Topic: Idea - BTC trading platform with possibility to go short. (Read 1820 times)

Over 1.5k BTC available for short positions right now on Bitfinex...

...and also a LOT of USD for going long, though the bulls there again start their stampede and gobble up money like crazy.

Cool stuff Shorting is sweet sometimes

(12) I will soon bring it on a full report about my relationship with exxe and 1BTCroker. Stay tuned.    (12)

Well, it's even more precise than that: each time a trader want to open or increase a position, the system checks if there is enough lending offers to do that. If not, the order stays pending until there is. The traders see this little box below, indicating the maximum position they can open (with the average rate asked by lenders):


So when someone goes short, he selling real BTC provided by lenders, instead of hedging against someone going long. And the lender can't withdraw money used by traders, of course.

So you see, the leverage system has nothing to do with bitcoinica. Even if all long users sell their btc at once, Bitfinex stay balanced.


Yes, I agree, this is a big challenge. Thanks for the encouragement
Raphael

I am not too familiar with shorting etc. but I think it should also be possible for you to calculate daily (as you pay out daily instead of continuously) the total limit the platform has before becoming a bucket shop and you can update this value even with every transaction logged.

I am of course not in a position to try this out, but are you for example denying ridicuolously huge positions that are just too big for the platform, meaning are there uppler limits as well?

Anyways on topic: as you can see there was already a popular platform for shorting (Bitcoinica) - but it ended up in tears, lawsuits etc.
Now a lot of people still would like to do these kind of trades - BUT there is a lot of mistrust going on and it's also quite hard to on the one hand do security right (Bitfinex' idea of only watching incoming transactions but creating outgoing transactions only once a day on an offline computer is a very good idea for example), on the other hand due to it's nature these platforms also have to deal with fiat - and that's also something where a lot of regulations come into place (Bitfines seems to be/want to be registered in Hong Kong).

Anyways, all the best to Bitfinex or whoever ends up being the next Bitcoinica, but one small error and it can also end like the last Bitcoinica!

Hi Sukrim,

I understand your concerns. I was scammed by pirateat40 and am not proud of that, but that's what actually boost me to build something actually useful.

The article your refer to is a bit old, Bitfinex has evolved a lot since then. Contrary to bitcoinica, bitfinex has a clear business model and leverage system that is working on his own and doesn't allow the risk of becoming a bucket shop: lenders provide usd and btc to go respectively long and short, the positions are not hedged against one each other as with Bitcoinica.

The platform is now profitable, and I have more interests in keeping it running than running away with the money and risking legal charges. PLus the adventure that it represents is enough on its own.

Now I understand that this can be not enough when so many hack and scams happened in bitcoin world. I try to be as transparent as possible, but I guess only time will eventually prove me trustable. If you have any idea of how to prove the money is there you can use the thread provided by myself. A way to now there is at least some money on our mtgox is to compare our public trades page with mtgox public trade history

Raphael

Are you planning on building this?

then you should comment in this thread https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/bitfinexcom-transparency-to-much-to-little-where-is-the-equilibrium-131566

also you should check the loan market https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/usd-and-btc-neededpeople-are-ready-to-pay-high-to-trade-take-advantage-of-it-131573
currently the cheapest loan in USD is at 300% and that's far lower from rates from last week 1600% APY and sometime 9001% APY

The account exists, the guy is probably(?) real and he was indeed advocating for pirateat40 and trying to push a scheme with 2% interest per week, maybe to get funds for his platform. The last 2 parts are for me an indication that someone did NOT do their homework in an very obvious field (risk management).

Also as there is no way of seing how many BTC + USD are actually on the platform (at least I haven't seen anything) the danger of it secretly becoming a bucket shop is real in my opinion, all it takes are a few whales.

@Sukrim did you even bother to check if the information on that article is relevant ? and accurate ?

They should short USD towards BTC then to enter a world of joy?

Bitfinex sounds nice... but then again there are some concerns - most of them mentioned in http://bitcoinmagazine.com/bitfinex-bitcoinica-rises-from-the-grave/

It might be interesting to play the metagame though (listing a fund on an exchange site that deposits to bitfinex)

Anyone shorting BTC is simply opening themselves to a world of pain.  Have at it. 

Hey! I posted the idea about shorting bitcoin ages ago here... Got shot down in flames by the usual douchbags. Its still a great idea.

@dust Borrowers get Forced executed and this action do show up on the public log
https://bitfinex.com/pages/public_log

No risk meaning it's not like btcjam where the borrower can just decide not to pay back. Bitfinex will liquidate your margin position before you go negative. So borrowers don't have the option of not paying back their loans.

Of course the risk exists that the operators of the service are scammers or they get hacked. But that's a much lower risk than typical bitcoin loan arrangements where the guy you loan to just decides not to pay back.

I lend on bitfinex, btw.

You can also try 1broker.com if you want to go short.

I'm not sure what your definition of "no risk" is. 

I second this recommendation.  Bitfinex is very useful (allows shorting, margin trading, and no risk loaning).

Use Bitfinex.com. I've been trying them out recently, and I was able to get execute shorts flawlessly.

Sounds like a bucket shop to me. See bitcoinica.