If the mining process was not incentivized not many would get into it - that's just human nature. ASIC development takes millions of dollars of investment into research and prototyping, that too for a specific application. To make that back and more, there should be sufficient interest in such a product. In the absence of a payout for mining, you can assume what the approach of hardcore supporters of a cryptocurrency would be to a highly priced, resource intensive piece of equipment, that has no other purpose than to mine a single coin/algo. Not that in such a scenario, any manufacturer would bother producing an ASIC, but miners would prefer the multi purpose GPUs/CPUs that has many other applications in real life. Moreover, it is made by mostly neutral parties, serving majority of other purposes, and is affordably spread between the common populace. The severe limitations current ASIC manufacturers put in place, like minimum order quality, shipping restrictions and payment methods, limit who can receive the product, i.e., the rich and influential few. This just beats the purpose of true decentralization and a fair distribution of power.
There are benefits of ASICs, definitely, but just making the points as to why some oppose it.
Topic: If ASIC miner is more efficient in power than GPU, then why the ASIC-resistance? - page 2. (Read 438 times)
February 10, 2018, 06:32:13 PM
February 10, 2018, 06:10:23 PM
Gpu's are sold and serviced by real companies with real warranties.
Many asic are pre order
Many asic have 90 day warranty that are next to worthless.
I can make a certain profit with gpu's 100% certain.
I can not do this with asics.
Build a solar array make sure you are in a grid tie back state that buys your power.
say you do 100k-watt build on about ¾ acre of land in New Jersey that translates to a constant 24/7/365 supply of 20kwatts.
i.e. free power up to 20kwatts.
If I fill a shed with gpu rigs from evga I get 3 year good warranties and have zero power cost.
if I fill a shed with asics I get 90 day shit warranties and have zero power cost.
why do I want asics? I don't
now not every one can do solar but frankly I don't care much for asics due to bullshit service and bullshit warranties. and pre orders.
If I could get asics at decent prices with decent service I would have an interest increase in them. until the companies learn to behave like real companies I will be more with gpus.
Many asic are pre order
Many asic have 90 day warranty that are next to worthless.
I can make a certain profit with gpu's 100% certain.
I can not do this with asics.
Build a solar array make sure you are in a grid tie back state that buys your power.
say you do 100k-watt build on about ¾ acre of land in New Jersey that translates to a constant 24/7/365 supply of 20kwatts.
i.e. free power up to 20kwatts.
If I fill a shed with gpu rigs from evga I get 3 year good warranties and have zero power cost.
if I fill a shed with asics I get 90 day shit warranties and have zero power cost.
why do I want asics? I don't
now not every one can do solar but frankly I don't care much for asics due to bullshit service and bullshit warranties. and pre orders.
If I could get asics at decent prices with decent service I would have an interest increase in them. until the companies learn to behave like real companies I will be more with gpus.
Ok you coming from the profit angle, so why then people hate ASICs? if you are more profitable than them then why not be confident to compete?
So why then is the need for the ASIC-resistance cult?
February 10, 2018, 06:09:02 PM
all of the above what has been stated. And I would not recommend to put one in your living room, they make a hell of noise.
For crying out loud, stop mining in your house, and if you do please dont complain about anything
Does Bitmain tell employees to mine at their houses? They invested in huge datacenters and mined there
First it is not healthy mining in your homes and now you want to use noise excuse?
Well mining rigs do n ot belong in the house to begin with..does you house have fire hazard protection and all the datacenter safety features?
I hope you get safe and nothing bad happens because many people just feel the need to mine at home and yet want to compare themselves to bitmain
February 10, 2018, 06:05:50 PM
I have seen how the mining community has been hating on the ASIC miner existence
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology...
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology...
Your argument is based on a faulty premise: ASICs are not "better technology," they are merely highly-optimized to perform one specific computational task. Furthermore, they have very short profitability lifespans - sometimes measured in weeks - after which they become "obsolete technology" which can't be used for anything else because "highly-optimized for one specific task" again.
This also applies to their supposed energy efficiency: the energy cost per unit of computation remains the same even as their profitability declines until they actually cost more to operate than they can generate.
No am not wrong
Tell me what tool is do-it-all, i mean don't even get me started
The point am trying to make is if i make ASIC for x algorithm and it is 100x or 1000x better than your GPU, with less power efficiency with what it puts out, so GPU is better technology for that algo?
You guys are too hell net on the profit, lets remove profit out of this, we all care about the blockchain don't we? so why not look at it like having the ASIC mining helps to speed up transactions and help the cyrpto ecosystem with LES POWER consumption
How about you think of it like that?
February 10, 2018, 06:02:43 PM
People hate ASICs because often the that companies make them mine with them first, then sell them when the person will barely make ROI. This was a few years ago, not sure if it's still going on. But regardless, the machine becomes useless with no resale value because of increased difficulty. With GPUs there are more algos, more coins, and easy resale, they are much more versatile.
It also puts GPU miners in a difficult position.
They are also obnoxiously loud. If you have a dedicated mining room that is fine. But a lot of people use their houses, bedrooms, etc.
A good time when ASICs make sense if is you are going to save your BTC long term and you aren't look at ROI or resale, whether you are mining BTC directly or Altcoins and trading for BTC. Although they are also useful in Altcoins too if you can get them fast, then you can make a bunch for short time.
It also puts GPU miners in a difficult position.
They are also obnoxiously loud. If you have a dedicated mining room that is fine. But a lot of people use their houses, bedrooms, etc.
A good time when ASICs make sense if is you are going to save your BTC long term and you aren't look at ROI or resale, whether you are mining BTC directly or Altcoins and trading for BTC. Although they are also useful in Altcoins too if you can get them fast, then you can make a bunch for short time.
So do you prefer they just innovate and keep the innovation to themselves and not sell?
Will you prefer that instead?
February 10, 2018, 05:41:09 PM
Gpu's are sold and serviced by real companies with real warranties.
Many asic are pre order
Many asic have 90 day warranty that are next to worthless.
I can make a certain profit with gpu's 100% certain.
I can not do this with asics.
Build a solar array make sure you are in a grid tie back state that buys your power.
say you do 100k-watt build on about ¾ acre of land in New Jersey that translates to a constant 24/7/365 supply of 20kwatts.
i.e. free power up to 20kwatts.
If I fill a shed with gpu rigs from evga I get 3 year good warranties and have zero power cost.
if I fill a shed with asics I get 90 day shit warranties and have zero power cost.
why do I want asics? I don't
now not every one can do solar but frankly I don't care much for asics due to bullshit service and bullshit warranties. and pre orders.
If I could get asics at decent prices with decent service I would have an interest increase in them. until the companies learn to behave like real companies I will be more with gpus.
Many asic are pre order
Many asic have 90 day warranty that are next to worthless.
I can make a certain profit with gpu's 100% certain.
I can not do this with asics.
Build a solar array make sure you are in a grid tie back state that buys your power.
say you do 100k-watt build on about ¾ acre of land in New Jersey that translates to a constant 24/7/365 supply of 20kwatts.
i.e. free power up to 20kwatts.
If I fill a shed with gpu rigs from evga I get 3 year good warranties and have zero power cost.
if I fill a shed with asics I get 90 day shit warranties and have zero power cost.
why do I want asics? I don't
now not every one can do solar but frankly I don't care much for asics due to bullshit service and bullshit warranties. and pre orders.
If I could get asics at decent prices with decent service I would have an interest increase in them. until the companies learn to behave like real companies I will be more with gpus.
February 10, 2018, 05:37:34 PM
If you're the first to develop the ASIC, you can grab a huge chunk of the market in a short amount of time. Look at SIA for example, the devs were going to bring out their own ASIC miners. BitMain beat them to it and within a month the difficulty went up 100x, effectively knocking out the GPU miners.
February 10, 2018, 04:48:19 PM
all of the above what has been stated. And I would not recommend to put one in your living room, they make a hell of noise.
February 10, 2018, 04:39:38 PM
I have seen how the mining community has been hating on the ASIC miner existence
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology
Lets remove the Bitmain issue out of this (another post for another day)
This is basically discussion on why are there coins claiming to be ASIC-resistant aka (we dont want better technology and want to burn more and more electricity using GPU)
So if you are an ASIC-resistant dev of NeoScrypt dev for example
Please join me on this dicsussion
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology
Lets remove the Bitmain issue out of this (another post for another day)
This is basically discussion on why are there coins claiming to be ASIC-resistant aka (we dont want better technology and want to burn more and more electricity using GPU)
So if you are an ASIC-resistant dev of NeoScrypt dev for example
Please join me on this dicsussion
Pretty much what MagicSmoke said. ASIC doesn't make sense. If there is a way to do mining with hardware commonly available to many, this would be the ideal from a number of angles:
* Decentralization
* Adoption
* Spread
* Reusability
Creating a device, shipping it across to the other sider of the world, only to be used for a couple of months, and then end up on the scrap yard is just a waste of resources.
February 10, 2018, 04:22:48 PM
I have seen how the mining community has been hating on the ASIC miner existence
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology...
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology...
Your argument is based on a faulty premise: ASICs are not "better technology," they are merely highly-optimized to perform one specific computational task. Furthermore, they have very short profitability lifespans - sometimes measured in weeks - after which they become "obsolete technology" which can't be used for anything else because "highly-optimized for one specific task" again.
This also applies to their supposed energy efficiency: the energy cost per unit of computation remains the same even as their profitability declines until they actually cost more to operate than they can generate.
February 10, 2018, 03:48:46 PM
People hate ASICs because often the that companies make them mine with them first, then sell them when the person will barely make ROI. This was a few years ago, not sure if it's still going on. But regardless, the machine becomes useless with no resale value because of increased difficulty. With GPUs there are more algos, more coins, and easy resale, they are much more versatile.
It also puts GPU miners in a difficult position.
They are also obnoxiously loud. If you have a dedicated mining room that is fine. But a lot of people use their houses, bedrooms, etc.
A good time when ASICs make sense if is you are going to save your BTC long term and you aren't look at ROI or resale, whether you are mining BTC directly or Altcoins and trading for BTC. Although they are also useful in Altcoins too if you can get them fast, then you can make a bunch for short time.
It also puts GPU miners in a difficult position.
They are also obnoxiously loud. If you have a dedicated mining room that is fine. But a lot of people use their houses, bedrooms, etc.
A good time when ASICs make sense if is you are going to save your BTC long term and you aren't look at ROI or resale, whether you are mining BTC directly or Altcoins and trading for BTC. Although they are also useful in Altcoins too if you can get them fast, then you can make a bunch for short time.
February 10, 2018, 03:48:13 PM
gpu miners hate asic because if an asic for a certain algo/coin gets released u can only mine it with asic and gpu miners are instant out of the game
see what happened to siacoin now
another thing is many asic miners are only profitable if you get them very early, once the whole batch is on the market difficulty goes moon, see L3+, D3(heater) or A3 depending on electricity price its not more profitable or profitiability going to hell like with siacoin
some asic company only sell in big batches, so only whales can effort it
i hate this asic shit too, because a small amount of people can destroy the possibility of mining for a certain coin/algo for the majority of miners
see what happened to siacoin now
another thing is many asic miners are only profitable if you get them very early, once the whole batch is on the market difficulty goes moon, see L3+, D3(heater) or A3 depending on electricity price its not more profitable or profitiability going to hell like with siacoin
some asic company only sell in big batches, so only whales can effort it
i hate this asic shit too, because a small amount of people can destroy the possibility of mining for a certain coin/algo for the majority of miners
February 10, 2018, 03:28:22 PM
I have seen how the mining community has been hating on the ASIC miner existence
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology
Lets remove the Bitmain issue out of this (another post for another day)
This is basically discussion on why are there coins claiming to be ASIC-resistant aka (we dont want better technology and want to burn more and more electricity using GPU)
So if you are an ASIC-resistant dev of NeoScrypt dev for example
Please join me on this dicsussion
Their excuse is that it is not fair to the guys using GPU
So when did we as humans become resistant to better technology?
GPU drinks lots of power compared to what it is chunking out and ASIC is hundred and thousand folds more efficient and yet people are opposed to the technology
Lets remove the Bitmain issue out of this (another post for another day)
This is basically discussion on why are there coins claiming to be ASIC-resistant aka (we dont want better technology and want to burn more and more electricity using GPU)
So if you are an ASIC-resistant dev of NeoScrypt dev for example
Please join me on this dicsussion
Jump to: