Israel calculates a daily allowed caloric intake for Palestinians. - page 2.

hashman

legendary

Activity: 1264

Merit: 1008

Quote from: Charlie Prime on September 21, 2012, 08:45:01 AM

Maybe they're sick of the vicious on-line arguments with apoplectic Israeli nationalists? And maybe the media makes it worse by suppressing these hideous crimes against humanity?

Both.

It really all boils down to one group of people who believe themselves to be the Master Race.

Animals like you and I do not possess a fully human soul. Our souls are more like those of intelligent animals. That's why it's morally acceptable to predate us.

Nah, nobody really believes that. If you are alive and able to talk or read a few basic symbols, you are too smart to really believe that 1) separate bloodlines exist (obviously they don't) or that 2) it would make any difference if they did (obviously it doesn't).

However, if you are suffering from one of many very common mental illnesses commonly passed on to children via abuse, you might want to pretend that you believe such bullshit because it lets you 1) continue being unhappy and 2) work to make other people unhappy.

Charlie Prime

sr. member

Activity: 406

Merit: 250

Quote from: ?? on ??

Maybe they're sick of the vicious on-line arguments with apoplectic Israeli nationalists? And maybe the media makes it worse by suppressing these hideous crimes against humanity?

Both.

It really all boils down to one group of people who believe themselves to be the Master Race.

Animals like you and I do not possess a fully human soul. Our souls are more like those of intelligent animals. That's why it's morally acceptable to predate us.

vampire

hero member

Activity: 574

Merit: 500

The article is a load of BS. The numbers are taken out of their asses. But let's not forget that today there are no restrictions on food.

US government calculates a daily calorie intake too... It's on every on box.

How many Palestinians died from hunger?

/crickets

Now read on:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunger_Plan

knight22

legendary

Activity: 1372

Merit: 1000

--------------->¿?

Quote from: ?? on ??

OMFG! What a bunch of Nazis! Shocked

Why is America allied with these bastards? Angry

Because America is a bunch of Nazis too!

Atlas

jr. member

Activity: 56

Merit: 1

http://www.hybridstates.com/2010/05/food-consumption-under-satans-administration-and-israeli-siege/

Nutritional planning in Gaza

What about Gaza? After an Israeli NGO named Gisha sued the Israeli government under freedom of information legislation in order to find out exactly what is allowed for import into Gaza, and why, we now have a much better picture of Israeli siege planning. In particular, the court case surfaced four documents that describe the details of Israel’s siege, which is considered a “central pillar in the means at the disposal of the State of Israel in the armed conflict between it and Hamas.” The documents lay out details about how goods requests are processed, how shortages in Gaza are monitored, and the list of approved goods.

The fourth document, of primary importance here, is titled “Food Consumption in the Gaza Strip – Red Lines,” and it establishes what Israel considers to be the minimum caloric intake needed Gaza’s 1.5 million inhabitants, according to their age and sex. Thus, Israeli planners have given careful consideration to the minimum amount of calories to be allowed in to Gaza to simultaneously serve as a weapon against Hamas, to attain Netanyahu’s strategy of “no prosperity, no development, no humanitarian crisis” but still ensure the Palestinians get on a diet, in Dov Weisglass’ “joking” words (“It’s like a meeting with a dietitian. We need to make the Palestinians lose weight, but not to starve to death.”).

The Israeli government argued in the court case that releasing the specific numbers of calories, and the goods lists (which include terrorist goods like coriander, crayons, and pasta), would damage national security, so we do not know the exact numbers for comparative purposes.

What we do know comes from two main sources. The first, the Gaza Gateway project, charts goods entering versus goods needed; typically allowances comprise between 25% and 33% of estimated daily need for Gaza’s 1.5 million residents. We also know from the IDF spokesperson (via the IDF Twitter feed: @IDFSpokesperson) the daily amount of goods they allow into Gaza. Let’s take yesterday to be our random day. According to the IDF tweet, 109 truckloads were allowed to enter (this is very, very close to the mean over all days, and is thus representative of average daily allowances) with 1,853 tons of humanitarian aid.

Now, how to compare? Well, let’s be as generous as possible to the IDF. Let’s assume all these tons of aid have no packaging and so every single gram aid has caloric value (to humans); this is, of course, an absurdly strong assumption that works in the favor of the IDF’s “benevolence.” Under this assumption, then, the IDF yesterday let in almost 2 billion grams of food—1,681,000,000 grams to be exact. For every individual in Gaza, therefore, the IDF allowed in about 1,120 grams of food.

Of course, our assumptions were stringent and unrealistic, so the real quantity of food is probably very much lower. We know from an IMF study that “75 percent of the population has been forced to reduce the quantity of food they buy, while 89 percent reduced the quality.“ But we cannot calculate calories because Israel won’t tell us what it allows in. Making these numbers even more unrealistic is the fact that this humanitarian aid includes shelters (from international agencies, foreign governments, and NGOs) and other non-edible items; this also means the amount of food is lower. If we assume that only one quarter of the humanitarian aid is non-edible, then we are left with something like 840 grams of food per person in Gaza. This is a reasonable upper bound on possible, per-capita nutritional allowances for Gaza.

This (admittedly rough) estimate suggests that Israel allows Gazans to consume (at most) about 40% more grams of food than the Nazis did their Auschwitz laborers. So generous!

The lavish humanitarianism illustrated by Israel’s Gaza policy is the final, definitive proof that critics of the Gaza siege are anti-Semites, as far as I am concerned. Israel’s siege differs from Auschwitz’s nutritional policy by 40%! Time for the critics to shut their mouths.

Or not. As long as you have scientists and military officials sit down to determine the lowest possible caloric intake you can provide to an imprisoned population, and then write policy documents explaining your methods, you are culpable for such comparisons, hyperbolic or not.

Topic: Israel calculates a daily allowed caloric intake for Palestinians. - page 2. (Read 2015 times)