Pages:
Author

Topic: Iran hangs billionaire over bank fraud (Read 1937 times)

legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
May 27, 2014, 01:16:28 AM
#44
In the USA white collar cases are also prosecuted, even big ones. Just remember Enron or Madoff.

Such instances are rare. Did the Americans prosecuted any of the bankers (JPM, Goldman Sachs.etc) for the economic collapse in 2008? Enron and Madoff were small fish.
legendary
Activity: 1455
Merit: 1033
Nothing like healthy scepticism and hard evidence
In the USA white collar cases are also prosecuted, even big ones. Just remember Enron or Madoff.
legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
Mahafarid Amir Khosravi was just unlucky. He should have fled to some Western country such as Canada or the US, where the white collar crimes are not prosecuted. (The main accused in this case, Mahmoud Reza Khavari is currently hiding in Canada).
legendary
Activity: 4690
Merit: 1276
I'm afraid I have no strong hopes on the value of technology to avoid the condemnation of innocents, at least current technology.

I am talking about examples such as these:

1. A person caught in video camera committing a crime such as murder or robbery.
2. A person proved to be involved in rape, from the DNA evidence.
3. A person proved to be involved in crimes such as extortion, as evident from telephone conversations.

In these cases, the judge can be 100% sure about the involvement of the alleged perpetrator in the crime.


One cannot be sure as long as there is the potential for evidence tampering and other sorts of malfeasance.  We know that our justice system has some deficiencies by virtue of the fact that different people from different socioeconomic strata get different results among other issues.  Once that issue is squared away I'll personally re-visit my support of capital punishment (in practice...in theory I've got no real problem with it.)  The thing about capital punishment is that it's permanent and so the machinery needs to be working with extreme precision.

On the other hand, absent a functional capital punishment framework it's more possible that law enforcement will be more incline to play a bigger role than it is supposed to (judge, jury, executioner) and we'll see even more problems in this respect.  Already it does seem like there is more police brutality, and I sometimes wonder if it is not becoming something of a policy which is informally filtering downward.  If we have another economic issue the cops are going to need every advantage they can get, and having the population being terrified of them is a very effective force multiplier.  That's what many countries to do mitigate the numbers issue.

legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
I'm afraid I have no strong hopes on the value of technology to avoid the condemnation of innocents, at least current technology.

I am talking about examples such as these:

1. A person caught in video camera committing a crime such as murder or robbery.
2. A person proved to be involved in rape, from the DNA evidence.
3. A person proved to be involved in crimes such as extortion, as evident from telephone conversations.

In these cases, the judge can be 100% sure about the involvement of the alleged perpetrator in the crime.
legendary
Activity: 1455
Merit: 1033
Nothing like healthy scepticism and hard evidence
I'm afraid I have no strong hopes on the value of technology to avoid the condemnation of innocents, at least current technology. In many countries, the guilty verdict is pronounced by fellow citizens, a jury. And even if this systems has its merits it can also put the life or liberty of a innocent person on the hands of amateurs that can be easily tricked by a motivated and professional prosecutor.
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 6403
Blackjack.fun
I am surprized that nobody mentions this but in islam (using sharia jurisdiction, as Iran claims to be) it is not possible to get a death sentence because of fraud, highest punishment for this would be cutting his "stealing" hand. Killing someone because he stole something / or fraud was never the case in islamic jurisprudence.

There is no unified Islamic law for punishment for various offences. It varies from place to place, and from sect to sect. Also, the offence can be interpreted in different ways. Some people may interpret it as theft. Some others might interpret it as treason.

I'm not familiar with Shiaa which is Irans way of Islam, but I'm pretty sure that cutting the stealing hand is the most severe form of punishment for theft and embezzlement in Islamic laws (this is a basic I believe) I think he and the guys that had the same sentence were involved in treason or and espionage (this is me speculating) as it seems the guy has companies in NA and stuff, or did something worse that got him the capital sentence

The fraud involved using forged documents to get credit at one of Iran's top financial institutions, Bank Saderat, to purchase assets including state-owned companies like major steel producer Khuzestan Steel Co.

Khosravi's business empire included more than 35 companies from mineral water production to a football club and meat imports from Brazil. According to Iranian media reports, the bank fraud began in 2007.

I doubt he was involved in espionage. They would have mentioned this as anti western propaganda.
hero member
Activity: 588
Merit: 501
I am surprized that nobody mentions this but in islam (using sharia jurisdiction, as Iran claims to be) it is not possible to get a death sentence because of fraud, highest punishment for this would be cutting his "stealing" hand. Killing someone because he stole something / or fraud was never the case in islamic jurisprudence.

There is no unified Islamic law for punishment for various offences. It varies from place to place, and from sect to sect. Also, the offence can be interpreted in different ways. Some people may interpret it as theft. Some others might interpret it as treason.

I'm not familiar with Shiaa which is Irans way of Islam, but I'm pretty sure that cutting the stealing hand is the most severe form of punishment for theft and embezzlement in Islamic laws (this is a basic I believe) I think he and the guys that had the same sentence were involved in treason or and espionage (this is me speculating) as it seems the guy has companies in NA and stuff, or did something worse that got him the capital sentence
legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
These guys have gotten off with a slap on the wrist for decades. The people who were implicated in the 2007-08 recession all got off with no jail time. Sure it is hard to prove, but the government has shown a clear lack of interest in prosecuting the high-level financiers involved...

Exactly. Generally in the Western nations, perpetrators of the white collar crimes are hardly ever brought to justice. Even people who steals billions of USD have in the past escaped with silly sentences.
sr. member
Activity: 280
Merit: 250
Knowledge is Power
I think the level-headed response here is not to praise Iran as the most just nation on Earth. The reason he was hanged was because OTHER powerful people disliked him, not because he broke the law.

But having said that, I would really like to see more serious punishments for these kind of crimes in the Western world, particularly the United States. The shit some of these guys pull causes financial distress for MILLIONS if not billions of people, whereas a murderer may kill a couple people, and he goes jail for a long time.

These guys have gotten off with a slap on the wrist for decades. The people who were implicated in the 2007-08 recession all got off with no jail time. Sure it is hard to prove, but the government has shown a clear lack of interest in prosecuting the high-level financiers involved...
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
I am surprized that nobody mentions this but in islam (using sharia jurisdiction, as Iran claims to be) it is not possible to get a death sentence because of fraud, highest punishment for this would be cutting his "stealing" hand. Killing someone because he stole something / or fraud was never the case in islamic jurisprudence.
In a scale such as this, it can be considered as treason... Treason is punishable by death according to Islamic jurisprudence.
legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
I am surprized that nobody mentions this but in islam (using sharia jurisdiction, as Iran claims to be) it is not possible to get a death sentence because of fraud, highest punishment for this would be cutting his "stealing" hand. Killing someone because he stole something / or fraud was never the case in islamic jurisprudence.

There is no unified Islamic law for punishment for various offences. It varies from place to place, and from sect to sect. Also, the offence can be interpreted in different ways. Some people may interpret it as theft. Some others might interpret it as treason.
sr. member
Activity: 994
Merit: 441
I am surprized that nobody mentions this but in islam (using sharia jurisdiction, as Iran claims to be) it is not possible to get a death sentence because of fraud, highest punishment for this would be cutting his "stealing" hand. Killing someone because he stole something / or fraud was never the case in islamic jurisprudence.
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 6403
Blackjack.fun
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.

Bullshit, there are people out there who genuinely believe a women can't rape a man etc. which means all humans will naturally be biased to a certain viewpoint, none of what you said is true especially since a judge is a human being and is capable of making mistakes and then there's the fact that technology can always be tampered with.

Zimbabwe women accused of raping men 'for rituals'
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-15876968

And article so that nobody contest your first phrase



Did you misread my post? I said they believe it, doesn't mean that it's actually true Tongue

Nope didn't misread it although my reply might seem so.

Just a small example on how this twisted this world is and how you should believe that everything is possible.
And how at first people didn't believe the actual criminals are guilty based only on their misconception , that  "a woman can't rape a man".
 
legendary
Activity: 1540
Merit: 1000
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.

Bullshit, there are people out there who genuinely believe a women can't rape a man etc. which means all humans will naturally be biased to a certain viewpoint, none of what you said is true especially since a judge is a human being and is capable of making mistakes and then there's the fact that technology can always be tampered with.

Zimbabwe women accused of raping men 'for rituals'
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-15876968

And article so that nobody contest your first phrase



Did you misread my post? I said they believe it, doesn't mean that it's actually true Tongue
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
http://www.haaretz.com/news/middle-east/1.592510

i don't know if i quite believe in capital punishment, but it's at least nice to for once see a wealthy person live by the same rule of law as the commonfolk.


This is a very severe punishment for fraud. Normally only the worst gays and apostates would be given such a harsh punishment!
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 6403
Blackjack.fun
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.

Bullshit, there are people out there who genuinely believe a women can't rape a man etc. which means all humans will naturally be biased to a certain viewpoint, none of what you said is true especially since a judge is a human being and is capable of making mistakes and then there's the fact that technology can always be tampered with.

Zimbabwe women accused of raping men 'for rituals'
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-15876968

And article so that nobody contest your first phrase

legendary
Activity: 1540
Merit: 1000
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.

Bullshit, there are people out there who genuinely believe a women can't rape a man etc. which means all humans will naturally be biased to a certain viewpoint, none of what you said is true especially since a judge is a human being and is capable of making mistakes and then there's the fact that technology can always be tampered with.
legendary
Activity: 2912
Merit: 6403
Blackjack.fun
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.

How can be one judge 100% sure of the verdict?
Is he god to know that everything that was said is the true and the proof have not been altered by somebody else?
As for the advancement of technology , this could be applied to the western Europe and US&CA but not for the rest of the countries.

I wonder if police officers in central Africa even take fingerprints in those cases.

legendary
Activity: 3752
Merit: 1217
I pose the same question when it comes to the death penalty that I pose to people who believe in god, what if you're wrong?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_exonerated_death_row_inmates

No, I don't believe in the death penalty, no matter the crime, I've had this argument with people before, it amazes me the lengths people will go to justify to themselves and others killing an unarmed person, it also amazes me how like the U.S Iran is but you will find all sorts of people ready to jump to the defence of the U.S when they do something wrong.

No one is sentenced to death, unless the judge is 100% sure about his crime. In the past mistakes might have happened. But with the advancement of technology, right now it is impossible to blame an innocent person for heinous crimes such as murder and rape.
Pages:
Jump to: