Topic: Hurray!!! Bitcoin defeated miscreants again (Read 244 times)

You just described what a phyric victory this is!

So it's not that much about the code or the people defeating ordinals, which still get minted even as we speak but a complete loss in demand for block space,  and think of the numbers that some claim, tes and hundred of millions of so-called "users" and without ordinals you don't have more than 120k in the last days willing to spend or transfer coins!

There was no battle, both sides just decided to return home!


Not going to happen, almost everyone is just waiting for a moment to sell at huge return, once the ordinal fomo truly goes down and not even 1sat/b ones are mined then you will see half empty blocks just like before February, the usage is simply not there, the p2p features has just been forgotten and the focus has shifted to investment.

It's a short term wave that will eventually die of with time, people were just thinking ordinals were the next place to get quick money as usual but were all disappointed how it didn't last upto a quarter of a year. I don't know why they decided to put such thing to bitcoin but the creativity is useless in my opinion, those domestic garbage ordinals are better off to ERC and other layers of blockchain because I see them as meme that are trying to corrupt bitcoin system.

Yeah, some days ago, I did a transaction in which I only spent $0.06 fee. It's really good how the transaction fee has dropped so drastically, and I am surprised that there have not been a lot of different topics regarding this issue from users, like the way almost everyone was complaining and creating different topics some months ago when the transaction fee of Bitcoin spike. Some people were even criticizing the Bitcoin transaction fee, as though it's going to stop people from transacting with Bitcoin. Even some so-called Bitcoiners, probably people who have not even invested in Bitcoin before complained. Now, I am not seeing so much appreciation for how low the fee has dropped. I can't tell how happy I am about this.

You are correct that bitcoin is not competing with any organisation because it is unique. However the clogging of the Mempool that increased the backlog of unconfirmed transactions was indeed a concern to the community. Marketing bitcoin to people became a problem because one of the cardinal benefits of using the currency is low transaction fees. Some people even started a media war targeted at undermining the adoption of the coin by telling the public that bank transaction charges are now cheaper.

This news is a positive one that will make awareness programs easier because the world needs alternatives that will be better than what conventional financial institutions offer. This is indeed a lesson not only to newbies but to bitcoiners who just experienced this event for the first time. There is always a need to avoid FUD and always follow your investment plans.

aaah well, yes that is correct, i agree with you, some other nodes without that limit will accept those TXs

It's too early to celebrate victory. Bitcoin faces many obstacles and difficulties ahead. In particular, problems with high commission prices will be advertised in the media more than once. Let's see what will happen with transaction fees and queues for confirmation of transactions in the next bitcoin / crypto-hype. Considering the minimum expected price for btc is $100.000, I am sure that commissions will again surprise us all with their extortionate rate.

Now for another moment. Everyone is waiting for bitcoin mass adoption and widespread distribution of the bitcoin, when they will pay for it left and right, when there will be a very big user base. What will the commission be? Is bitcoin ready for this kind of scaling? Add to this that btc is rising in price and that by then this will also directly affect the level of commissions. All this together will “pleasantly” surprise with the amount of transaction fees.

One more thing. Bitcoin is priced at $1.000.000, as predicted by some very enthusiastic bitcoiners Can you imagine how high the commissions will be at that moment?

The past events with the jump in the price of the transaction commission on the bitcoin network were a kind of crash test, which confirm my fears that btc is not quite ready for the high “influx” of users, demand, and level of transactions.

Hmmm
Even with the current low fees, some nodes reach the default memory limit, so transactions with less than < 1.56 sat/vB will be discarded. Therefore, I believe that most nodes will be able to broadcast transactions with 2 sat/vB, but will not be able to do it with 1 sat/vB. .


here you can find max limits https://github.com/bitcoin/bitcoin/blob/master/doc/reduce-memory.md

Isn't a mined block it is a expected block, those are still transaction on mempool waiting to be mined. you can see those on the mempool.space.
Can you see my images that i post?



That is not true... i can broadcast right now a Transaction with that fee and the nodes will accept it without problem... it is not going to be mined of course, becuase there are still transaction with higher fee on the mempool but the nodes MUST be accept it without problem.

This thread has been tracking fees prices since 2018 Fees are lower, use this opportunity to Consolidate your small inputs Use it when you want to Consolidate your small inputs.
Low fees are not considered a victory if there is no update or upgrade, but rather there are fewer transactions. If we all knew how to calculate fees correctly and stopped using wallets that were poorly programmed or had inaccurate price estimates, then the reduction in fees would be greater.

What block are you talking about, it has been a long time since nodes no longer accept broadcast transactions with a fee of 1 sat/vByte.

It has started since last weekend. If you use https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#BTC%20(default%20mempool),1w,weight to trace it, you will see that 2 sat/vbyte transactions has been confirming since Saturday on the 6th of October. Although, the fee rate is still getting high but consolidating and if able to wait for longer time, likely 2 sat/vbyte will be confirmed again and again.

Unfortunately it doesn't last long and the average fee increase to 6-9 sat/vbyte, it's strange the mempool emptied in weekday because it mostly happen in weekend.

But, you can minimize it by consolidating your inputs when the fee is cheap. As you're participated in signature campaign where you could earn Bitcoin every week, you must consolidate your inputs.

To say the truth, everyone was worried, the smart ones suspended every instant transaction until further notice, but I needed to make transactions back then so I ended paying up the transaction fee and man, it hurt so badly, because the amount I am moving into the exchange is not even much.

Days ago I was surprised to see Bitcoin transaction fee to be as low as it is, it's been a long time I've seen that type of low before but OP, I am not going to sit on this thinking it's going go always be the same, because right now it's not more $0.08$, I checked mempool this morning and it's going up again, now at $0.19 so that's that.

When the Bull market comes it's going to get more painful for Bitcoin, a high transaction fee will be one of the most discussed at the time, and even the Bitcoin Ordinals will nearly cripple Bitcoin, I believe this is going to be unavoidable, the real spamming hasn't even started yet, let's wait til the next bull market and see.

The network congestion was at the time of ordinals that pushed the fees higher and memepool full of unconfirmed transactions and it was sorted few days later only when fees came down to normal and high priority also not going too high.The prices are somewhat stable so not too much panic as well like people selling aggressively to cash out their returns but it can go up if we witness something like that again.

If this situation continues to be good, mempools will clear most of waiting transactions with 1 sat/vbyte fee rate after a long time. A last time mempools are clean like this is in late of April, 6 months ago.

After Ordinals, BRC20 tokens wave in early and mid of May, mempools have never cleaned up waiting transactions with fee rate at 1 sat/vbyte. The time is coming and I hope to see it in next weekend.

Mempool is looking good for now, but I wouldn't call it victory. It will get clogged again, fees will spike again. If more adoption will be coming, fees will be getting higher because the space is so limited. This current moment should be used to consolidate funds or make some transactions ahead of the time.

Not all transactions have the same weight, the ~26k transactions that remains are some big



if you see there are some prediction of the next blocks are going to have only a few dozens of transaction per block, this will slow down the remain transactions that are stuck on mempool.

The mempool is back up a little bit, but I trace in on https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#BTC%20(default%20mempool),24h,weight and noticed that you are very correct:

   

But I do not think Ordinals and BRC20 congesting transactions are over yet, there are still many of them. It is good to see blthe mempool as low as 2 sat/vbyte again.

Ordinals are something that could come back and bite bitcoin's immutability. Tokenization is in part what made Ethereum's blockchain bloated to a point that running a full node requires datacenter grade servers. Can't have decentralization with that. Ordinals also brought a lot of bloat into bitcoin's blockchain and mounted a lot of pressure on transaction costs and confirmation times too. Hopefully if they become popular again in the future their addition to the bitcoin blockchain will be reconsidered.

It is not like they don’t want to pay but one thing is even the transaction fee is less than a sat/vbyte the block has a size limit of 1,000,000 byte for non-segwit transactions and 4,000,000 weight for segwit transactions. This limit cannot be surpass by miners when including transactions into blocks so since they have been Chunks of unconfirmed transactions in the mempool it is logical that the number will only reduce gradually as the transaction fee is low now and if more transactions are broadcasted because many will use this opportunity to consolidate then Those transactions with extremely low fee will be dropped

I don't know if we're over the ordinals spam attack just yet, but obviously the mempool is not clogged right now or as it was a couple of months ago, one can make transactions again with a fee rate of 2-7 sat/vB. Anyway, like i said; i don't think the BRC-20 spam attack is over, but it has definitely reduced and as was predicted when it began: it'd continue in that way until it is completely over.