You have done a great job SatoPrincess, It's good to see that suggestions are assembled in a single thread but I think there are even more in New Forum software that are yet to be implemented and many abandoned, I have some good suggestions to share but seeing how the development slowed is killing the morals.
My first post on that list was created on 2022 and not 2017, please check again.
Topic: List of Meta suggestions for Bitcointalk Improvement (Read 388 times)
Why did you not separate topic list into some categories?
I did not check all topics in your list but it seems there are few categories that can be used: Merit (not surprised why it is hottest
); trust/ feedback system; new boards; new moderators; new features; etc.
Quote locked threads, 120-day merit total, custom themes, and other good stuff. Link for people who have yet known about this one.
I did not check all topics in your list but it seems there are few categories that can be used: Merit (not surprised why it is hottest
); trust/ feedback system; new boards; new moderators; new features; etc.The down side is that you need to have the browser add-on installed to get this and other benefits so it won't work for the newbies, as I initially thought.
Quote locked threads, 120-day merit total, custom themes, and other good stuff. Link for people who have yet known about this one.
Can we have merits reconsideration on banned accounts[/i]? Allowing merits to be returned to their source after an account has been banned? This is one of the changes I'd like to see on the new forum.
I don't think it's needed. If something like that was to be applied, it should only happen to merits given to users who got nuked. Nuked means 0 posts, hence there is nothing to merit. But if someone were to be banned and their post history is still publicly available, their merits shouldn't be removed. The fact they got banned, doesn't mean they didn't have quality and merit-worthy posts at some point in time. It's the same thing with scammers and other jerkoffs. They could have been quality members with good forum contributions who one day turned bad and got banned for whatever reason. But their merit-worthy posts are still there. 
Oh I see my name there too. My suggestion got partly fixed by BPIP team and now my More menu looks like this:
The down side is that you need to have the browser add-on installed to get this and other benefits so it won't work for the newbies, as I initially thought.
BTW it will be nice if I can add/remove links to that menu manually in BPIP. Just an idea
The down side is that you need to have the browser add-on installed to get this and other benefits so it won't work for the newbies, as I initially thought.
BTW it will be nice if I can add/remove links to that menu manually in BPIP. Just an idea
OP, let me make the list of threads you attached more organized than you have. This might not be my best try, but that's okay because it will make it easier for people to read. Apart from that, I've also added some threads suggested by The Pharmacist in the last post. So, hope this is good for your topic. 
Release Date
OP, I've been around long enough to tell you that the number of threads you summarized and linked to would, if graphed on a pie chart as a fraction of the total number of suggestion threads, look like a sillhouette of Pac-Man with his mouth completely shut. But I applaud your effort, because I'm sure it took a lot of time and effort to dig all of those up.
And maaan, you missed my three suggestion threads. I don't tend to start a lot of new threads in general, so when I create one that requests some new feature or some sort of change in whatever, you know I have strong feelings about the issue in question. Among the bugaboos that have hit my berzerk button have been "list" threads, PMs from Copper Member newbies, and members consistently posting enormous images in their posts that add no value to what the topic is. I love the thread about ending the merit system--it really takes me back down memory lane, because I remember how frustrated a lot of members were when they suddenly couldn't rank up nearly as quickly as they were accustomed to. Those were fun, lively times. Is there a plan to have a new forum? If yes, why? Not just a plan, the project was already set in motion, the name of the new forum was decided and funds allocated to it about 11 years ago, when theymos created a thread looking for a software developer .The beta for the new forum software was actually launched for testing. The project is long overdue and there is some uncertainty about when it would be ready. What will happen to this forum we are using and its features. Will it be the changing of everything in the forum or will it be an update to the existing features in the forum or is it going to be only domain name change. But I like this forum as I have seen it. Although I have not been in other big forums I don't know how they look like. But I like this forum and the way it is designed to easily find any board you wish. The data on the forum would be migrated to the new software.And most of the forum features and layout would be the same, but where would be some major updates to it. I believe some of these suggestions would be implemented on the new forum; these ideas should be moved to the "New forum software" subboard for further discussion because I don't see why they should be implemented on this old forum while we wait for the new one. Is there a plan to have a new forum? If yes, why?What will happen to this forum we are using and its features. Will it be the changing of everything in the forum or will it be an update to the existing features in the forum or is it going to be only domain name change. But I like this forum as I have seen it. Although I have not been in other big forums I don't know how they look like. But I like this forum and the way it is designed to easily find any board you wish. I think Theymos is adding the suggestions on meta to the new software maybe that’s why he doesn’t bother about making changes to this one. I researched about some users who had donators on their profile. Old members know the history. I’m curious if there is actually going to be a new forum Where's the new forum Theymos? I believe some of these suggestions would be implemented on the new forum; these ideas should be moved to the "New forum software" subboard for further discussion because I don't see why they should be implemented on this old forum while we wait for the new one. Is there a plan to have a new forum? If yes, why?What will happen to this forum we are using and its features. Will it be the changing of everything in the forum or will it be an update to the existing features in the forum or is it going to be only domain name change. But I like this forum as I have seen it. Although I have not been in other big forums I don't know how they look like. But I like this forum and the way it is designed to easily find any board you wish.
I believe some of these suggestions would be implemented on the new forum; these ideas should be moved to the "New forum software" subboard for further discussion because I don't see why they should be implemented on this old forum while we wait for the new one.
And as for the Like and Dislike buttons, it would cause a lot of problems if a post received a lot of likes but had no merits, and verse versa, a lot of trolls would abuse the Like/dislike button. As for the decay of smerits, I don't see it happening; it's been discussed a thousand times for no good reason. Can we have merits reconsideration on banned accounts? Allowing merits to be returned to their source after an account has been banned? This is one of the changes I'd like to see on the new forum. I think the liking a post has already been implemented with the merit system? Hmmm, very loosely you could probably argue that. I don't tend to think of the merit system as a ways of liking someones post though. Rather, using it as a way of rewarding effort, and good quality content. Though, usually that does mean you have to sort of like the post to an extent, I don't think that should be the primary focus. Although, I'm probably against the idea of a liking system, think our modern world has more than enough of it with social media these days.
I think you have missed one of the most frequent requests - Bitcointalk app for phone. It's been asked for so many times already.
Anyway, I think it's not likely that newbies (or not newbies) will stop repeatingold suggestions after seing this thread. If they don't use search before new thread, they won't notice this thread too.
Quite a lot of users overlook the search button, if it definitely wasn't useful, then it wouldn't have been there in the first place, if forum users use the search button more frequently, then many threads will not be repeated.
Good topic, but i do not know if it will be useful in the long run when this thread leaves the first 3 or so pages, users would still repeat such threads again, so what is most important is that users should make use of the search button first before starting a thread, only then will they find already existing threads on the topics/suggestion they want to make, and compilations of already existing threads like the OP.
I think the liking a post has already been implemented with the merit system?
There's a lot of topics on smerit that could probably all be made into one sentence with the different ideas but I don't think decaying smerit is going to help with anything - and if Theymos wanted to, they could increase the merits being sent to sources or recruit more sources.
Since there is a possibility of newbies repeating threads that have already been discussed on meta, I decided to make a list of suggestions by forum members over the years. Some have been implemented, others are still unanswered.
|
