoid scam, most of the suggestion are what is well understood by scammers that they can go about it and still scam. Track record of some reliable project managers can keep one at rest. A lot of them had left traces everywhere that make it hard for them to run.

Grdas130979

member

Activity: 84

Merit: 10

The truth is out there

Usually a good ico will attract interest from a lot of people who know what to look for, so go after that projects for a start

instacalm

hero member

Activity: 798

Merit: 500

Quote from: dihari on February 07, 2017, 10:49:30 PM

As we know, new coins is born almost every week. ICO is inviting peoples to invest on their project with the promise of big return.
But we have seen many of them disappeared without a trace after hold fund from investors. This make a decrease in the level of trust to invest on new project from new developer.
How do we know if some project is going to be scam? What factors make it different with "good future" project?

There is no single good recipe as in a cookbook to identify altcoin/cryptocurrency/ICO scams. What you need is common sense and a healthy perception of the markets, as well as some inside knowledge of how the markets work and which people and forces are at play. Now all of this is dynamic and changes constantly, so you have to do your research and/or participate in the research and the stream of opinions that are openly shared in this forum.

dihari

hero member

Activity: 910

Merit: 525

Quote from: Slark on February 07, 2017, 11:05:56 PM

I will tell you the truth. If the scam is good enough you won't be able to spot it that easily. There are however some clear indicators that we are dealing with fraudulent developers:

1. Unrealistic or hyper optimistic goals.
2. Stolen, copied whitepaper or paper without technical details.
3. No transparency, no real names behind the coin, no social media accounts, or fake LinkedIn profiles.
4. Self Moderated thread is usually slightly suspicious too, but that is rather minor fact, might be a way to deter idiots and trolls.
5. No real purpose, or project overly similar to already existing ones.

Good answer tips here. This can be use to analyze ICO and being indicator to trust to invest or not on some ICO.
I usually see they website design, logo design, and how attract they write their's work programs.

Dr.Osh

legendary

Activity: 2758

Merit: 1004

Buzz App - Spin wheel, farm rewards

well, the project may be stopped on the way, and his admin started to disappear. we can only know the project scam, when sites are no longer accessible, or his admin disappear. we can also predict failure or failure of a project of the goal.

articleheros

member

Activity: 83

Merit: 10

Thai translator and Blogger icoreview.com

I consider it as an innovation. What can change that Along with the view that digital development team medal. There is much more reliable.

and every answer is very nice and useful to me.

BTCLovingDude

legendary

Activity: 1134

Merit: 1010

BTC to the moon is inevitable...

your only chance is checking the project out yourself.
if you have an ICO project in mind then go find their announcement topic and start reading what the project is all about, if they had a website go there and check it out.
it is also preferred if you can check their source code if you can to see if it is just a copy paste or is there actually some work being done on it. you can see based on number of commits, contributions, and lots of other factors.
also check to see if the developers team is a good team or not.

and in the end it is an investment with its risks and rewards which you have to weigh against each other.

calkob

hero member

Activity: 1106

Merit: 521

In my opinion the best way to judge if it will be a scam or go nowhere is to look at the people running it, the devs. whats their past and have they got good reputation in crypto scene. Grin

iram3130

legendary

Activity: 1512

Merit: 1010

ITSMYNE 🚀 Talk NFTs, Trade NFTs 🚀

Quote from: Herbert2020 on February 08, 2017, 04:31:03 AM

there are two risks involved with ICOs and investing in them, one of them is the owners running away and disappearing after they get the funds. and the other once which most people forget is the fact that their projects are often failing, so it doesn't matter if they don't run away, the price of that altcoin because it failed will be lower than what you paid for ICO.

And 99% of the time the altcoin's value will get lower than what you have paid for.
I believe analyzing an ICO project is not that hard. If the technical details are valid and perfect then it is most likely to understand that it is good. Even most of the new projects won't be having a social media profiles, I dunno how they are gonna survive with that. Undecided

Herbert2020

legendary

Activity: 1946

Merit: 1137

there are two risks involved with ICOs and investing in them, one of them is the owners running away and disappearing after they get the funds. and the other once which most people forget is the fact that their projects are often failing, so it doesn't matter if they don't run away, the price of that altcoin because it failed will be lower than what you paid for ICO.

mkmdoc

sr. member

Activity: 658

Merit: 251

VIMee - Social Network

While you are choosing a coin with an ICO, you need to check whether the coin has an unique features from others and also you need to find whether coin has an innovative thought with stream line road map. You also need to consider the coin with development phase first and later ICO.

ivanst776

legendary

Activity: 1540

Merit: 1003

Quote from: dihari on February 07, 2017, 10:49:30 PM

As we know, new coins is born almost every week. ICO is inviting peoples to invest on their project with the promise of big return.
But we have seen many of them disappeared without a trace after hold fund from investors. This make a decrease in the level of trust to invest on new project from new developer.
How do we know if some project is going to be scam? What factors make it different with "good future" project?

You have to check if the ICO project has hired any escrow and not anyone but one of some popular escrows that are here in forum.

Even if it has escrow we should check if the money that is being invested there is moving to escrow address(es) and not like the ASC which turned into scam recently even though there were 3 escrows.

Topic: How to analyze an ICO project going to be scam or not? (Read 2228 times)