As I understand it, the FFP created a need for clubs to look for ways to get around it and this led to "small" financial manipulations. But if from the point of view of sports these are "little tricks", then for the prosecutor's office/tax authorities these are financial crimes.
I wonder how many clubs are involved in this (I think all of them) and will they all be caught? After all, if you remove 15 points from all clubs, then in the end no one will notice the difference
This is a good analysis by you. "The FFP created a need", sure, every law creates a need to get around it if the person feels the need to get around it.
If I feel the need to evade tax (lol), the law is to blame that forces me to pay tax. Poor soccer clubs that rules exist, they all have a need to get around those rules.
Well, if I am not ok with the speed on the highways, I can take a plane. But the difference is that the plane is legal. I have no idea what's going on now but I believe that a lot of clubs are hiding a lot of legally relevant information. It's not even surprising, is it?
When you read the numbers what Mbappe and Neymar cost in transfer fees, salaries and these outrageous bounties for giving their signature? It can't be compliant with FFP. There is no way.The thing is I don't know how quick they are and whether clubs get removed from competitions retrospectively if according to the rules they shouldn't have qualified for the European tournaments. But that would destroy the competition if it is already running. Here in Italy now if the three clubs concerned would lose 15 points, that would change a whole lot. Just check the table!
But generally you are right, the question is who is not to blame, and how much sense does a 15 point deduction then even make? Also, if all receive the same financial penalty, a poor club suffers even harder than a rich club, leaving the rich club with sufficient room to go while the poor club might collapse. Penalties somehow need to be individual.
The nuance is that PSG is a political project and the French prosecutor/tax police are not very (for some reason
) interested in the machinations of this club. A similar picture with City, this is the most notorious fraudulent club, but for some reason they are not prosecuted by the authorities, and the League has little power, so the attempt to punish City (from Leage side) has been going on for many years.
And standing aside from all this is UEFA/FIFA, which cover up obvious scammers (PSG, City) but attack their enemies (the organizers of the Super League - Juventus, Real and Barcelona) using any pretexts and reasons. As I understand it, Juventus and Barcelona have already been dealt with, and the next victim is Real Madrid.
Such selective "justice" is itself a fraud because the law should be the same for all.
In general, clubs find themselves between two fires - on the one hand, UEFA/FIFA allow "friendly" clubs to cheat, so all clubs are forced to do this too (to one degree or another) in order to keep up with competitors. On the other hand, sometimes there are problems with the authorities, and here the Federations (the same bastards UEFA/FIFA officials) also impose sports sanctions on the clubs. Very comfortably.