Topic: If The Bankers Wanted To Destroy Bitcoin They Only Have To Do This One Thing... - page 2. (Read 1280 times)

Miners don't set the price (exchange rate) for Bitcoin. It's really the other way around: The Bitcoin price determines the number of miners.

It is not as simple as that fortunately.

This would never work, it would be the ultimate betrayal. I think if the core devs sell themselves at that level ruining Bitcoin, they would be at danger by some mad cryproanarchists , don't wanna piss them off.
In any case, I think someone would start a fork to try to counteract that.

In fact, it might be even good to reduce the supply making Bitcoin more scarce. At least for those who are holding them

op, I agree but I think no one would agree to changing supply.  if some people did, it would necessarily be a fork and the inflation coin would lose.  it's such a core part of Bitcoin that I think you don't have to worry.

Core Devs, among many other people, have a lot to lose if Bitcoin starts going in a different direction. That's why we have all this friction regarding block size changes. Devs are afraid that the core essence of Bitcoin is changed and this whole thing fails. I don't see them being easily manipulated.

Even if they were manipulated, some of them might resist, and if all of them were manipulated, they would probably be forking to a government run chain, used by nobody

I'm sure your right about having good people. But it is fair if they want to lobby the bitcoin using public to go with a fork. That gives them no more control than you have, and you have convinced me not to increase the total. So you won and they have already lost. Good job!
 

As long as there is bitcoin, there will be miners. profitable or not.  When their multi million dollar mining farm become un-profitable, and the hash rate drops it will be time again for me and many other to fire up some miners.

They are historically masters at persuasion when it comes to things like this. REmember they employ the most persuasive team of lobbyists in the world and they also own the press and the media….

Miners are only part of the equation. Not everything turns around them... If they get too little reward, hashrate will drop and mining will become more profitable again. It will be self sustaining..

I agree not to increase the cap though, that would be bad.

So all they have to do is convince all of us to change the protocol? Sounds fair to me. There is more chance of the Sun exploding tomorrow than convincing me.

All they would have to do is persuade the Core Developers, The Miners, and the general Bitcoin Users that increasing the 21 million Bitcoin cap is a good thing and perhaps the only solution to some problem.

The only argument I ever hear for increasing the cap (and I hear it far to often!) is that mining bitcoin will not be profitable enough for the miners to continue to do it, therefore we should increase the 21 million cap so we can pay the miners more. THIS IS A HORRIBLE ARGUMENT!!!!

It is a matter of basic supply vs demand. If the supply of bitcoin is less than the demand, the price of bitcoin must necessarily go up. So after a halving and the supply of bitcoin is contained, miners selling bitcoin will be asking for higher prices to keep their profits up, and the supply being so low, buyers will have no choice but to pay the higher price for bitcoin if they want some. So miners will remain profitable because the market will correct itself to make the lower amount of bitcoin still profitable for the miners by becoming more expensive.

The more bitcoins there are, the less valuable the become. If you increase the supply of bitcoin, the price of bitcoin goes down! Now who here wants to see the price of bitcoin going down?? If you want a inflationary currency just stick with the us dollar, they print that by the trillions! If you want the bitcoin price to go up, then the 21 million cap must remain!

If the argument is that mining will no longer be profitable, that is the worst argument ever. If the demand for bitcoin remains at least what is today, then the price will go up when the supply is decreased and the miners will remain profitable. IF the demand increases, even more so. That is the design that satoshi nakamot implemented into bitcoin and we should stick to it.

If the demand is not enough to justify a price that makes mining profitable, then the miners can mine for other crypto currencies and the remaining miners would get a higher percentage of the rewards.

We must NEVER let anyone convince us to change the 21 million limit! If we do that, we remove the TRUST in bit coin's limited supply. ONce you change the limit once, you can change again and again and again and people will see it as just another fiat with an unlimited supply. All trust will be lost, the masses with shout SCAM! and I for one will selloff all my bitcoins and move into another crypto currency that I can trust will not inflate.

The bankers may very well try something like this. So we must be on our guard!